On-off pumping for drag reduction in a turbulent channel flow

Giulio Foggi Rota,Alessandro Monti,Marco E. Rosti,Maurizio Quadrio

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2023.451

2023-04-29

Abstract:We show that the energy required by a turbulent flow to displace a given amount of fluid through a straight duct in a given time interval can be reduced by modulating in time the pumping power. The control strategy is hybrid: it is passive, as it requires neither a control system nor control energy, but it manipulates how pumping energy is delivered to the system (as in active techniques) to increase the pumping efficiency. Our control employs a temporally periodic pumping pattern, where a short and intense acceleration (in which the pumping system is on) followed by a longer deceleration (in which the pumping system is off) makes the flow alternately visit a quasi-laminar and a turbulent state. The computational study is for a plane channel flow, and employs direct numerical simulations, which present specific computational challenges, for example the highly varying instantaneous value of the Reynolds number, and the importance of discretisation effects. Particular care is devoted to a meaningful definition of drag reduction in the present context. The ability of the forcing to yield significant savings is demonstrated. Since only a small portion of the parameter space is investigated, the best performance of the control technique remains to be assessed.

Fluid Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to reduce drag in turbulent pipe flow by time - modulated pumping power, thereby improving pumping efficiency. Specifically, the researchers proposed a hybrid control strategy that requires neither a control system nor additional control energy, but instead increases pumping efficiency by adjusting the way pumping energy is delivered. They adopted a periodic pumping pattern, that is, high - intensity acceleration in a short time (the pumping system is on), followed by a longer deceleration phase (the pumping system is off), so that the fluid alternates between quasi - laminar and turbulent states. Through this method, the researchers hope to reduce the resistance of the fluid in the pipe without increasing additional energy consumption, thereby achieving a more efficient pumping process.

The paper conducted a computational study on plane channel flow through direct numerical simulation (DNS) to explore the effectiveness and potential advantages of this time - modulated pumping method. The study specifically focused on how to define meaningful drag reduction in this context and showed that this forcing method can significantly save energy. Although only a small part of the parameter space has been explored so far, the preliminary results indicate that this control technique has great potential, and future work will further evaluate its optimal performance.