Quantum Theory, Gravity and Second Order Geometry

Folkert Kuipers

2024-10-24

Abstract:We argue that a consistent coupling of a quantum theory to gravity requires an extension of ordinary `first order' Riemannian geometry to second order Riemannian geometry, which incorporates both a line element and an area element. This extension results in a misalignment between the dimension of the manifold and the dimension of the tangent spaces. In particular, we find that for a 4-dimensional spacetime, tangent spaces become 18-dimensional. We then discuss the construction of physical theories within this framework, which involves the introduction of terms that are quadratic in derivatives in the action. On a flat spacetime, the quadratic sector is perpendicular to the first order sector and only affects the normalization of the path integral, whereas in a curved spacetime the quadratic sector couples to the first order sector. Moreover, we show that, despite the introduction of higher order derivatives, the Ostragradski instability can be avoided, due to an order mixing of the two sectors. Finally, we comment on extensions to higher order geometry and on relations with non-commutative and generalized geometry.

High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Mathematical Physics,Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to consistently combine quantum theory with gravitational theory**. Specifically, the author believes that traditional Riemannian geometry is not sufficient to describe this combination and needs to be extended to a higher - order geometric framework - especially **second - order Riemannian geometry**.

### Main problems and solutions

1. **Limitations of traditional Riemannian geometry**:
- Traditional Riemannian geometry can well describe classical gravity (such as general relativity), but it encounters difficulties when dealing with the interaction between quantum theory and gravity.
- For example, in quantum field theory, the path integral method involves non - smooth paths, which are difficult to handle within the framework of classical Riemannian geometry.

2. **Introduction of second - order Riemannian geometry**:
- The author proposes a new geometric framework - second - order Riemannian geometry, which not only contains line elements but also introduces area elements. This extension increases the dimension of the tangent space from the usual 4 - dimensions to 18 - dimensions (for 4 - dimensional space - time).
- This extension solves the problem of non - smooth paths in path integrals and allows a more natural description of quantum effects.

3. **Construction of physical theories**:
- In the second - order geometric framework, the author discusses how to construct physical theories. This includes introducing action with second - derivative terms and discussing the influence of these terms in flat and curved space - times respectively.
- Although higher - order derivatives are introduced, the Ostragradski instability is avoided through the mixing between two different orders.

### Formula summary

- Line Element:
\[
ds^2 = g_{\mu\nu} dx^\mu dx^\nu
\]

- Area Element:
\[
dA^2 = G_{|\mu\nu|\rho\sigma|} d\langle x^\mu, x^\nu \rangle d\langle x^\rho, x^\sigma \rangle
\]

- Vector representation in second - order geometry:
\[
v = v^\mu \partial_\mu+\frac{1}{2} v^{\mu\nu}_2 \partial_\mu \partial_\nu
\]

- Second - order differential operator:
\[
d^2 f=\partial_\mu f d^2 x^\mu+\frac{1}{2} \partial_\nu \partial_\mu f dx^\mu dx^\nu
\]

### Conclusion

By introducing second - order Riemannian geometry, the author provides a new framework to consistently combine quantum theory and gravitational theory. This extension not only solves the problem of non - smooth paths in path integrals but also provides a new perspective for constructing quantum gravity theory.