Deflating the Chinese Balloon: Types of Twitter Bots in US-China balloon incident

Lynnette Hui Xian Ng,Kathleen M. Carley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjds/s13688-023-00440-3

2024-01-11

Abstract:As digitalization increases, countries employ digital diplomacy, harnessing digital resources to project their desired image. Digital diplomacy also encompasses the interactivity of digital platforms, providing a trove of public opinion that diplomatic agents can collect. Social media bots actively participate in political events through influencing political communication and purporting coordinated narratives to influence human behavior. This article provides a methodology towards identifying three types of bots: General Bots, News Bots and Bridging Bots, then further identify these classes of bots on Twitter during a diplomatic incident involving the United States and China. Using a series of computational methods, this article examines the impact of bots on the topics disseminated, the influence and the use of information maneuvers of bots within the social communication network. Among others, our results observe that all three types of bots are present across the two countries; bots geotagged to the US are generally concerned with the balloon location while those geotagged to China discussed topics related to escalating tensions; and perform different extent of positive narrative and network information maneuvers.

Social and Information Networks

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Aims to Address

This paper aims to study how different types of bot accounts participated in political discussions on social media platforms (especially Twitter) during the Sino-American balloon incident in early 2023, and to analyze the role of these bots in digital diplomacy.

#### Research Background and Motivation
The paper points out that in today's increasingly digital world, countries use digital resources to achieve their diplomatic goals and shape their national image through social media. In this context, social media bots play an important role in international relations, especially in influencing public opinion during political events. For example, during the 2016 U.S. presidential election, Russian-controlled bots attempted to create divisions, and during the 2022 Russia-Ukraine war, both countries deployed bots to shape public opinion.

#### Research Subjects
Specifically, the paper focuses on the Sino-American balloon incident that occurred in early 2023. At that time, a high-altitude surveillance balloon believed to be from China appeared in U.S. airspace, causing tensions between the two countries. The paper analyzes three types of bots active on Twitter during this event: General Bots, News Bots, and Bridging Bots, exploring their roles and impacts in the incident.

#### Main Contributions
1. **Digital Public Diplomacy Analysis**: By analyzing inauthentic online interactions, the study examines digital public diplomacy in a diplomatic event involving two world powers.
2. **Bot Type Identification Methods**: Defines and develops methods to identify three key types of Twitter bots.
3. **Bot Activity Analysis**: Studies the performance of different types of bots between China and the U.S. by analyzing themes, networks, and information manipulation techniques in the event discussions.

#### Methodology
1. **Bot Classification**:
- **General Bots**: Identified using general bot detection algorithms such as BotHunter.
- **News Bots**: Identified through substring matching of user profiles containing the word "news" or using machine learning classifiers.
- **Bridging Bots**: Identified through position analysis in social networks using the Louvain clustering algorithm.
2. **Data Analysis**:
- **Social Network Analysis**: Measures network centrality of different bot types to assess their influence.
- **Theme Analysis**: Visualizes text content differences to reveal discussion themes.
- **Information Manipulation Analysis**: Uses the BEND framework to quantify the degree of information manipulation.

Through these methods, the paper reveals how different types of bots participated in political discussions and influenced public opinion in the context of Sino-American relations.