Abstract:The in-plane (thermal) Hall effect is an unconventional transverse response when the applied magnetic field is in the (heat) current plane. In contrast to the normal Hall effect, the in-plane Hall effect requires the absence of certain crystal symmetries, and possibly manifests a non-trivial topology of quantum materials. An accurate estimation of the intrinsic in-plane (thermal) Hall conductivity is crucial to identify the underlying mechanisms as in the case of the Kitaev spin-liquid candidate alpha-RuCl3. Here, we give the symmetry conditions for the in-plane Hall effect and discuss the implications that may impede the experimental evaluation of the in-plane (thermal) Hall conductivity within the single-device measurement. First, the lack of symmetry in crystals can create merohedral twin domains that cancel the total Hall signal. Second, even in a twin-free crystal, the intrinsic response is potentially contaminated by the out-of-plane conduction in three-dimensional systems, which is systematically unavoidable in the in-plane Hall systems. Third, even in a quasi-two-dimensional system, the conversion of (thermal) resistivity, rho (lambda), to (thermal) conductivity, sigma (kappa) requires protocols beyond the widely-used simplified formula due to the lack of in-plane-rotational symmetry. In principle, two independent sample devices are necessary to accurately estimate the s_xy (k_xy). As a case study, we discuss the half-integer quantization of the in-plane thermal Hall effect in the spin-disordered state of alpha-RuCl3. For an accurate measurement of the thermal Hall effect, it is necessary to avoid crystals with the merohedral twins contributing oppositely to k_xy, while the out-of-plane transport may have a negligible effect. To deal with the field-induced rotational-symmetry breaking, we propose two symmetry-based protocols, improved single-device and two-device methods.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to accurately measure and understand the in - plane Hall conductivity and in - plane thermal Hall conductivity under the action of in - plane magnetic fields. Specifically, the author explores the following aspects: 1. **Symmetry Conditions**: - The paper proposes the symmetry requirements for the in - plane Hall effect. For example, the lack of certain crystal symmetries is a necessary condition for the existence of the in - plane Hall effect. These conditions are crucial for explaining experimental results. - By introducing a graphical method, the author derives the conditions for the non - existence of the in - plane Hall effect and applies them to specific materials such as ZrTe₅. 2. **The Influence of Twin - Crystal Effects on Signals**: - Twin - crystal phenomena in crystals may cause the cancellation of in - plane Hall signals, thus affecting the accuracy of experimental measurements. The paper discusses how to avoid or deal with such problems to ensure that the measured signals can reflect the real physical properties. 3. **The Interference of Out - of - Plane Transport in Three - Dimensional Systems**: - In three - dimensional systems, out - of - plane transport will interfere with the measurement of in - plane Hall conductivity. The paper analyzes in detail the source of this interference and its mathematical expression, and points out that this interference is inevitable and requires special attention. 4. **The Lack of Rotational Symmetry in Two - Dimensional Systems**: - For quasi - two - dimensional systems, in - plane magnetic fields will lead to the breaking of rotational symmetry in the xy - plane. This makes the commonly used simplified formulas no longer applicable, and more complex measurement methods must be adopted to accurately estimate the in - plane Hall conductivity. 5. **The Thermal Hall Effect in α - RuCl₃**: - As a case study, the paper discusses the half - integer - quantized thermal Hall effect in α - RuCl₃, a candidate material for Kitaev spin liquid. The author points out that some existing measurement methods may have systematic errors and proposes an improved experimental protocol to clarify this phenomenon. ### Formula Summary - **The Relationship between In - Plane Hall Resistivity and Conductivity**: \[ \rho_{yx}^o=\frac{\sigma_{zz}^e}{\Delta \sigma}\left(\sigma_{xy}^o + \frac{\sigma_{xz}^e\sigma_{yz}^o}{\sigma_{zz}^e}\right) \] where \(\Delta \sigma\) is the determinant of the conductivity tensor. - **Comparison between Approximate and Exact Formulas**: - Approximate formula (single - device measurement): \[ \sigma_{xy}^{\text{approx}}=\frac{\rho_{yx}^o}{(\rho_{xx}^e)^2+(\rho_{yx}^o)^2}\sim\frac{\rho_{yx}^o}{(\rho_{xx}^e)^2} \] - Exact formula (double - device measurement): \[ \sigma_{xy}^{\text{exact}}=\frac{\rho_{yx}^o}{\rho_{xx}^e\rho_{yy}^e+(\rho_{yx}^o)^2}\sim\frac{\rho_{yx}^o}{\rho_{xx}^e\rho_{yy}^e} \] Through these analyses, the paper provides researchers with the theoretical basis and experimental guidance for understanding and measuring the in - plane Hall effect, especially how to avoid common mistakes when dealing with complex materials.

Symmetry-based requirement for the measurement of electrical and thermal Hall conductivity under an in-plane magnetic field

Intrinsic spin Hall effect in noncubic crystals

Spontaneous Crystal Thermal Hall Effect in Insulating Altermagnets

Crystal Symmetry-Dependent In-Plane Hall Effect

Planar thermal Hall effect from phonons in a Kitaev candidate material

Pathological study of chronic pulmonary toxicity induced by intratracheally instilled Asian sand dust (Kosa): possible association of fibrosis with the development of granulomatous lesions.

Thermal Hall conductivity of a valence bond solid phase in the square lattice $J_1$-$J_2$ antiferromagnet Heisenberg model with a Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction

Planar thermal Hall effect from phonons in cuprates

Anisotropy of thermal conductivity oscillations in relation to the Kitaev spin liquid phase

Thermal Hall conductivity of electron-doped cuprates

Anomalous and Topological Hall Effects with Phase-Space Berry Curvatures: Electric, Thermal, and Thermoelectric Transport in Magnets

Intrinsic Thermal Hall Effect in Mott Insulators

Thermal Hall response of an abelian chiral spin liquid at finite temperatures

On the angular dependence of anomalous Hall current

Geometric origin of intrinsic spin hall effect in an inhomogeneous electric field

Dissipative Chiral Channels, Ohmic Scaling and Half-integer Hall Conductivity from the Relativistic Quantum Hall Effect

Dissipative Chiral Channels, Ohmic Scaling, and Half-Integer Hall Conductivity from Relativistic Quantum Hall Effect

Simultaneous measurement of anisotropic thermal conductivity and thermal boundary conductance of 2-dimensional materials

Spatial Symmetry Modulation of Planar Hall Effect in Weyl Semimetals

Observation of in-plane anomalous Hall effect associated with orbital magnetization