J. Brian Pitts,W.C. Schieve
Abstract:The oft-neglected issue of the causal structure in the flat spacetime approach to Einstein's theory of gravity is considered. Consistency requires that the flat metric's null cone be respected, but this does not happen automatically. After reviewing the history of this problem, we introduce a generalized eigenvector formalism to give a kinematic description of the relation between the two null cones, based on the Segre' classification of symmetric rank 2 tensors with respect to a Lorentzian metric. Then we propose a method to enforce special relativistic causality by using the naive gauge freedom to restrict the configuration space suitably. A set of new variables just covers this smaller configuration space and respects the flat metric's null cone automatically. In this smaller space, gauge transformations do not form a group, but only a groupoid. Respecting the flat metric's null cone ensures that the spacetime is globally hyperbolic, indicating that the Hawking black hole information loss paradox does not arise.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to ensure the consistency of the causal structure when using a flat background metric in general relativity. Specifically, the author is concerned with whether the relationship between the null cone of the curved metric and that of the flat metric is consistent in the flat - spacetime method. If these two are inconsistent, it may lead to a violation of causality, thus affecting the physical meaning of the theory.
### Background and Problem Description
In the study of general relativity, some researchers attempt to simplify the problem by introducing a flat background metric \(\eta_{\mu\nu}\), so that the gravitational field can be regarded as a field propagating in a flat spacetime. The advantage of this method is that it can use the framework of special relativity to deal with gravitational problems, making it easier to quantize. However, an important problem faced by this method is whether there is consistency between the null cone of the curved metric \(g_{\mu\nu}\) and that of the flat metric \(\eta_{\mu\nu}\). If the two are inconsistent, it may lead to a physically unacceptable violation of causality.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
1. **Historical Review**:
- The author reviews the research history of this problem in the past 60 years, pointing out that although many researchers have explored the application of the flat background metric in general relativity, few have systematically considered the null - cone consistency problem.
- The author points out different ways of dealing with this problem in history, including ignoring, wrongly solving or postponing the solution, etc.
2. **Problem Proposal**:
- The author clearly proposes the importance of the null - cone consistency problem and points out that this is the key to ensuring the physical meaning of the theory.
- The author points out that if the null cone of the curved metric does not respect the null cone of the flat metric, then even if the theory is formally special - relativity - invariant, there may be problems in physics.
3. **Solutions**:
- The author introduces a formalism based on generalized eigenvectors, using Segre classification to describe the relationship between the two null cones.
- The author proposes a method to enforce the causality of special relativity by restricting the configuration space. This method involves introducing a new set of variables that naturally respect the null cone of the flat metric.
- The author proves that in this new configuration space, gauge transformations no longer form a group but form a groupoid, which is physically reasonable.
4. **Physical Significance**:
- The author points out that ensuring that the curved metric respects the null cone of the flat metric can guarantee the global hyperbolicity of spacetime, which means that the Hawking black hole information - loss paradox will not occur.
- This result shows that the flat metric is not just a formal mathematical trick but has beneficial physical consequences.
### Conclusion
This paper provides a solid theoretical basis for the application of the flat background metric in general relativity by systematically analyzing and solving the null - cone consistency problem. This work not only solves the long - ignored problem but also provides an important reference for future theoretical development.