From observer-dependent facts to frame-dependent measurement records in Wigner friend scenarios

J. Allam,A. Matzkin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1209/0295-5075/acfbf4

2023-08-08

Abstract:The description of Wigner-friend scenarios -- in which external agents describe a closed laboratory containing a friend making a measurement -- remains problematic due to the ambiguous nature of quantum measurements. One option is to endorse assumptions leading to observer-dependent facts, given that the friend's measurement outcome is not defined from the point of view of the external observers. We introduce in this work a model in a relativistic context showing that these assumptions can also lead to measurement records that depend on the inertial reference frame in which the agents make their observations. Our model is based on an entangled pair shared by the friend and a distant agent performing space-like separated measurements. An external observer at rest relative to the closed laboratory and observers in a moving frame do not agree on the observed records, which are not Lorentz transforms of one another.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the issues of fact dependence and measurement record dependence encountered by different observers in different inertial reference frames in Wigner's Friend Scenarios. Specifically:

1. **Ambiguity of Quantum Measurement**: When an external observer describes the measurement results of a friend observer in a closed laboratory, the inherent ambiguity of quantum measurement leads to facts becoming dependent on the observer.

2. **Measurement Record Dependence under Relativistic Effects**: The authors introduce a model based on entangled pairs, demonstrating that this dependence manifests not only among different observers but also in different inertial reference frames in a relativistic context. That is, the records observed by an external stationary observer and an observer in a moving reference frame are inconsistent, and these records are not the result of Lorentz transformations.

Through this model, the authors show that considering relativistic effects, using unitary evolution to describe Wigner's Friend Scenarios leads to inconsistent observation results in different reference frames. This implies that combining the unitary evolution assumption with the instantaneous state update assumption may result in physically unacceptable outcomes.