Abstract:Introduction Validation of functional free-breathing MRI involves a comparison to more established or more direct measurements. This procedure is cost-intensive, as it requires access to patient cohorts, lengthy protocols, expenses for consumables, and binds working time. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to introduce a synthetic lung model (ASYLUM), which mimics dynamic MRI acquisition and includes predefined lung abnormalities for an alternative validation approach. The model is evaluated with different registration and quantification methods and compared with real data. Methods A combination of trigonometric functions, deformation fields, and signal combinations were used to create 20 synthetic image time series. Lung voxels were assigned either to normal or one of six abnormality classes. The images were registered with three registration algorithms. The registered images were further analyzed with three quantification methods: deformation-based or signal-based regional ventilation (JVent/RVent) analysis and perfusion amplitude (QA). The registration results were compared with predefined deformations. Quantification methods were evaluated regarding predefined amplitudes and with respect to sensitivity, specificity, and spatial overlap of defects. In addition, 36 patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease were included for verification of model interpretations using CT as the gold standard. Results One registration method showed considerably lower quality results (76% correlation vs. 92/97%, p ≤ 0.0001). Most ventilation defects were correctly detected with RVent and QA (e.g., one registration variant with sensitivity ≥78%, specificity ≥88). Contrary to this, JVent showed very low sensitivity for lower lung quadrants (0–16%) and also very low specificity (1–29%) for upper lung quadrants. Similar patterns of defect detection differences between RVent and JVent were also observable in patient data: Firstly, RVent was more aligned with CT than JVent for all quadrants ( p ≤ 0.01) except for one registration variant in the lower left region. Secondly, stronger differences in overlap were observed for the upper quadrants, suggesting a defect bias in the JVent measurements in the upper lung regions. Conclusion The feasibility of a validation framework for free-breathing functional lung imaging using synthetic time series was demonstrated. Evaluating different ventilation measurements, important differences were detected in synthetic and real data, with signal-based regional ventilation assessment being a more reliable method in the investigated setting.

Modeling ventilation of patients with interstitial lung disease at rest and exercise: a bench study

Comparing physiological impacts of positive pressure ventilation versus self-breathing via a versatile cardiopulmonary model incorporating a novel alveoli opening mechanism

Patient-specific prediction of regional lung mechanics in ARDS patients with physics-based models: A validation study

Full-lung simulations of mechanically ventilated lungs incorporating recruitment/derecruitment dynamics

Stress–strain curve and elastic behavior of the fibrotic lung with usual interstitial pneumonia pattern during protective mechanical ventilation

A synthetic lung model (ASYLUM) for validation of functional lung imaging methods shows significant differences between signal-based and deformation-field-based ventilation measurements

Stress & strain in mechanically nonuniform alveoli using clinical input variables: a simple conceptual model

Pressure- and time-dependent alveolar recruitment/derecruitment in a spatially resolved patient-specific computational model for injured human lungs

Investigation of inert gas washout methods in a new numerical model based on an electrical analogy

Breathomics to monitor interstitial lung disease associated with systemic sclerosis

Image-based Measurement of Alveoli Volume Expansion in an Animal Model of a Diseased Lung.

Virtual patients for mechanical ventilation in the intensive care unit

Lung- and diaphragm-protective strategies in acute respiratory failure: an in silico trial

Pulmonary response prediction through personalized basis functions in a virtual patient model

Ex Vivo Porcine Experimental Model for Studying and Teaching Lung Mechanics

A model of mechanical loading of the lungs including gravity and a balancing heterogeneous pleural pressure

A damaged-informed lung model for ventilator waveforms

Noninvasive and Invasive Pulmonary Function in Mouse Models of Obstructive and Restrictive Respiratory Diseases

Determination of reliable lung function parameters in intubated mice