Todd Lowe Alexander J. Smits Michel Visonneau Ganbo Deng Liuyang Ding Emmanuel Guilmineau Richard Sandberg Ali Haghiri Aldo Gargiulo Julie Duetsch-Patel Philippe Lavoie Daniel MacGregor Luca Savio Yngve L. Jenssen Christopher Roy Owen Williams Serge Toxopeus William Devenport a Virginia Tech,Blacksburg,VA,USAb Princeton University,Princeton,NJ,USc CNRS,LHEEA Lab. (ECN/CNRS),Nantes,Franced University of Melbourne,Melbourne,Australiae University of Leicester,Leicester,UKf University of Virginia,Charlottesville,VA,USg University of Toronto Institute for Aerospace Studies (UTIAS),Toronto,ON,Canadah SINTEF Ocean,Trondheim,Norwayi Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU),Trondheim,Norwayj University of Washington,Seattle,WA,USk Maritime Research Institute Netherlands (MARIN),Wageningen,The Netherlands

Abstract:The physics and computational prediction of turbulent boundary layer flow over axisymmetric and three-dimensional bodies are examined. Three cases were considered for which extensive experimental results and companion Reynolds-averaged Navier Stokes (RANS) solutions were obtained and/or available in the open literature. These cases all have Reynolds numbers based upon the freestream velocity and body geometric scale on the order of 105 to 106 , which is large for laboratory scales but small compared to the maximum scales observed for full-scale vehicles. Despite significant differences in approach flow fields and geometries for these three cases, some common themes emerged in the findings. All cases involved complications due to pressure gradients combined with streamwise curvature, and all exhibited regions of turbulence reduction due to accelerated flow. These complications led to discrepancies in computed results even in attached flow regions where it is often assumed that RANS models provide reliable predictions. The authors recommend further work on modelling approaches that can capture rapid distortion effects on turbulence transport that can be incorporated into industry-useful frameworks. Two cases involving laterally symmetric, three-dimensional wall-mounted hills with aft-body separation revealed that asymmetric mean flow fields are likely to result. This finding has been observed in experiments conducted in multiple facilities and in computations using multiple solvers and turbulence models. It is concluded that non-unique and asymmetric global flow solutions are fundamental to flow cases with lateral geometric symmetry involving turbulent boundary layer separation. Further work is also needed to accurately predict low-frequency unsteadiness due to geometries that produce non-unique mean flow fields. For such flows, it remains to be definitively determined whether experimentally observed modes of the mean flow are equivalent, or nearly equivalent, to asymmetric mean flow solutions obtained using RANS approaches.

Evidence of quasi equilibrium in pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers

Evidence of quasiequilibrium in pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers

Equivalence of Three Thermal Boundary Conditions in Compressible Turbulent Channel Flows

Adverse-Pressure-Gradient Effects on Turbulent Boundary Layers: Statistics and Flow-Field Organization

Reynolds-number effects on the outer region of adverse-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers

Investigation of Large Scale Motions in Zero and Adverse Pressure Gradient Turbulent Boundary Layers Using High-Spatial-Resolution PIV

Reynolds number required to accurately discriminate between proposed trends of skin friction and normal stress in wall turbulence

Quantifying equilibrium pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers via a symmetry approach

Boundary Layer Stability for two Phase Flow with Pressure Gradient

A symmetry-based theory for the mean velocity profiles of turbulent boundary layers subjected to pressure gradient and historical turbulence effects

Turbulent boundary layer with strong favorable pressure gradient and curvature effects: Streamline coordinate and scaling analysis

A family of adverse pressure gradient turbulent boundary layers with upstream favorable pressure gradients

Experimental study of a turbulent boundary layer with a rough-to-smooth change in surface conditions at high Reynolds numbers

Experimental characterization of turbulent boundary layers around a NACA 4412 wing profile

Turbulent boundary layer statistics at very high Reynolds number

Turbulent boundary layers around wing sections up to Rec = 1,000,000

Wind-Tunnel Simulation of Approximately Horizontally Homogeneous Stable Atmospheric Boundary Layers

Reynolds-number effects in turbulent boundary layers around wing sections

An extension of Thwaites method for turbulent boundary layers

Non-equilibrium turbulent boundary layers in high reynolds number flow at incompressible conditions: effects of streamline curvature and three dimensionality

Streamwise energy-transfer mechanisms in zero- and adverse-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers