Abstract:When spin-orbit torques are measured using spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance (ST-FMR), two alternative ways of analyzing the results to extract the torque efficiencies -- lineshape analysis and analysis of the change in linewidth versus DC current -- often give inconsistent results. We identify a source for these inconsistencies. We show that fits of ST-FMR data to the standard analysis framework leave significant residuals that we identify as due to (i) current-induced excitations of a small volume of magnetic material with magnetic damping much larger than the bulk of the magnetic layer, that we speculate is associated with the heavy-metal/magnet interface and (ii) oscillations of the sample magnetization at the modulation frequency due to heating. The dependence of the residual signals on DC current can interfere with an accurate extraction of spin-torque efficiencies by the linewidth method. We show that the discrepancies between the two types of analysis can be largely eliminated by extrapolating the window of magnetic fields used in the linewidth fits to small values so as to minimize the influence of the residual signals.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve the problem of inconsistency between the spin - torque efficiencies extracted by two different analysis methods in Spin - Torque Ferromagnetic Resonance (ST - FMR) measurements. Specifically, these two methods are: 1. **Lineshape Analysis**: Determine the in - plane and perpendicular - to - the - plane spin - orbit torques by fitting the amplitudes of the symmetric and antisymmetric resonance components. 2. **Linewidth Analysis**: Determine the damping - type in - plane component of the spin - orbit torque by fitting the variation of the resonance linewidth with the direct - current. Although ST - FMR is one of the most commonly used methods for quantifying Spin - Orbit Torques (SOTs), the results obtained using the above two analysis methods are often inconsistent, sometimes even differing by several times. For example, in the data of this paper, the difference in the damping - type spin - orbit torque efficiency obtained by lineshape analysis and linewidth analysis is more than 3 times. ### Main research content To find out the reasons for these inconsistencies, the author carried out the following tasks: 1. **Experimental design and data analysis**: - Conduct ST - FMR measurements using Pt/Permalloy and Pt/CoFeB samples. - Compare the data obtained by using microwave current Amplitude Modulation (AM) and Frequency Modulation (FM). - Carefully analyze the residual signals after fitting the standard ST - FMR model. 2. **Discover the reasons for the inconsistencies**: - It is found that the residual signals are mainly from the excitation of small - volume magnetic material regions induced by current, and the magnetic damping in these regions is much larger than that in most regions of the magnetic layer, which may be related to the heavy - metal/magnet interface. - It is also found that the sample magnetization oscillations caused by heating occur at the modulation frequency, which affects the accuracy of linewidth analysis. 3. **Propose solutions**: - By extrapolating the magnetic field window used in linewidth fitting to a smaller value to minimize the influence of the residual signal, the difference between lineshape analysis and linewidth analysis can be significantly reduced. - Using frequency modulation instead of amplitude modulation can also reduce these differences. ### Conclusion Through the above research, the author reveals the main reasons for the inconsistency between the results of lineshape analysis and linewidth analysis in ST - FMR measurements, and proposes specific measures to improve the analysis methods, thus providing theoretical basis and technical support for more accurate measurement of spin - orbit torques. This helps to better understand the microscopic origin of SOTs and promotes the development of next - generation magnetic storage technologies based on SOTs.

Resolving Discrepancies in Spin-Torque Ferromagnetic Resonance Measurements: Lineshape vs. Linewidth Analyses

Spin-current Effect on Ferromagnetic Resonance in Patterned Magnetic Thin Film Structures

Transverse and Longitudinal Spin-Torque Ferromagnetic Resonance for Improved Measurements of Spin-Orbit Torques

Anatomy of Electrical Signals and Dc-Voltage Line Shape in Spin-Torque Ferromagnetic Resonance

Anatomy of electrical signals and dc-voltage lineshape in spin torque ferromagnetic resonance

Spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance based on current-induced impedance

Determination of the spin Hall angle by the inverse spin Hall effect, device level ferromagnetic resonance, and spin torque ferromagnetic resonance: A comparison of methods

Quantifying Spin-Torque Efficiency and Magnetoresistance Coefficient by Microwave Photoresistance in Spin-Torque Ferromagnetic Resonance

FMR-related phenomena in spintronic devices

Influence of the spin pumping induced inverse spin Hall effect on spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance measurements

Resonant Measurement of Non-Reorientable Spin-Orbit Torque from a Ferromagnetic Source Layer Accounting for Dynamic Spin Pumping

Influence of Exchange Bias on Spin Torque Ferromagnetic Resonance for Quantification of Spin-orbit Torque Efficiency

Optically detected spin–orbit torque ferromagnetic resonance in an in-plane magnetized ellipse

Disentangling relativistic spin torques in a ferromagnet/semiconductor bilayer

Influence of nonuniform magnetization reorientation on spin-orbit torque measurements

Spin Wave Dynamics and the Determination of Intrinsic Damping in Locally Excited Permalloy Thin Films.

Effects of lateral device size and material properties on the ferromagnetic resonance response of spinwave eigen-modes in magnetic devices

Quantification Of The Spin-Hall Anti-Damping Torque With A Resonance Spectrometer

Dependence of the Efficiency of Spin Hall Torque on the Transparency of Pt-Ferromagnetic Layer Interfaces

Damping Dependence of Spin-Torque Effects in Thermally Assisted Magnetization Reversal

Determination of spin-orbit torques by thickness-dependent spin-orbit torque FMR measurement