Experimental evidence on tonal noise generation and its control in tip-leakage flows

Prateek Jaiswal,Stephane Moreau
2024-03-18
Abstract:The present study is first to provide experimental evidence of tonal noise and acoustic feedback by a stationary airfoil with a tip-gap placed between two side plates. Tones are linked to an aero-acoustic coupling using synchronized measurements between Particle Image Velocimetry and far-field microphone probes. To aid in the correlation analysis, the wall boundary condition on the pressure side of the airfoil was modified by introducing surface roughness. For tip leakage flows without roughness elements, the far-field acoustic spectra show peaks in the acoustic autospectra. These peaks are present regardless of the flow speed studied. The findings reveal that tones associated with tip-gap extend till 16.5 kHz in a low-noise facility. Roughness alters cross-flow velocity along the airfoil chord, influencing acoustics at matched Reynolds and Mach numbers. Roughness induces cancellation of spectral peaks and changes in the velocity and acoustic pressure correlation pattern between airfoil pressure and suction side. Modal shapes confirm the presence of coherent structures in the tip-gap region, with smooth surfaces exhibiting confined flow instabilities and non-dipolar noise sources around and beyond 10 kHz. At these high frequencies, the sound radiation mechanism can be uniquely attributed to neither a jet-like noise source nor these acoustic peaks can be uniquely attributed to coherent structures in the tip-gap region. On the contrary, coherence between airfoil sides is required for noise peaks, which stresses the importance of diffraction on the airfoil pressure side and acoustic feedback.
Fluid Dynamics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on two aspects: 1. **Explore the working frequency range of tip noise**: Researchers hope to determine the frequency ranges in which the noise generated by tip leakage flow works. Previous studies have shown that tip noise mainly works in the range of 0.7 to 10 kHz, but these studies may not have detected higher - frequency noise due to high background noise. Therefore, this study aims to verify through experiments in a low - noise environment whether tip noise can extend to a higher frequency range. 2. **Provide experimental evidence on the origin of peaks or bulges in the acoustic spectrum**: Researchers hope to reveal the specific mechanisms that cause high - amplitude peaks or bulges in the acoustic spectrum through experimental data. The appearance of these peaks or bulges may be due to aero - acoustic coupling, such as the interaction between vortices and the boundary layer, or due to the acoustic feedback phenomenon at specific frequencies. Specifically, researchers hope to verify whether these acoustic peaks can be uniquely attributed to the coherent structures within the tip - gap region, or whether the generation mechanisms of these peaks are more complex. ### Main research methods To achieve the above - mentioned goals, the researchers adopted the following methods: - **Experimental setup**: The experiment was carried out in an anechoic wind tunnel, using a fixed airfoil model with a tip gap. The airfoil model was placed between two side plates to simulate the tip leakage flow in actual turbomachinery. The geometric angle of attack of the airfoil was set to 8° to reflect the flow state under the design condition. - **Synchronous measurement**: Researchers used planar particle image velocimetry (PIV) technology to measure the flow field in the tip - gap region and used a far - field microphone probe to simultaneously record the sound pressure signal. Through synchronous measurement, researchers were able to establish the relationship between flow field characteristics and far - field acoustic response. - **Effect of surface roughness**: To explore the effect of surface roughness on tip noise, researchers added rough strips on the pressure side of the airfoil and compared the changes in flow field and acoustic characteristics with and without rough strips. ### Experimental results - **Flow field characteristics**: The experimental results show that surface roughness significantly changes the lateral velocity distribution along the chord length direction of the airfoil. Specifically, under the rough wall condition, the lateral velocity near the trailing edge of the airfoil decreases, while the lateral velocity at the mid - chord position slightly increases. This indicates that surface roughness causes a secondary flow effect on the pressure side. - **Acoustic characteristics**: Sound pressure level (SPL) measurements show that tip noise dominates in the frequency range above 1 kHz. In particular, for the first time, obvious acoustic peaks were observed in the 20 kHz frequency range in this study, and these peaks were not reported in previous studies. In addition, the experiment also found that these high - frequency peaks disappeared after adding surface roughness, indicating that surface roughness has a significant impact on the generation mechanism of tip noise. - **Coherence analysis**: By calculating the cross - spectral density between mode 8 and the far - field sound pressure, researchers found that under the smooth wall condition, mode 8 does carry information related to the acoustic spectrum peaks. Under the rough wall condition, these peaks disappear, indicating that surface roughness destroys the aero - acoustic coupling. ### Conclusions - **Working frequency range of tip noise**: Tip noise not only exists in the range of 0.7 to 10 kHz, but can also extend to higher frequencies, such as 16.5 kHz or even higher. - **Origin of acoustic peaks**: The generation of acoustic peaks is related to the coherent structures in the tip - gap region, but these structures exhibit non - dipole properties at high frequencies and cannot be fully explained by traditional aero - acoustic models. The introduction of surface roughness can significantly change these structures, thereby affecting the acoustic response. - **Aero - acoustic coupling**: Noise sources at low and medium frequencies have dipole characteristics, while noise sources at high frequencies exhibit non - dipole characteristics, indicating that the generation mechanism of tip noise is different at different frequencies. In general, this study provides new experimental evidence for understanding the noise generated by tip leakage flow, which is helpful for further optimizing the design of turbomachinery and reducing noise pollution.