No U(1) 'electric-magnetic' duality in Einstein gravity

Ricardo Monteiro

2024-05-01

Abstract:We revisit the question of whether classical general relativity obeys, beyond the linearised order, an analogue of the global U(1) electric-magnetic duality of Maxwell theory, with the Riemann tensor playing the role analogous to the field strength. Following contradictory claims in the literature, we present a simple gauge-invariant argument that the duality does not hold. The duality condition is the conservation of the helicity charge. Scattering amplitudes of gravitons in general relativity, and of gluons in Yang-Mills theory, violate this selection rule already at tree level. Indeed, the maximally-helicity-violating (MHV) amplitudes are famous for their simplicity. The duality in the linearised theories is, therefore, broken by the interactions. In contrast, the tree-level scattering amplitudes in duality-invariant theories of non-linear electromagnetism are known to obey helicity conservation. While the duality is not a symmetry of the full theory of general relativity, it does hold within a sector of the solution space, including vacuum type D solutions, where the duality is known to rotate between mass and NUT charge.

High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether there is a global U(1) electric - magnetic duality in classical general relativity similar to that in Maxwell's theory. Specifically, the paper explores whether general relativity obeys this duality at the nonlinear level, where the Riemann tensor plays a role similar to the electromagnetic field strength. By reviewing the contradictory views in the literature, the author presents a simple gauge - invariant argument and proves that this duality does not hold in general relativity. The condition for duality is the conservation of chiral charge, and the scattering amplitudes of gravitons in general relativity and of gluons in Yang - Mills theory already violate this selection rule at the tree - level. Therefore, the paper points out that this duality is broken by interactions in the nonlinear theory. However, the paper also notes that in certain parts of the solution space, such as in vacuum type D solutions, duality does exist. These solutions include those in the Kerr - Taub - NUT family, where duality is manifested as a rotation between mass and NUT charge.

The main contribution of the paper lies in clarifying the existence or non - existence of U(1) electric - magnetic duality in general relativity and explaining why this duality is still valid in certain parts of the solution space. This not only helps in understanding the basic properties of general relativity but also provides a reference for studying duality in other theories.