Abstract:This paper explores the implications of producing forecast distributions that are optimized according to scoring rules that are relevant to financial risk management. We assess the predictive performance of optimal forecasts from potentially misspecified models for i) value-at-risk and expected shortfall predictions; and ii) prediction of the VIX volatility index for use in hedging strategies involving VIX futures. Our empirical results show that calibrating the predictive distribution using a score that rewards the accurate prediction of extreme returns improves the VaR and ES predictions. Tail-focused predictive distributions are also shown to yield better outcomes in hedging strategies using VIX futures.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores how to improve the accuracy of risk assessment in financial risk management through optimized probability forecasting. Specifically, the study focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Research Background and Motivation**: Traditional probability forecasting methods often assume that the predictive model correctly specifies the data generating process (DGP), but in practice, this assumption is difficult to hold. Therefore, the paper proposes a method based on scoring rules to construct optimal probability forecasts. 2. **Core Contributions**: - Optimizing the predictive distribution using scoring rules related to financial risk management to improve the prediction of extreme returns (such as Value at Risk (VaR) and Expected Shortfall (ES)). - Empirically validating that the method of calibrated predictive distributions can enhance the accuracy of VaR and ES forecasts. - Demonstrating the application of tail distribution optimized forecasts in hedging strategies using VIX futures. 3. **Specific Methods**: - Using two types of scoring rules: Censored Likelihood Scoring (CLS) and Quantile Scoring (QS), which help focus on the tail regions of the predictive distribution. - Comparing the forecasting performance based on different scoring rules in simulation studies, particularly focusing on the performance under model misspecification. - Conducting empirical analysis on 12 S&P market and sector indices to confirm the effectiveness of optimized forecasts in practical risk management. - Exploring the application of optimized forecasts for VIX index predictions in constructing effective VIX futures hedging strategies. 4. **Experimental Results**: - Simulation results show that under different degrees of model misspecification, forecasts based on CLS and QS perform better in predicting tail risks compared to traditional Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE). - Empirical analysis indicates that optimized forecasts are more accurate than MLE forecasts in predicting VaR and ES. - Optimized forecasts for the VIX index also demonstrate better performance in actual hedging strategies. In summary, the paper proposes a method for optimizing predictive distributions using specific scoring rules and demonstrates through theoretical analysis and empirical research the effectiveness and practicality of this method in financial risk management.

Optimal probabilistic forecasts for risk management

Optimal Capital Allocation Based on Weighted-Mean-Variance Principle

Evaluating Density Forecasts Using Weighted Multivariate Scores in a Risk Management Context

Static and Dynamic Models for Multivariate Distribution Forecasts: Proper Scoring Rule Tests of Factor-Quantile vs. Multivariate GARCH Models

Score-driven Exponentially Weighted Moving Averages and Value-at-Risk Forecasting

Risk-Aware Objective-Based Forecasting in Inertia Management

Risk-Averse Optimal Combining Forecasts for Renewable Energy Trading under CVaR Assessment of Forecast Errors

A Two-Step Short-Term Probabilistic Wind Forecasting Methodology Based on Predictive Distribution Optimization

Non-probabilistic odds and forecasting with imperfect models

THE OPTIMAL FUTURES HEDGING STRATEGIES WITH VAR

An empirical review of dynamic extreme value models for forecasting value at risk, expected shortfall and expectile

Distributionally Robust Optimization Under Distorted Expectations

Distributionally Robust Return-Risk Optimization Models and Their Applications.

Optimizing Investment Strategies with Lazy Factor and Probability Weighting: A Price Portfolio Forecasting and Mean-Variance Model with Transaction Costs Approach

A novel probabilistic hesitant fuzzy portfolio selection model with value-at-risk and safety level of score

The efficient frontiers of mean-variance portfolio rules under distribution misspecification

Portfolio Optimization Managing Value at Risk under Heavy Tail Return, using Stochastic Maximum Principle

A Bayesian approach for more reliable tail risk forecasts

From Data to Decisions: Distributionally Robust Optimization Is Optimal

Risk Management and Return Prediction

A Bayesian Risk Approach to Data-driven Stochastic Optimization: Formulations and Asymptotics