Bringing together two paradigms of non-equilibrium: Fragile versus robust aging in driven glassy systems

Diego Tapias,Charles Marteau,Fabián Aguirre-López,Peter Sollich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.133.197101

2024-11-05

Abstract:There are two key paradigms for non-equilibrium dynamics: on the one hand, aging towards an equilibrium state that cannot be reached on reasonable timescales; on the other, external driving that can lead to non-equilibrium steady states. We explore how these two mechanisms interact, by studying the behaviour of trap models, which are paradigmatic descriptions of slow glassy dynamics, when driven by trajectory bias towards high or low activity. To diagnose whether the driven systems continue to age, we establish a framework for mapping the biased dynamics to a Markovian time evolution with time-dependent transition rates. We find that the original aging dynamics reacts in two qualitatively distinct ways to the driving: it can be destroyed by driving of any nonzero strength (fragile aging), whereby the dynamics either reaches an active steady state or effectively freezes; or it can persist within a finite range of driving strengths around the undriven case (robust aging). This classification into fragile and robust aging could form the basis for distinguishing different universality classes of aging dynamics.

Statistical Mechanics,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore how two non - equilibrium kinetic paradigms interact, especially the phenomena of fragile aging and robust aging in driven glassy systems. Specifically, the paper studies how the aging behavior of these systems changes when the trap model (a typical model for describing slow glassy dynamics) is driven using trajectory biasing (i.e., biasing towards high or low mobility).

### Problems the paper attempts to solve:

1. **Interaction between aging dynamics and external driving**:
- Aging dynamics refers to the fact that a system gradually approaches an equilibrium state that cannot be reached within the actual time scale over a long - time scale.
- External driving is to make the system enter a non - equilibrium steady state by means of mechanical stress, magnetic field, etc.
- The paper attempts to understand how these two mechanisms interact in the same system.

2. **Classification of fragile aging and robust aging**:
- By studying the behavior of the trap model under different driving intensities, the paper finds that aging dynamics can be divided into two categories:
- **Fragile aging**: Any non - zero - intensity driving will disrupt the aging process, causing the system to either enter an active steady state or almost freeze.
- **Robust aging**: Within a certain range of driving intensities, the aging process can still continue.

3. **Mechanism of the effect of driving on aging**:
- To diagnose whether the driven system continues to age, the paper establishes a framework that maps the biased dynamics to Markovian time evolution with time - dependent transition rates.
- By analyzing the dynamic behavior under driving, the paper reveals the response mechanism of the system to driving at different temperatures, especially that the BM model at low temperatures exhibits robust aging behavior.

### Main findings:

- **Bouchaud model**: At any temperature, aging is fragile. Any positive driving will cause the system to freeze, and negative driving will produce an active steady state.
- **BM model**:
- **T > 1/2**: The aging behavior is similar to that of the Bouchaud model, showing fragile aging.
- **T < 1/2**: The aging behavior becomes robust. Even under moderate driving, the system can still continue to age, and its total activity grows logarithmically with time.

### Methodology:

- **Dynamic free energy**: By calculating the dynamic free energy, the paper distinguishes between active and inactive kinetic phases.
- **Auxiliary Markov process**: To study more precisely whether the driven system continues to age, the paper develops a formal method to represent the driving dynamics as an equivalent "auxiliary" Markov process.

### Conclusion:

- This research shows the complex interaction between aging dynamics and external driving and proposes a new classification framework that divides aging dynamics into fragile and robust types.
- This classification is helpful for understanding different types of non - equilibrium systems and may provide new tools and perspectives for future non - equilibrium dynamics research.