Abstract:We study the Reynolds-number effects on the outer region of moderate adverse-pressure-gradient (APG) turbulent boundary layers (TBLs) and find that their small scale energy reduces with increasing friction Reynolds-number ($Re_{\tau}$). The trend is based on analyzing APG TBL data across 600 $\lesssim$ $Re_{\tau}$ $\lesssim$ 7000, and contrasts with the negligible variation in small scale energy noted for canonical wall flows. The datasets considered include those from a well-resolved numerical simulation (Pozuelo et al. 2022), which provides access to an APG TBL maintained at near-equilibrium conditions across 1000 $\lesssim$ $Re_{\tau}$ $\lesssim$ 2000, with a well-defined flow history, and a new high-$Re_{\tau}$ ($\sim$ 7000) experimental study from the large Melbourne wind tunnel, with its long test section modified to permit development of an APG TBL from a 'canonical' upstream condition. The decrease in small scale energy with $Re_{\tau}$ is revealed via decomposing the streamwise normal stresses into small and large scale contributions, based on a sharp spectral cut-off. The origin for this trend is traced back to the production of turbulent kinetic energy in an APG TBL, the small scale contribution to which is also found to decrease with $Re_{\tau}$ in the outer region. The conclusion is reaffirmed by investigating attenuation of streamwise normal stresses due to changing spatial-resolutions of the numerical grid/hotwire sensors, which reduces with increasing $Re_{\tau}$ and is found to be negligible at $Re_{\tau}$ $\sim$ 7000 in this study. The results emphasize that new scaling arguments and spatial-resolution correction schemes should be tested rigorously across a broad $Re_{\tau}$ range, particularly for the outer region of pressure gradient TBLs.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the influence of Reynolds number ($Re_\tau$) on the small - scale energy in the outer region of adverse - pressure - gradient turbulent boundary layers (APG TBLs). Specifically, the authors analyzed how the small - scale (viscous - scale) energy in the outer region of the adverse - pressure - gradient turbulent boundary layer changes under different friction Reynolds numbers ($600 \lesssim Re_\tau \lesssim 7000$) and compared it with the situation in canonical wall flows. ### Research Background and Problems 1. **Importance of Turbulent Boundary Layers**: Turbulent boundary layers (TBLs) are of great significance in engineering and scientific applications, but their complexity has led to slow research progress. 2. **Influence of Adverse - Pressure - Gradient**: The adverse - pressure - gradient (APG) has a significant impact on the structure and characteristics of the turbulent boundary layer, especially in the outer region. 3. **Limitations of Existing Research**: Although previous studies have shown that the adverse - pressure - gradient will increase the large - scale and small - scale energy, these studies mainly focused on the low - to - medium friction Reynolds number range and did not systematically study the small - scale energy change at high Reynolds numbers. ### Main Findings 1. **Change Trend of Small - Scale Energy**: The authors found that in the adverse - pressure - gradient turbulent boundary layer, as the friction Reynolds number increases, the small - scale energy in the outer region decreases. This trend is in sharp contrast to the almost unchanged small - scale energy in the canonical wall flow. 2. **Mechanism Discussion**: The reason for this decreasing trend is traced back to the generation mechanism of turbulent kinetic energy in the outer region of the adverse - pressure - gradient turbulent boundary layer, especially the decrease in small - scale contributions. 3. **Data Sources**: The study used numerical simulation (LES) and experimental data, covering a wide range of friction Reynolds numbers from low to high, ensuring the wide applicability of the results. ### Methods and Conclusions 1. **Data Sources**: - **Numerical Simulation**: High - resolution LES data from Pozuelo et al. (2022) were used, covering the range of $1000 \lesssim Re_\tau \lesssim 2000$. - **Experimental Data**: New experimental data from the Melbourne large - scale wind tunnel were used, with a friction Reynolds number of about 7000. 2. **Analysis Methods**: - **Spectral Decomposition**: The streamwise normal stress was decomposed into small - scale and large - scale contributions by the spectral decomposition method. - **Influence of Spatial Resolution**: The influence of numerical grids/hot - wire sensors at different spatial resolutions on the attenuation of streamwise normal stress was studied. ### Conclusions 1. **Decrease in Small - Scale Energy**: The small - scale energy in the outer region of the adverse - pressure - gradient turbulent boundary layer decreases as the friction Reynolds number increases. 2. **Necessity of New Scaling Laws**: This finding emphasizes the need to strictly test new scaling laws and spatial resolution correction methods in a wide range of Reynolds numbers, especially in the adverse - pressure - gradient turbulent boundary layer. 3. **Measurement Error**: Understanding the change in small - scale energy is also very important for quantifying measurement error, especially under high Reynolds number conditions. ### Formulas - **Friction Reynolds Number**: \[ Re_\tau=\frac{\delta_{99} U_\tau}{\nu} \] - **Clauser Pressure - Gradient Parameter**: \[ \beta(x)=\left(\frac{\delta^*}{\rho U_\tau^2}\right) \frac{dP}{dx} \] - **Displacement Thickness**: \[ \delta^*=\int_0^{\delta_{99}}\left(1 - \frac{U(z)}{U_e}\right) dz \] - **Average Flow Velocity**: \[ U(z) \] - **Edge Velocity**: \[ U_e = U(z=\delta_{99}) \] Through these studies, the authors provide a new perspective for understanding the complex behavior of the adverse - pressure - gradient turbulent boundary layer and lay the foundation for further research.

Reynolds-number effects on the outer region of adverse-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers

Consistent Outer Scaling and Analysis of Adverse Pressure Gradient Turbulent Boundary Layers

Reynolds-number effects in turbulent boundary layers around wing sections

Effects of Reynolds number and spatial resolution on the pressure source terms in turbulent boundary layers

Streamwise energy-transfer mechanisms in zero- and adverse-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers

Turbulent boundary layers around wing sections up to Rec = 1,000,000

Asymptotic Expansions and Scaling of Turbulent Boundary Layers in Adverse Pressure Gradients

Effect of an Adverse Pressure Gradient on the Streamwise Reynolds Stress Profile Maxima in a Turbulent Boundary Layer

Adverse-Pressure-Gradient Effects on Turbulent Boundary Layers: Statistics and Flow-Field Organization

Effects of adverse pressure gradient on Reynolds stresses inturbulent boundary layers

Turbulent activity in the near-wall region of adverse pressure gradient turbulent boundary layers

Outer scaling of self-similar adverse-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers

Investigation of Large Scale Motions in Zero and Adverse Pressure Gradient Turbulent Boundary Layers Using High-Spatial-Resolution PIV

Reynolds number asymptotics of wall-turbulence fluctuations

Reynolds number dependence of length scales governing turbulent flow separation with application to wall-modeled large-eddy simulations

Reynolds number required to accurately discriminate between proposed trends of skin friction and normal stress in wall turbulence

Reynolds-dependence of turbulent skin-friction drag reduction induced by spanwise forcing

Finite Reynolds Number Effect on Small-Scale Statistics in Decaying Grid Turbulence

Quantifying equilibrium pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers via a symmetry approach

Finite Reynolds Number Effect on Small-Scale Statistics of Homogeneous Isotropic Turbulence

Scaling Laws for the Mean Velocity in Adverse Pressure Gradient Turbulent Boundary Layers Based on Asymptotic Expansions