Abstract:Observables in quantum gravity are famously defined asymptotically, at the boundary of AdS or Minkowski spaces. However, by gauge fixing a coordinate system or suitably dressing the field operators, an approximate, "quasi-local" approach is also possible, that can give account of the measurements performed by a set of observers living inside the spacetime. In particular, one can attach spatial coordinates to the worldlines of these observers and use their proper times as a time coordinate. Here we highlight that any such local formulation has to face the relativity of the event , in that changing frame (= set of observers) implies a reshuffling of the point-events and the way they are identified. As a consequence, coordinate transformations between different frames become probabilistic in quantum gravity. We give a concrete realization of this mechanism in Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity, where a point in the bulk can be defined operationally with geodesics anchored to the boundary. We describe different ways to do so, each corresponding to a different frame , and compute the variances of the transformations relating some of these frames. In particular, we compute the variance of the location of the black hole horizon, which appears smeared in most frames. We then suggest how to calculate this effect in Einstein gravity, assuming knowledge of the wavefunction of the metric. The idea is to expand the latter on a basis of semiclassical states. Each element of this basis enjoys standard/deterministic coordinate transformations and the result is thus obtained by superposition. As a divertissement , we sabotage Lorentz boosts by adding to Minkoswki space a quantum superposition of gravitational waves and compute the probabilistic coordinate transformation to a boosted frame at linear order. Finally, we attempt to translate the relativity of the event into the language of dressed operators.

Coordinates are messy -- not only in General Relativity

On the center of mass in general relativity

On center of mass and foliations by constant spacetime mean curvature surfaces for isolated systems in General Relativity

Non-commutative coordinates from quantum gravity

Holomorphic gravity and its regularization of Locally Signed Coordinate Invariance

Relativity of the event: examples in JT gravity and linearized GR

Quasilocal Center-of-Mass for Teleparallel Gravity

Non-coordinates basis in General Relativity and Cartan's structure equations

General Relativistic Center-of-Mass Coordinates for Composite Quantum Particles

Null Cones in Lorentz-Covariant General Relativity

On a scalar field of time and electromagnetism

How the non-metricity of the connection arises naturally in the classical theory of gravity

Conserved Quantities in General Relativity: from the Quasi-Local Level to Spatial Infinity

Fermi-normal coordinates for the Newtonian approximation of gravity

Signed Coordinate Invariance, invariant lagrangians and manifolds, the time problem in quantum cosmology, quantum space time, spacetimes and antispacetimes

Holomorphic General Coordinate Invariant Modified Measure Gravitational Theory

Definition of Center of Mass for Isolated Physical Systems and Unique Foliations by Stable Spheres with Constant Mean Curvature

GPS Observables in Newtonian Spacetime or Why We Do Not Need 'Physical' Coordinate Systems

Comparing Equivalent Gravities: common features and differences

Linking Edge Modes and Geometrical Clocks in Linearized Gravity