Classical information and collapse in Wigner's friend setups

Veronika Baumann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/e25101420

2023-08-16

Abstract:The famous Wigner's friend experiment considers an observer -- the friend -- and a superobserver -- Wigner -- who treats the friend as a quantum system and her interaction with other quantum systems as unitary dynamics. This is at odds with the friend describing this interaction via collapse dynamics, if she interacts with the quantum system in a way that she would consider a measurement. These different descriptions constitute the Wigner's friend paradox. Extended Wigner's friend experiments combine the original thought experiment with non-locality setups. This allows for deriving local friendliness inequalities, similar to Bell's theorem, which can be violated for certain extended Wigner's friend scenarios. A Wigner's friend paradox and the violation of local friendliness inequalities require that no classical record exists, which reveals the result the friend observed during her measurement. Otherwise Wigner agrees with his friend's description and no local friendliness inequality can be violated. In this article, I introduce classical communication between Wigner and his friend and discuss its effects on the simple as well as extended Wigner's friend experiments. By controlling the properties of a (quasi) classical communication channel between Wigner and the friend one can regulate how much outcome information about the friend's measurement is revealed. This gives a smooth transition between the paradoxical description and the possibility of violating local friendliness inequalities, on the one hand, and the effectively collapsed case, on the other hand.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores Wigner's friend paradox and its behavior under different communication conditions. Specifically:

1. **Wigner's Friend Paradox**: In Wigner's friend experiment, one observer (the friend) measures a quantum system, while another observer (Wigner) treats the friend as a quantum system and considers the interaction between the friend and the quantum system as unitary dynamics. However, the friend would describe their measurement process as wave function collapse. These two different descriptions lead to Wigner's friend paradox.

2. **Impact of Classical Records**: The paper discusses the impact on Wigner's friend experiment when classical records are present. If there is a record revealing the result observed by the friend, even Wigner, who describes the process using unitary dynamics, would obtain the same probability distribution as wave function collapse. In this case, the presence of classical records effectively leads to state collapse.

3. **Extended Wigner's Friend Experiment**: The paper also explores an extended Wigner's friend experiment that incorporates non-local settings. By introducing local-friendly inequalities (similar to Bell's theorem), the paradox can be tested in certain extended scenarios. These inequalities are violated under specific conditions, indicating that not all assumptions can be simultaneously satisfied.

4. **Role of (Quasi-)Classical Communication Channels**: The paper further investigates the role of a (quasi-)classical communication channel in both simple and extended Wigner's friend experiments. By controlling the properties of the channel, the amount of information about the friend's observation results can be adjusted, allowing a smooth transition to either complete collapse or complete unitary dynamics. For the extended experiment, the properties of the channel determine whether the local-friendly inequalities can be violated.

In summary, the paper studies Wigner's friend paradox and its behavior in different scenarios by introducing classical communication channels, demonstrating how classical records influence the results of quantum measurements.