The Evolution of U.S. Retail Concentration

Dominic A. Smith,Sergio Ocampo
2023-10-19
Abstract:Increases in national concentration have been a salient feature of industry dynamics in the U.S. and have contributed to concerns about increasing market power. Yet, local trends may be more informative about market power, particularly in the retail sector where consumers have traditionally shopped at nearby stores. We find that local concentration has increased almost in parallel with national concentration using novel Census data on product-level revenue for all U.S. retail stores between 1992 and 2012. The increases in concentration are broad based, affecting most markets, products, and retail industries. We show that the expansion of multi-market firms into new markets explains most of the increase in national retail concentration, with consolidation via increases in local market shares increasing in importance between 1997 and 2007, and single-market firms playing a negligible role. Finally, we find that increases in local concentration can explain one-quarter to one-third of the observed rise in retail gross margins.
General Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the trends and causes of changes in the concentration of the U.S. retail industry. Specifically, the paper aims to address the following key issues: 1. **Describe the trends in retail industry concentration**: The study analyzes the changes in the concentration of the U.S. retail industry at both the national and local levels from 1992 to 2012 and finds that both levels have grown almost in parallel. 2. **Investigate the reasons for the increase in retail industry concentration**: By analyzing the data, the authors find that the cross-market expansion of large retailers is the main factor leading to the increase in national-level retail industry concentration. Additionally, the consolidation of local market shares from 1997 to 2007 also played a significant role in the growth of concentration. 3. **Evaluate the impact of changes in retail industry concentration**: The study also discusses the relationship between the increase in retail industry concentration and the rise in retailer profit margins, estimating that the increase in local product market concentration can explain one-quarter to one-third of the rise in retailer gross margins. 4. **Compare results from different data sources**: The paper also compares the results obtained using different datasets (such as the National Establishment Time Series, NETS) and explains the reasons for the differences. In summary, the core purpose of this paper is to reveal the trends, causes, and impacts of retail industry concentration in the U.S. through detailed microdata analysis, particularly focusing on changes at the local level, and to explore the implications of these changes for market competition and consumers.