Lu Chen,Léna Le Roux,Gaël Grissonnanche,Marie-Eve Boulanger,Steven Thériault,Ruixing Liang,D. A. Bonn,W. N. Hardy,S. Pyon,T. Takayama,H. Takagi,Kejun Xu,Zhi-Xun Shen,Louis Taillefer
Abstract:A surprising "planar" thermal Hall effect, whereby the field is parallel to the current, has recently been observed in a few magnetic insulators, and this has been attributed to exotic excitations such as Majorana fermions or chiral magnons. Here we investigate the possibility of a planar thermal Hall effect in three different cuprate materials, in which the conventional thermal Hall conductivity $\kappa_{\rm {xy}}$ (with an out-of-plane field perpendicular to the current) is dominated by either electrons or phonons. Our measurements show that the planar $\kappa_{\rm {xy}}$ from electrons in cuprates is zero, as expected from the absence of a Lorentz force in the planar configuration. By contrast, we observe a sizable planar $\kappa_{\rm {xy}}$ in those samples where the thermal Hall response is due to phonons, even though it should in principle be forbidden by the high crystal symmetry. Our findings call for a careful re-examination of the mechanisms responsible for the phonon thermal Hall effect in insulators.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore whether there is a planar thermal Hall effect in copper - based superconducting materials, especially whether this effect can be generated by phonons. The traditional thermal Hall effect describes the transverse temperature gradient in the y - direction when a heat flow \(J\) is applied in the x - direction and a magnetic field \(H\) is applied in the z - direction. However, recently, a "planar" thermal Hall effect has been observed in some magnetic insulators, that is, the magnetic field is parallel to the current direction, which is attributed to exotic excited states such as Majorana fermions or chiral magnons.
In this study, the authors investigated the planar thermal Hall effect in three different copper - based materials. In these materials, the traditional thermal Hall conductivity \(\kappa_{xy}\) (the magnetic field is perpendicular to the current direction) is mainly dominated by electrons or phonons. It was found that in the electron - dominated materials, the planar \(\kappa_{xy}\) is zero, as expected, because the Lorentz force does not exist in this planar configuration. Conversely, a significant planar \(\kappa_{xy}\) was observed in the phonon - dominated samples, although in principle, high crystal symmetry should prohibit this from happening. This finding requires a re - examination of the mechanism of the phonon thermal Hall effect in insulators.
Specifically, the paper experimentally measured the planar thermal Hall effect of the following materials:
- **YBa_2Cu_3O_y (YBCO)**: At a doping level of p = 0.11, this is a superconductor, and its traditional thermal Hall conductivity is mainly dominated by electrons. The experimental results show that the planar \(\kappa_{xy}\) is zero.
- **Nd_2 - xCe_xCuO_4 (NCCO)**: At a low doping level of x = 0.04, this is an insulator, and its traditional thermal Hall conductivity is entirely caused by phonons. The experimental results unexpectedly found a non - zero planar \(\kappa_{xy}\), whose magnitude is comparable to that of the traditional \(\kappa_{xy}\).
- **La_2 - y - xEu_ySr_xCuO_4 (Eu - LSCO)**: At doping levels of p = 0.21 and 0.24, this material is located on both sides of the pseudogap phase. The experiments show that at p = 0.24, the planar \(\kappa_{xy}\) is zero; while at p = 0.21, the planar \(\kappa_{xy}\) is non - zero, indicating that the signal at this time mainly comes from phonons.
These findings indicate that even in materials with high crystal symmetry, phonons can generate the planar thermal Hall effect, which may be related to local symmetry breaking, for example, due to the presence of impurities, defects or domains. This finding is of great significance for understanding the mechanism of the phonon thermal Hall effect and re - evaluating the reported planar thermal Hall conductivity in Kitaev candidate materials.