The kinetic theory of ultra-subsonic fermion systems and applications to flat band magic angle twisted bilayer graphene

Seth M. Davis,Sankar Das Sarma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.109.195105

2023-05-16

Abstract:The only kinematically-allowed phonon-scattering events for bands of subsonic fermions ($v_F < v_p$) are interband transitions, leading to different low-$T$ transport physics than in the typical supersonic case. We apply a kinetic theory of phonon-limited transport to a generic two-band system of subsonic fermions, deriving formulae for relaxation times and resistivity that are accurate in the limit of close bands and small $v_F/v_p$. We predict regimes of $\rho \propto T$, $\rho \propto T^2$, and perfect conductivity. Our theory predicts linear-in-$T$ resistivity down to a crossover temperature that is suppressed from its supersonic analogue by a factor of $v_F/v_p$, offering a new explanation for low-$T$ "strange metal" behavior observed in flat band systems.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the influence of phonon scattering on low - temperature transport properties in fermionic systems below the supersonic speed (especially magic - angle twisted bilayer graphene with flat bands, MATBLG). Specifically, the author focuses on the behavior of the resistivity of the system as a function of temperature under the so - called "ultrasubsonic" (USS) condition when the Fermi velocity \(v_F\) is less than the phonon velocity \(v_p\).

### Main problems and research motivation
1. **The particularity of the ultrasubsonic fermionic system**:
- In the ultrasubsonic fermionic system, due to momentum and energy conservation, single - phonon scattering processes can only occur between different energy bands (i.e., inter - band transitions), which is different from the situation in the supersonic fermionic system.
- Such inter - band transitions lead to different low - temperature transport physical phenomena, especially the resistivity that shows a linear temperature dependence (\(\rho\propto T\)) at low temperatures, and this phenomenon is called "strange - metal" behavior.

2. **Experimental observations of magic - angle twisted bilayer graphene (MATBLG)**:
- MATBLG has been found to exhibit superconductivity close to the strongly - correlated insulating state, and a linear temperature - dependent resistivity has been observed over a wide range of doping and temperature, sometimes even as low as 50 mK.
- These phenomena have inspired discussions on the analogy between MATBLG and high - temperature superconducting cuprates and speculation that its superconductivity may be driven by strongly - correlated physics.

3. **Limitations of existing theoretical explanations**:
- Existing phonon - based theories can well quantitatively explain experimental results, but these theories are mainly applicable to supersonic fermionic systems in normal metals and semiconductors.
- Therefore, a new theoretical framework needs to be developed to explain the low - temperature transport behavior in the ultrasubsonic fermionic system, especially the resistivity with a linear temperature dependence.

### Research objectives
- Develop a kinetic theory applicable to the ultrasubsonic fermionic system and derive analytical formulas for describing the relaxation time and resistivity.
- Explain why the resistivity with a linear temperature dependence occurs in the ultrasubsonic fermionic system and explore whether this behavior can be attributed to the "strange - metal" state.
- Explore other possible resistivity behaviors in the ultrasubsonic fermionic system, such as \(\rho\propto T^2\) and perfect conductivity.

Through these studies, the author hopes to provide a new theoretical basis for understanding the low - temperature transport phenomena in MATBLG and other ultrasubsonic fermionic systems.