Linking Edge Modes and Geometrical Clocks in Linearized Gravity

Kristina Giesel,Viktoria Kabel,Wolfgang Wieland

2024-10-23

Abstract:Reference frames are crucial for describing local observers in general relativity. In quantum gravity, different proposals exist for how to treat reference frames. There are models with either classical or quantum reference frames. Recently, different choices appeared for investigating these possibilities at the level of the classical and quantum algebra of observables. One choice is based on the covariant phase space approach, using gravitational edge modes. In the canonical approach, there is another choice, relational clocks, built from matter or geometry itself. In this work, we extend existing results and show how to relate edge modes and geometrical clocks in linearized gravity. We proceed in three steps. First, we introduce an extension of the ADM (Arnowitt-Deser-Misner) phase space to account for covariant gauge fixing conditions and the explicit time dependence they add to Hamilton's equations. Second, we show how these gauge fixing conditions recover a specific choice of geometrical clocks in terms of Ashtekar-Barbero connection variables. Third, we study the effect of the Barbero-Immirzi parameter on the generators of asymptotic symmetries and the corresponding charges. This parameter, which disappears from metric gravity, affects the generators for angle-dependent asymptotic symmetries and the corresponding super-translation charges, while it has no effect on the global charges.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory,Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explore how to connect edge modes with geometrical clocks at the classical and quantum levels, especially in the linearized theory of gravity. Specifically, the paper focuses on two different reference frame frameworks:

1. **Geometrical clocks**: Geometrical clocks constructed based on the ADM formalism, using 3 + 1 decomposition and Ashtekar - Barbero variables.
2. **Coordinate fields**: Coordinate fields studied in the covariant phase - space formalism. These coordinate fields become physical edge modes on the boundary and are related to the quantum reference frame.

Although these two frameworks are very different in mathematical form, they are applicable to the same physical scenario, namely the linearized theory of gravity, and do not rely on additional matter degrees of freedom to construct the reference frame. Therefore, the main objective of the paper is to establish an explicit relationship between these two frameworks, thereby deepening the understanding of the connection between edge modes and dynamic reference frames.

### Specific steps

The paper achieves this goal through the following steps:

1. **Expanding the ADM phase - space**: Starting from the canonical ADM description, a new expanded ADM phase - space is proposed so that covariant gauge - fixing conditions can be formulated. This step solves the problem of implementing covariant gauge - fixing conditions in the canonical phase - space.

2. **Introducing the Barbero - Immirzi parameter**: Starting from the covariant phase - space description, the Barbero - Immirzi parameter is incorporated into the derivation of edge modes and their conjugate momenta, with particular attention to the situation in the linearized theory.

3. **Partial gauge - fixing**: It is proved that the covariant gauge - fixing conditions imposed in the covariant phase - space can reproduce the geometrical clocks in the canonical formalism under specific partial gauge - fixing. Specifically, the geometrical clocks can be regarded as the gauge - unfixed version of the specifically selected coordinate reference fields. The key gauge - fixing condition here is the harmonic gauge - fixing condition.

### Main contributions

1. **Construction of the expanded phase - space**: Compared with existing work, the expanded phase - space proposed in this paper is different in several aspects. In particular, instead of introducing additional matter fields to achieve the harmonic gauge condition, we introduce additional coordinate fields and two additional (co - ) vector fields as the normal vector field and the time - flow vector field respectively.

2. **The influence of the Barbero - Immirzi parameter**: The influence of the Barbero - Immirzi parameter on the boundary charge is discussed in detail. Although this parameter has no influence on the global Poincaré charges (such as gravitational energy and momentum), it will affect the higher - order multipoles, which are obtained by non - uniform integration on the asymptotic two - dimensional sphere.

3. **Building a bridge**: In a specific and tractable linearized gravity scenario, a bridge is established between two different reference frame models based on the canonical ADM and the covariant phase - space formalism. By studying the linearized theory, valuable preliminary insights are provided for studying similar problems in non - perturbative theories.

### Conclusion

The paper successfully establishes the connection between edge modes and geometrical clocks through the above steps, providing a new perspective for understanding the reference frame problem in quantum gravity. In addition, the paper also shows how to implement covariant gauge - fixing conditions in the canonical phase - space and discusses the influence of the Barbero - Immirzi parameter on the boundary charge. These results lay the foundation for further research on the reference frame problem in quantum gravity.