A multidisciplinary framework for deconstructing bots' pluripotency in dualistic antagonism

Wentao Xu,Kazutoshi Sasahara,Jianxun Chu,Bin Wang,Wenlu Fan,Zhiwen Hu

2024-05-11

Abstract:Anthropomorphic social bots are engineered to emulate human verbal communication and generate toxic or inflammatory content across social networking services (SNSs). Bot-disseminated misinformation could subtly yet profoundly reshape societal processes by complexly interweaving factors like repeated disinformation exposure, amplified political polarization, compromised indicators of democratic health, shifted perceptions of national identity, propagation of false social norms, and manipulation of collective memory over time. However, extrapolating bots' pluripotency across hybridized, multilingual, and heterogeneous media ecologies from isolated SNS analyses remains largely unknown, underscoring the need for a comprehensive framework to characterise bots' emergent risks to civic discourse. Here we propose an interdisciplinary framework to characterise bots' pluripotency, incorporating quantification of influence, network dynamics monitoring, and interlingual feature analysis. When applied to the geopolitical discourse around the Russo-Ukrainian conflict, results from interlanguage toxicity profiling and network analysis elucidated spatiotemporal trajectories of pro-Russian and pro-Ukrainian human and bots across hybrid SNSs. Weaponized bots predominantly inhabited X, while human primarily populated Reddit in the social media warfare. This rigorous framework promises to elucidate interlingual homogeneity and heterogeneity in bots' pluripotent behaviours, revealing synergistic human-bot mechanisms underlying regimes of information manipulation, echo chamber formation, and collective memory manifestation in algorithmically structured societies.

Computers and Society,Social and Information Networks

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: How to comprehensively understand the pluripotency of social bots in the dualistic antagonism on social media platforms, especially in the heterogeneous media ecology between different languages and platforms. Specifically, the paper aims to:

1. **Propose an interdisciplinary framework**: for characterizing the pluripotency of social bots on social media, combining influence quantification, network dynamic monitoring, and cross - language feature analysis.
2. **Study the information manipulation mechanism**: to reveal the synergy of social bots in information dissemination, echo - chamber formation, and collective memory construction.
3. **Analyze behavioral differences in a multilingual environment**: by studying the behavior of social bots in different language communities (such as English and Japanese), explore their similarities and differences in information diffusion and toxic content generation.
4. **Evaluate the impact of social bots**: especially during the Russia - Ukraine war, analyze the activities of social bots on platforms such as Twitter (X) and Reddit and their impact on human users.

### Specific problems:
- **Pluripotency of social bots**: How do social bots play multiple roles on different social media platforms, including spreading false information, manipulating public opinion, and exacerbating political polarization?
- **Heterogeneity across languages and platforms**: How to understand the behavioral differences of social bots in multilingual and multi - platform environments, and what are the impacts of these differences on social dialogue?
- **Information manipulation and echo - chamber effect**: How do social bots influence public opinion and social cognition through information manipulation and the echo - chamber effect?
- **Shaping of collective memory**: What is the role of social bots in shaping collective memory, especially on issues related to historical events and national identity?

### Research background:
With the development of artificial intelligence technology, the activities of social bots on social media platforms are increasing day by day, especially between two parties with strong opposing views (such as political conflicts). However, most of the existing research focuses on a single platform or specific events and fails to fully consider the complexity in multilingual and multi - platform environments. Therefore, a comprehensive framework is needed to fully understand the behavior and impact of social bots in these complex environments.

### Methodology:
The paper proposes an AID framework (Adaptation, Intelligence, Distribution) with three attributes to characterize the pluripotency of social bots and verifies the effectiveness of this framework through empirical analysis. Specific methods include:
- **Network dynamic monitoring**: Analyze the distribution and interaction patterns of social bots in the network.
- **Language feature analysis**: Evaluate the toxicity level of texts and other language features through natural language processing technology.
- **Cross - platform data integration**: Combine data from multiple platforms for comprehensive analysis.

### Application cases:
Taking the Russia - Ukraine war as the background, the paper analyzes the activities of social bots on Twitter (X) and Reddit, showing their roles and impacts in the information war. By comparing the behavior of social bots in different language communities (such as English and Japanese), it reveals their significant differences in information diffusion and toxic content generation.

In short, by proposing an interdisciplinary framework, this paper aims to comprehensively understand the pluripotency of social bots on social media platforms and their impact on social dialogue, especially their complex behaviors in multilingual and multi - platform environments.