Abstract:This paper presents the results of an extensive structural search of ternary solids containing lutetium, nitrogen and hydrogen. Based on thousands of thermodynamically stable structures, available online, the convex hull of the formation enthalpies is constructed. To obtain the correct energetic ordering, the highly accurate RSCAN DFT functional is used in high quality all-electron calculations. In this way possible pseudopotential errors are eliminated. A novel lutetium hydride structure (HLu$_2$) that is on the convex hull is found in our search. An electron phonon analysis however shows that it is not a candidate structure for near ambient superconductivity. Besides this structure, which appears to have been missed in previous searches, possibly due to different DFT methodologies, our results agree closely with the results of previously published structure search efforts. This shows, that the field of crystal structure prediction has matured to a state where independent methodologies produce consistent and reproducible results, underlining the trustworthiness of modern crystal structure predictions. Hence it is quite unlikely that a structure, that would give rise within standard BCS theory to the superconducting properties, claimed to have been observed by Dasenbrock-Gammon et al. <a class="link-https link-external" data-doi="10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0" href="https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0" rel="external noopener nofollow">https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0</a> , exists. This solidifies the evidence that no structure with conventional superconducting properties exists that could explain the experimental observation made by Dasenbrock-Gammon et al. <a class="link-https link-external" data-doi="10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0" href="https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0" rel="external noopener nofollow">https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0</a>

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the prediction of the structure of nitrogen - doped lutetium hydride (Lu - N - H) and whether it may have room - temperature superconducting properties. Specifically, the paper aims to verify or refute the experimental results published by Dasenbrock - Gammon et al. in 2023 on the superconductivity of nitrogen - doped lutetium hydride (Lu - N - H) observed under near - ambient conditions through detailed structure search and thermodynamic stability analysis. The main objectives of the paper include: 1. **Explore the ternary phase diagram**: Through extensive structure search, determine the thermodynamically stable structures of ternary solids containing lutetium, nitrogen, and hydrogen, and construct a convex hull diagram of formation enthalpy. 2. **Verify superconducting candidate structures**: Use the high - precision RSCAN DFT functional for all - electron calculations to eliminate pseudopotential errors and ensure the accuracy of energy ordering. Pay special attention to the newly discovered lutetium hydride structure (HLu2) and conduct electron - phonon analysis to evaluate its potential as a near - ambient superconducting candidate structure. 3. **Compare with existing research**: Compare with previous research results (such as the work of Liu et al. and Ferreira et al.) to verify the consistency and reliability of modern crystal structure prediction methods. 4. **Interpret experimental results**: Explore whether the superconducting phenomenon observed by Dasenbrock - Gammon et al. can be explained by known crystal structures and the conventional BCS theory. Through these objectives, the paper aims to provide a deeper understanding of the superconducting properties of nitrogen - doped lutetium hydride and provide reliable data support for future research.

Ternary Phase Diagram of Nitrogen Doped Lutetium Hydrides

Electronic structure of nitrogen-doped lutetium hydrides

On parent structures of near-ambient nitrogen-doped lutetium hydride superconductor

Structure, Stability and Superconductivity of N-doped Lutetium Hydrides at kbar Pressures

Novel Electronic Structure of Nitrogen-Doped Lutetium Hydrides

Ab initio study of the structural, vibrational and optical properties of potential parent structures of nitrogen-doped lutetium hydride

Magnetic, electronic and optical properties of lanthanide hydrides, GdH2 and GdH3

Pressure-induced formation of cubic lutetium hydrides derived from trigonal LuH$_3$

Anatomy of the band structure of the newest apparent near-ambient superconductor LuH$_{3-x}$N$_x$

Assessing the feasibility of near-ambient conditions superconductivity in the Lu-N-H system

Effect of nitrogen doping and pressure on the stability of LuH$_3$

Thermodynamic properties and enhancement of diamagnetism in nitrogen doped lutetium hydride synthesized at high pressure

Novel ground state structures of N-doped LuH3

Unraveling the electronic structure of LuH, LuN, and LuNH: building blocks of new materials

Crystal structure prediction and non-superconductivity of N-doped LuH3at near ambient pressure

Leading components and pressure-induced color changes in N-doped lutetium hydride

Observation of Flat Band and Van Hove Singularity in Non-superconducting Nitrogen-doped Lutetium Hydride

Superconducting and topological properties of compound Lu$_4$H$_7$N

First-principles study on the superconductivity of N-doped fcc-LuH3

Observation of non-superconducting phase changes in nitrogen doped lutetium hydrides

Unveiling a Novel Metal-to-Metal Transition in LuH2: Critically Challenging Superconductivity Claims in Lutetium Hydrides