Abstract:People are well aware that, inherently, certain small-scale nonchaotic particle movements are not governed by thermodynamics. Usually, such phenomena are studied by kinetic theory and their energy properties are considered "trivial". In current research, we show that, beyond the boundary of the second law of thermodynamics where Boltzmann's H-theorem does not apply, there are also large-sized systems of nontrivial energy properties: when the system is isolated, entropy can decrease; from a single thermal reservoir, the system can absorb heat and produce useful work without any other effect. The key concept is local nonchaoticity, demonstrated by using a narrow energy barrier. The barrier width is much less than the nominal particle mean free path, so that inside the barrier, the particle-particle collisions are sparse and the particle trajectories tend to be locally nonchaotic. Across the barrier, the steady-state particle flux ratio is intrinsically in a non-Boltzmann form. With a step-ramp structure, the nonequilibrium effect spreads to the entire system, and a global flow is generated spontaneously from the random thermal motion. The deviation from thermodynamic equilibrium is steady and significant, and compatible with the basic principle of maximum entropy. These theoretical and numerical analyses may shed light on the fundamentals of thermodynamics and statistical mechanics.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address whether the second law of thermodynamics still applies under specific conditions. Specifically, the authors explore whether entropy can decrease in an isolated system when there is a local non-chaotic energy barrier, and whether the system can absorb heat from a single thermal source and produce useful work without any other external effects. This study challenges the universal applicability of the traditional second law of thermodynamics.
### Background and Problem Statement
1. **Importance of the Second Law of Thermodynamics**:
- The second law of thermodynamics holds a central position in various fields of physics (such as quantum mechanics, astrophysics, materials science, energy science, etc.).
- However, unlike the first law, the second law lacks a solid theoretical foundation.
2. **Limitations of the Classical H-Theorem**:
- The classical H-theorem attempts to explain why entropy can irreversibly increase in an isolated system, even though all governing equations are time-reversible.
- The H-theorem assumes molecular chaos, meaning that collisions between particles in the system are widespread. However, for large-scale systems, it is still undetermined whether the global state is dominated by these local processes if particle interactions in some local processes can be neglected.
3. **Previous Research**:
- Past research has attempted to find counterexamples to the second law of thermodynamics, but these studies generally support the robustness of statistical mechanics theory.
- Typical models include Maxwell's demon and Feynman's ratchet. Maxwell's demon is non-equilibrium but not spontaneous; Feynman's ratchet is spontaneous but not non-equilibrium.
4. **Concept of Spontaneous Non-Equilibrium Dimension (SND)**:
- The authors propose the concept of SND, where the particle number density distribution in a region cannot reach thermodynamic equilibrium.
- SND combines the non-equilibrium characteristics of Maxwell's demon and the spontaneous characteristics of Feynman's ratchet.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
1. **Local Non-Chaotic Energy Barrier**:
- The authors demonstrate local non-chaotic phenomena through a narrow energy barrier. Within this barrier, particle collisions are sparse, and particle trajectories tend to be locally non-chaotic.
- The steady-state particle flux ratio across the barrier is non-Boltzmann in form.
2. **Propagation of Non-Equilibrium Effects**:
- Through a step-ramp structure, non-equilibrium effects can extend to the entire system, thereby spontaneously generating a global flow.
- This state, deviating from thermodynamic equilibrium, is stable and significant, and is compatible with the fundamental principle of maximum entropy.
3. **Experimental Verification**:
- The authors designed and conducted experiments to verify that entropy can decrease in an isolated system without energy cost.
- Experimental data support the theoretical analysis, indicating that it is possible to absorb heat from a single thermal source and produce useful work.
### Conclusion
Through theoretical and numerical analysis, this paper explores the applicability of the second law of thermodynamics under specific conditions. The results indicate that in the presence of a local non-chaotic energy barrier, entropy in an isolated system can decrease, and it is possible to absorb heat from a single thermal source and produce useful work, providing a new perspective on the fundamental principles of thermodynamics and statistical mechanics.