Urban Parks Quality Assessment Using Multi-Dimension Indicators in Chengdu, China

Sining Zhang,Haoxiang Song,Xiaopeng Li,Shixian Luo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/land13010086
IF: 3.905
2024-01-12
Land
Abstract:High-quality urban parks are considered an integral part of health resources as they can deliver diverse ecosystem services. However, the quality of parks is not always similar, resulting in different levels and values of the services provided. A systematic and complete assessment frame of urban park quality is limited. From the perspective of landscape architecture and design, this study aims to propose a comprehensive assessment framework of urban park quality based on six dimensions (planning and design, cultural services, complete and various facilities, landscape planting, landscape management, and landscape ecology), consisting of 27 indicators with different weights by using the objective and subjective weighting method. Taking the city of Chengdu, China as a case study, 100 urban parks are studied via field investigation and scored using methods that consist of a category count, existence score, field measurement, experts score, and photo review and recheck (13,589 images). The results reveal the spatial distribution and differences in park quality, including six quality dimensions and five districts, and the proportion of the existing quality elements in 100 parks. Based on the results, the spatial areas (Barren area, Low-quality area, Medium-quality area, and High-quality area) are identified, which leads to the establishment of the improvement strategies of spatial equity regarding multi-quality parks. The results can help improve the assessment index system of urban parks, guide the landscape planning and design of urban parks for sustainability, as well as provide a reference for future environmental and social equity development, so as to provide insight and reference for decision-makers and designers considering the landscape planning and design of parks.
environmental studies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are the lack of an urban park quality assessment system and the unbalanced distribution of urban park quality among different regions. Specifically: 1. **Propose a comprehensive urban park quality assessment framework**: From the perspective of landscape architecture, this study aims to establish a comprehensive urban park quality assessment framework covering six dimensions (planning and design, cultural services, complete and diverse facilities, landscape planting, landscape management, and landscape ecology), including 27 indicators with different weights. These indicators are determined by objective and subjective weighting methods to ensure the scientific nature and accuracy of the assessment. 2. **Evaluate the quality of urban parks in Chengdu**: Taking Chengdu, China as an example, 100 urban parks were studied. The parks were scored through field investigations and scoring methods (including classification counting, presence scoring, on - site measurement, expert scoring, and photo review), revealing the spatial distribution and differences in park quality, including the six quality dimensions and the situation in five districts, as well as the proportion of existing quality elements in 100 parks. 3. **Identify spatial regions and put forward improvement suggestions**: Based on the assessment results, four spatial regions (barren areas, low - quality areas, medium - quality areas, and high - quality areas) were identified, and accordingly, spatial equity improvement strategies for multi - quality parks were proposed. These suggestions are helpful for improving the urban park assessment index system, guiding the landscape planning and design of urban parks, and promoting the development of environmental and social equity. Through the above research, the author hopes to provide insights and references for decision - makers and designers regarding urban park landscape planning and design, especially in the context of considering park quality.