On the second law of thermodynamics: Spontaneous cold-to-hot heat transfer in a nonchaotic medium

Yu Qiao,Zhaoru Shang
2024-07-05
Abstract:It has long been known that, fundamentally different from a large body of rarefied gas, when a Knudsen gas is immersed in a thermal bath, it may never reach thermal equilibrium. The root cause is nonchaoticity: as the particle-particle collisions are sparse, the particle trajectories tend to be independent of each other. Usually, this counterintuitive phenomenon is studied through kinetic theory and is not considered a thermodynamic problem. In current research, we show that if incorporated in a compound setup, such an intrinsically nonequilibrium behavior has nontrivial consequences and cannot circumvent thermodynamics: cold-to-hot heat transfer may happen spontaneously, either continuously (with an energy barrier) or cyclically (with time-dependent entropy barriers). It allows for production of useful work by absorbing heat from a single thermal reservoir without any other effect. As the system obeys the first law of thermodynamics, the refrigeration statement and the heat-engine statement of the second law of thermodynamics cannot be applied. The basic principle of maximum entropy is adhered to.
Statistical Mechanics,Chaotic Dynamics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether self - heating transfer between hot and cold can occur in non - chaotic media. Specifically, the author explores whether Knudsen gas (a rarefied gas in which collisions between particles are very few, resulting in non - chaotic system behavior) can achieve self - heating transfer from low temperature to high temperature under specific conditions (such as the existence of energy barriers or time - dependent entropy barriers). This phenomenon challenges the traditional second law of thermodynamics, which states that heat is usually transferred from high temperature to low temperature, unless through external work. The paper also discusses how this self - heating transfer could be used to generate useful work without absorbing heat from an additional heat source, which contradicts the traditional formulation of the second law of thermodynamics. The research results show that under certain specific conditions, self - heating transfer from low temperature to high temperature can indeed be observed, which provides a new perspective for understanding and exploring non - equilibrium thermodynamics.