A minimalist version of the circle method and Diophantine problems over thin sets

Kirsti D. Biggs,Julia Brandes
2023-04-17
Abstract:This paper studies the minimal conditions under which we can establish asymptotic formulae for Waring's problem and other additive problems that may be tackled by the circle method. We confirm in quantitative terms the well-known heuristic that a mean value estimate and an estimate of Weyl type, together with suitable distribution properties of the underlying set over a set of admissible residue classes, are sufficient to implement the circle method. This allows us to give a rather general proof of Waring's problem which is applicable to a range of sufficiently well-behaved thin sets, such as the ellipsephic sets recently investigated by the first author.
Number Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to study under what minimal conditions asymptotic formulas can be established for Waring's problem and other additive problems that can be dealt with by the circle method. Specifically, the authors confirm the following points: 1. **Mean - value estimates and Weyl - type estimates**: A mean - value estimate and a Weyl - type estimate, as well as the appropriate distribution properties of the underlying set over the allowed residue classes, are sufficient to implement the application of the circle method. 2. **Generalized proof**: This enables them to give a relatively general proof of Waring's problem, applicable to a series of sufficiently good thin sets, such as the ellipsephic sets recently studied by the first author. ### Specific background and problem description Let \(n\) be a natural number. Given a subset \(A\subseteq\mathbb{N}\), how many ways can \(n\) be represented as the sum of elements in \(A\)? This problem spans multiple areas of pure mathematics: - When the subset is the set of prime numbers, this problem is equivalent to the Goldbach problem. - When the subset is the \(k\)-th powers, this is an instance of Waring's problem. - For more general sets, this is a currently actively studied problem in additive combinatorics. - If the elements in the subset carry complex weights, the same problem becomes a problem in discrete harmonic analysis. In this paper, the authors study the situation of Waring's problem and related problems when the variables are restricted to a rather general subset of integers. In particular, they explore what properties are sufficient to derive the asymptotic formula for the number of representations of an arbitrarily large enough integer as the sum of the \(k\)-th powers of elements in a given subset of integers. This can be regarded as a generalization of Brüdern [13]'s work on binary additive forms. ### Main contributions The authors propose a unified method to handle the major - arc analysis, which only needs to meet the same conditions required to control the minor - arc and is applicable to all sets with appropriate residue - class distribution properties. This unified method avoids the complexity of adjusting standard techniques for each specific set. ### Key results The main results include: - **Theorem 1.1**: For sets \(A\) that satisfy certain distribution properties and are not too sparse, an asymptotic formula for \(R_{s,1;k}(n;A)\) is given. - **Theorem 1.2**: For the ellipsephic sets \(E_p\), a similar asymptotic formula is also obtained under specific conditions. - **Theorem 1.3**: For the set of prime numbers \(P\), an asymptotic formula for \(R_{s;k}(n;P)\) is given. These results demonstrate the effectiveness and flexibility of dealing with Waring's problem on sparse sets by the circle method.