Abstract:Metacognition refers to thinking about one's thinking or knowing what one knows. Research suggests that this ability is not unique to humans and may be shared with nonhuman animals. In particular, great apes have shown behaviors on a variety of tasks that are suggestive of metacognitive ability. Here we combine a metacognitive task, the information-seeking task, with tool use and variable forms of initial information provided to chimpanzees to explore how informational states impact behavioral responses in these apes. Three chimpanzees were presented with an apparatus that contained five locations where food could be hidden. If they pointed to the correct location, they received the reward, but otherwise they did not. We first replicated several existing findings using this method, and then tested novel hypotheses. The chimpanzees were given different types of information across the experiments. Sometimes, they were shown the location of the food reward. Other times, they were shown only one empty location, which was not useful information. The chimpanzees also could use a tool to search any of those locations before making a selection. Chimpanzees typically used the tool to search out the location of the reward when they could not already know where it was, but they did not use the tool when they already had been given that information. One chimpanzee made inferences about the location of hidden food, even when that food was never shown in that location. The final experiment involved hiding foods of differing preference values, and then presenting the chimpanzees with different initial knowledge states (i.e., where the best food was located, where the less-preferred food was located, or where no food was located). All chimpanzees used the tool when they needed to use it to find the best possible item on that trial, but responded by choosing a location immediately when they did not need the tool. This finding highlights that their behavior was not the result of a simple rule following such as pointing to where any food had been seen.

Grey parrots use inferential reasoning based on acoustic cues alone

Reasoning by exclusion in the kea (Nestor notabilis)

Inferential reasoning abilities in wild-caught bumblebees

Inference in wolves and dogs: The “cups task”, revisited

Inferential reasoning by exclusion in children (Homo sapiens).

Do kea parrots infer the weight of objects from their movement in a breeze?

How can I find what I want? Can children, chimpanzees and capuchin monkeys form abstract representations to guide their behavior in a sampling task?

Reasoning by exclusion in food-caching Eurasian jays (Garrulus glandarius)

Performance of Azure-winged magpies in Aesop's fable paradigm

A test of the submentalizing hypothesis: Apes' performance in a false belief task inanimate control

Chimpanzees show some evidence of selectively acquiring information by using tools, making inferences, and evaluating possible outcomes

The emergence of reasoning by the disjunctive syllogism in early childhood

Comparative Cognition Research Demonstrates the Similarity between Humans and Other Animals

Among-individual differences in auditory and physical cognitive abilities in zebra finches

Inferring Unseen Causes: Developmental and Evolutionary Origins

Investigating the relationship between physical cognitive tasks and a social cognitive task in a wild bird

Metacognition in dogs: Do dogs know they could be wrong?

Sensitivity to Relational Similarity and Object Similarity in Apes and Children

Chimpanzees process structural isomorphisms across sensory modalities

How great apes perform on a modified trap-tube task

Mechanical problem solving in Goffin's cockatoos -- Towards modeling complex behavior