Chi-Feng Pai,Yongxi Ou,D. C. Ralph,R. A. Buhrman
Abstract:We report that spin current transport across Pt-ferromagnet (FM) interfaces is strongly dependent on the type and the thickness of the FM layer and on post-deposition processing protocols. By employing both harmonic voltage measurements and spin-torque ferromagnetic resonance measurements, we find that the efficiency of the Pt spin Hall effect in exerting a damping-like spin torque on the FM ranges from < 0.05 to > 0.10 under different interfacial conditions. We also show that the temperature dependence of the spin torque efficiencies for both the damping-like torque and field-like torque is dependent upon the details of the Pt-FM interface. The "internal" spin Hall angle of the Pt thin films used in this study, after taking the interfacial spin transmission factor into account, is estimated to be ~ 0.20. This suggests that a careful engineering of Pt-FM interfaces can improve the spin-Hall-torque efficiency of Pt-based spintronic devices.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **The influence of the transparency of the Pt - ferromagnetic layer interface on the efficiency of the spin Hall torque**.
Specifically, the authors studied how the transparency of the interface between platinum (Pt) and ferromagnetic materials (FM) affects the spin - current transmission efficiency and the resulting spin Hall torque (SHE). Through experimental and theoretical analysis, they explored the influence of different types of ferromagnetic layers, their thicknesses, and post - deposition processing techniques on the efficiencies of the damping - like spin torque and the field - like spin torque exerted on the ferromagnetic layer by the spin Hall effect.
### Main problems include:
1. **The influence of interface transparency on spin - current transmission**:
- Research shows that the transparency of the Pt - FM interface significantly affects the transmission of spin current. If the interface is not completely transparent, the spin current will flow back, thereby reducing the spin torque exerted on the ferromagnetic layer.
2. **Estimation of the internal value of the spin Hall angle**:
- By considering the interface spin - transport factor, the authors estimated the "internal" spin Hall angle of the Pt film to be approximately 0.20. This indicates that by carefully designing the Pt - FM interface, the spin Hall torque efficiency of Pt - based spintronic devices can be improved.
3. **Changes in spin - torque efficiency under different conditions**:
- Through harmonic voltage measurement and spin - torque ferromagnetic resonance measurement, the authors found that, under different interface conditions, the efficiency of the damping - like spin torque exerted on the ferromagnetic layer by the spin Hall effect of Pt ranges from less than 0.05 to greater than 0.10.
4. **Temperature dependence**:
- The research also shows that the temperature dependence of the efficiencies of the damping - like and field - like spin torques depends on the specific situation of the Pt - FM interface. For example, in some cases, as the temperature decreases, the efficiency of the damping - like spin torque remains almost unchanged, while the efficiency of the field - like spin torque decreases significantly.
### Conclusion:
By optimizing the type and thickness of the ferromagnetic layer, the efficiency of spin - current transmission from spin - Hall materials (such as Pt) to adjacent ferromagnetic layers can be improved. In addition, for in - plane - magnetized Pt - CoFe samples, the spin - orbit torque efficiency varies significantly with different heat - treatment and growth processes, further demonstrating the important influence of the NM - FM interface structure and quality on spin - transmission.
Ultimately, the authors' research results show that by carefully designing the Pt - FM interface, more efficient and energy - saving spintronic devices can be achieved, and may even exceed the overall performance of some high - resistance spin - Hall metals (such as β - Ta and β - W).
### Related formulas:
1. The expressions for the efficiencies of the damping - like and field - like spin torques are:
\[
\xi_{\text{DL}} = \theta_{\text{SH}} \times \frac{\tanh\left(\frac{2d_{\text{NM}}}{\lambda_{\text{s,NM}}}\right)}{\coth\left(\frac{2d_{\text{NM}}}{\lambda_{\text{s,NM}}}\right) + \frac{G_{\uparrow\downarrow}}{\sigma_{\text{NM}} \lambda_{\text{s,NM}}}}
\]
\[
\xi_{\text{FL}} = \theta_{\text{SH}} \times \frac{\tanh\left(\frac{2d_{\text{NM}}}{\lambda_{\text{s,NM}}}\right)}{\coth\left(\frac{2d_{\text{NM}}}{\lambda_{\text{s,NM}}}\right) + \frac{G_{\uparrow\downarrow}}{\sigma_{\text{NM}} \lambda_{\text{s,NM}}}}
\]
2. Spin - mixing conductivity \( G_{\upar