Exploring the nonclassical dynamics of the "classical" Schrödinger equation

David Navia,Ángel S. Sanz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aop.2024.169637
2024-03-07
Abstract:The introduction of nonlinearities in the Schrödinger equation has been considered in the literature as an effective manner to describe the action of external environments or mean fields. Here, in particular, we explore the nonlinear effects induced by subtracting a term proportional to Bohm's quantum potential to the usual (linear) Schrödinger equation, which generates the so-called "classical" Schrödinger equation. Although a simple nonlinear transformation allows us to recover the well-known classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation, by combining a series of analytical results (in the limiting cases) and simulations (whenever the analytical treatment is unaffordable), we find an analytical explanation to why the dynamics in the nonlinear "classical" regime is still strongly nonclassical. This is even more evident by establishing a one-to-one comparison between the Bohmian trajectories associated with the corresponding wave function and the classical trajectories that one should obtain. Based on these observations, it is clear that the transition to a fully classical regime requires extra conditions in order to remove any trace of coherence, which is the truly distinctive trait of quantum mechanics. This behavior is investigated in three paradigmatic cases, namely, the dispersion of a free propagating localized particle, the harmonic oscillator, and a simplified version of Young's two-slit experiment.
Quantum Physics,Optics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper discusses the role of the nonlinear Schrödinger equation in describing the transition from quantum to classical, particularly through the study of the so-called "classical" Schrödinger equation. This equation introduces nonlinearity by subtracting a term related to wave dynamics from the standard (linear) Schrödinger equation, resulting in a dynamics similar to classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation. Although classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation can be recovered through a simple nonlinear transformation, the author found that even in the nonlinear "classical" regime, the dynamics still exhibit strong non-classical features through the analysis of limiting cases and numerical simulations. This is mainly manifested in significant differences between Bohmian trajectories and classical trajectories compared to their corresponding wave dynamics. In the paper, the authors studied typical cases such as diffusion of a free particle, harmonic oscillator, and interference of two wave packets. By adjusting the coupling factor λ of the nonlinear term from 0 to 1, they simulated the transition process from quantum to classical. They found that even at λ=1 (completely nonlinear or "classical" regime), the system's dynamics still retain the coherence characteristic of quantum mechanics and do not truly reach complete classical behavior. This indicates that additional conditions are required to eliminate coherence in order to achieve the transition from quantum to classical world. Therefore, the main objective of the paper is to challenge and deepen our understanding of the quantum-to-classical transition, pointing out that the classical behavior of quantum systems cannot be fully captured by solely nonlinear corrections, highlighting the central role of quantum coherence in this process.