The Mechanical Turkness: Tactical Media Art and the Critique of Corporate AI

Dejan Grba
2024-02-27
Abstract:The extensive industrialization of artificial intelligence (AI) since the mid-2010s has increasingly motivated artists to address its economic and sociopolitical consequences. In this chapter, I discuss interrelated art practices that thematize creative agency, crowdsourced labor, and delegated artmaking to reveal the social rootage of AI technologies and underline the productive human roles in their development. I focus on works whose poetic features indicate broader issues of contemporary AI-influenced science, technology, economy, and society. By exploring the conceptual, methodological, and ethical aspects of their effectiveness in disrupting the political regime of corporate AI, I identify several problems that affect their tactical impact and outline potential avenues for tackling the challenges and advancing the field.
Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper discusses the application of artificial intelligence (AI) in the field of art, particularly how tactical media art critically examines the economic and social impact of corporate AI. The author, Dejan Grba, discusses how artists reveal the social roots of AI technology through their creations, emphasizing the productive role humans play in the development of AI and exposing the economic and social consequences of AI capitalism. The paper focuses on creative agents, crowdsourced labor, and commissioned art production, to reveal the human societal foundations of AI technology. The author points out the need for critical discussions as wealth and power become highly concentrated with the industrialization of AI. Artists uncover the ideological and ontological issues of AI through their works. These works are not typically revolutionary but rather micro-political interventions aimed at educating the public and offering new perspectives on power systems. The paper also explores how AI technology intensifies strategies such as quantification, datification, and manipulative decision-making, as well as its role in bias, inequality, and political agendas. Several art practices are mentioned in the paper, such as Adam Basanta's work, which utilizes machine learning to challenge concepts of creative attribution, originality, and intellectual property. Additionally, some artists critique the labor transparency issues in the AI industry by revealing the role of online micro-work platforms like Amazon's Mechanical Turk in AI development. These platforms often obscure the value of human labor while portraying AI as autonomous. Furthermore, the paper mentions works by other artists, such as Mona Hatoum's performance art, and Derek Curry and Jennifer Gradecki's Crowd-Sourced Intelligence Agency, which explore the role of humans in AI decision-making processes and the accuracy and accountability of data processing in different ways. Overall, this paper seeks to address how art practices can critically analyze and reveal the societal, economic, and ethical impact of artificial intelligence and how these artworks can increase public awareness of potential issues with AI technology.