International Institutions for Advanced AI

Lewis Ho,Joslyn Barnhart,Robert Trager,Yoshua Bengio,Miles Brundage,Allison Carnegie,Rumman Chowdhury,Allan Dafoe,Gillian Hadfield,Margaret Levi,Duncan Snidal

2023-07-11

Abstract:International institutions may have an important role to play in ensuring advanced AI systems benefit humanity. International collaborations can unlock AI's ability to further sustainable development, and coordination of regulatory efforts can reduce obstacles to innovation and the spread of benefits. Conversely, the potential dangerous capabilities of powerful and general-purpose AI systems create global externalities in their development and deployment, and international efforts to further responsible AI practices could help manage the risks they pose. This paper identifies a set of governance functions that could be performed at an international level to address these challenges, ranging from supporting access to frontier AI systems to setting international safety standards. It groups these functions into four institutional models that exhibit internal synergies and have precedents in existing organizations: 1) a Commission on Frontier AI that facilitates expert consensus on opportunities and risks from advanced AI, 2) an Advanced AI Governance Organization that sets international standards to manage global threats from advanced models, supports their implementation, and possibly monitors compliance with a future governance regime, 3) a Frontier AI Collaborative that promotes access to cutting-edge AI, and 4) an AI Safety Project that brings together leading researchers and engineers to further AI safety research. We explore the utility of these models and identify open questions about their viability.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on how to ensure that advanced artificial intelligence systems can benefit all of humanity through international institutions and manage the risks they bring. Specifically, the paper explores the following aspects:

1. **Promoting Global Benefits**:
- The paper points out that although powerful AI systems have significant benefits, these benefits may not be evenly distributed. In particular, developing countries may lack the resources, infrastructure, or expertise required to utilize cutting - edge AI technologies. Therefore, international institutions are needed to support sustainable global development and ensure that everyone can benefit from AI technologies.

2. **Managing Shared Risks**:
- The capabilities of advanced AI systems may bring negative global externalities. For example, malicious actors may use AI to reinvent dangerous chemicals, solve fundamental problems in synthetic biology, develop cyber - weapons, etc., all of which may pose a threat to global security. In addition, the misuse and accidents of AI systems may also cross national borders and affect multiple countries and regions. Therefore, international institutions are needed to formulate and implement safety norms and standards to reduce these risks.

3. **The Need for International Governance**:
- The paper emphasizes that due to the high complexity of AI technologies and their transnational use, domestic regulation alone may not be able to effectively manage the risks of AI. Therefore, international - level cooperation and coordination are required to ensure the responsible development and deployment of AI.

To achieve the above goals, the paper proposes four possible international institution models:

1. **Commission on Frontier AI**:
- This commission aims to promote experts' consensus on the opportunities and risks of advanced AI, raise public awareness of the prospects and problems of AI, and provide a scientific basis for policymakers.

2. **Advanced AI Governance Organization**:
- This organization is responsible for formulating international standards, supporting the implementation of these standards, and may monitor compliance to manage global AI risks.

3. **Frontier AI Collaborative**:
- This organization promotes the development and distribution of frontier AI technologies through international cooperation and public - private partnerships, helping less - developed societies benefit from them.

4. **AI Safety Project**:
- This project brings together top researchers and engineers, provides computing resources and advanced AI models to conduct AI safety research and reduce AI risks.

The paper also discusses the challenges faced by these models, such as the difficulty of scientific understanding, the risk of politicization, the management of dual - use technologies, etc., and proposes corresponding solutions. Overall, the paper hopes that through the cooperation of international institutions, the development of advanced AI systems will bring global benefits and effectively manage their potential risks.