Frequency-domain probe beam deflection method for measurement of thermal conductivity of materials on micron length scale

Jinchi Sun,Guangxin Lv,David G. Cahill
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0126717
2022-09-21
Abstract:Time-domain thermoreflectance (TDTR) and frequency-domain thermoreflectance (FDTR) have been widely used for non-contact measurement of anisotropic thermal conductivity of materials with high spatial resolution. However, the requirement of high thermoreflectance coefficient restricts the choice of metal coating and laser wavelength. The accuracy of the measurement is often limited by the high sensitivity to the radii of the laser beams. We describe an alternative frequency-domain pump-probe technique based on probe beam deflection. The beam deflection is primarily caused by thermoelastic deformation of the sample surface with a magnitude determined by the thermal expansion coefficient of the bulk material to measure. We derive an analytical solution to the coupled elasticity and heat diffusion equations for periodic heating of a multilayer sample with anisotropic elastic constants, thermal conductivity, and thermal expansion coefficients. In most cases, a simplified model can reliably describe the frequency dependence of the beam deflection signal without knowledge of the elastic constants and thermal expansion coefficients of the material. The magnitude of the probe beam deflection signal is larger than the maximum magnitude achievable by thermoreflectance detection of surface temperatures if the thermal expansion coefficient is greater than 5x10^(-6) /K. The sensitivity to laser beam radii is suppressed when a larger beam offset is used. We find nearly perfect matching of the measured signal and model prediction, and measure thermal conductivities within 6% of accepted values for materials spanning the range of polymers to gold, 0.1 - 300 W/(m K).
Applied Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to develop a new frequency - domain probe - beam - deflection (FD - PBD) method for measuring the thermal conductivity of materials on the micrometer scale. Although the existing time - domain thermoreflectance (TDTR) and frequency - domain thermoreflectance (FDTR) techniques are widely used for non - contact measurement of the anisotropic thermal conductivity of materials, these techniques have some limitations. For example, the requirement for a high thermal reflectance coefficient restricts the choice of metal coatings and laser wavelengths, and the measurement accuracy is highly sensitive to the laser - beam radius. Therefore, the paper proposes an alternative frequency - domain pump - probe technique based on probe - beam - deflection to overcome the above limitations. ### Main Objectives: 1. **Increase Signal Amplitude**: By utilizing the surface deformation caused by the thermal expansion effect of the material to increase the amplitude of the probe - beam - deflection signal, thereby improving the signal - to - noise ratio of the measurement. 2. **Flexibly Select Metal Coatings and Laser Wavelengths**: The new method is not strictly limited by metal coatings and laser wavelengths, and can more flexibly select experimental conditions. 3. **Reduce Errors Caused by Uncertain Laser - Beam Radius**: By using a larger beam offset, reduce the influence of laser - beam - radius changes on the measurement results. 4. **Applicable to Multiple Materials**: This method is applicable not only to transparent and translucent materials, but also to materials with different elastic constants and thermal expansion coefficients. ### Technical Details: - **Principle**: When the metal thin film is heated by the modulated pump beam, the thermal expansion of the material will cause thermoelastic deformation on the sample surface, which in turn causes the deflection of the reflected probe beam. By measuring the relationship between the probe - beam - deflection angle and the pump - beam - modulation frequency, the thermal conductivity of the material can be extracted. - **Model**: The paper derives an analytical model that describes the coupled elastic equations and thermal diffusion equations of a multilayer sample under periodic heating. This model takes into account the anisotropic elastic constants, thermal conductivity, and thermal expansion coefficients of the material. - **Experimental Setup**: The experimental setup includes two continuous - wave (CW) lasers (pump light and probe light), a four - quadrant photodetector, and a lock - in amplifier. By adjusting the offset distance between the pump light and the probe light, the probe - beam - deflection signals at different modulation frequencies can be measured. ### Results and Discussion: - **Signal Analysis**: The paper shows the probe - beam - deflection signals of four representative materials (polystyrene, SrTiO3, MoS2, and gold), and analyzes the contributions of surface deformation, air - optical - path - length change, and reflectance - coefficient change to the signal. - **Applicable Range**: This method is applicable to a variety of materials from polymers to metals (0.1 - 300 W/(m K)), and the deviation of the measurement results from the known values is within 6%. - **Advantages**: Compared with the traditional TDTR and FDTR techniques, the FD - PBD method has a larger signal amplitude, higher measurement accuracy, and broader applicability. In conclusion, the paper proposes a new frequency - domain probe - beam - deflection method, which significantly improves the accuracy and reliability of thermal - conductivity measurement and provides a powerful tool for materials - science research.