System-environment entanglement phase transitions

Yuto Ashida,Shunsuke Furukawa,Masaki Oshikawa

2024-08-22

Abstract:Entanglement in quantum many-body systems can exhibit universal phenomena governed by long-distance properties. We study universality and phase transitions of the entanglement inherent to open many-body systems, namely, the entanglement between a system of interest and its environment. Specifically, we consider the Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid (TLL) under a local measurement and analyze its unconditioned nonunitary evolution, where the measurement outcomes are averaged over. We quantify the system-environment entanglement by the Rényi entropy of the post-measurement density matrix, whose size-independent term encodes the universal low-energy physics. We develop a field-theoretical description to relate the universal term to the effective ground-state degeneracy known as the $g$ function in a boundary conformal field theory, and use the renormalization group method to determine its value. We show that the universal contribution is determined by the TLL parameter $K$ and can exhibit singularity signifying an entanglement phase transition. Surprisingly, in certain cases the size-independent contribution can increase as a function of the measurement strength in contrast to what is naïvely expected from the $g$-theorem. We argue that this unconventional behavior could be attributed to the dangerously irrelevant term which has been found in studies of the resistively shunted Josephson junction. We also check these results by numerical calculations in the spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ XXZ chain subject to a site-resolved measurement. Possible experimental realization in ultracold gases, which requires no postselections, is discussed.

Statistical Mechanics,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Quantum Gases,High Energy Physics - Theory,Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the entanglement characteristics between the system and the environment in open many - body quantum systems, especially whether this entanglement will exhibit phase - transition behaviors and whether these phase transitions are universal. Specifically, the author focuses on:

1. **Does the system - environment entanglement have a phase transition? If so, do these phase transitions exhibit universal behaviors?**
2. **How to develop a field - theory description to study the universality and phase transitions of system - environment entanglement?**
3. **Can the universal contributions of system - environment entanglement be calculated analytically?**

To answer these questions, the author chose the Tomonaga - Luttinger liquid (TLL) as the research object, which is an effective model for describing one - dimensional critical states. By introducing local measurements, the author studied the behavior of TLL under non - unitary evolution and used the Rényi entropy to quantify the entanglement between the system and the environment.

### Main findings

1. **Universal entanglement phase transition**: The author proved that under local measurements, TLL will experience a universal entanglement phase transition, which depends on the measurement intensity and the TLL parameter \(K\).

2. **Universal term in Rényi entropy**: The Rényi entropy of system - environment entanglement contains a universal term \(s_0\) that is independent of the system size. This term is usually an irrational number and can undergo singular changes in some cases as the measurement intensity increases.

3. **Application of boundary conformal field theory**: The author related the universal term \(s_0\) to the effective ground - state degeneracy \(g\) function through the boundary conformal field theory (boundary CFT) technique and determined its value using the renormalization group (RG) method.

4. **Non - monotonic behavior**: Surprisingly, in some cases, the universal term \(s_0\) increases as the measurement intensity increases, which is not in line with the expectation of the g - theorem. The author speculates that this unconventional behavior may be caused by dangerous irrelevant terms in the non - perturbative region.

### Formula summary

- **Rényi entropy**:
\[
S^{(n)}_{SE}=\frac{1}{1 - n}\log\text{tr}[\hat{\rho}_E^n]
\]

- **Simplified Rényi entropy (\(n = 2\))**:
\[
S_{SE}=-\log\text{tr}[\hat{\rho}_E^2]
\]

- **Form of total entanglement entropy**:
\[
S_{SE}=s_1L - s_0+o(1)
\]
where \(s_1\) is a non - universal term related to the system size, and \(s_0\) is a universal term independent of the system size.

- **Relationship between the universal term and the g - function**:
\[
e^{s_0}=\frac{g_E}{g_I}
\]

Through these studies, the author revealed new universal characteristics of system - environment entanglement in open many - body systems and provided a new perspective for understanding the non - unitary evolution of quantum many - body systems.