Estimation of Direct and Indirect Polygenic Effects and Gene-Environment Interactions using Polygenic Scores in Case-Parent Trio Studies

Ziqiao Wang,Luke Grosvenor,Debashree Ray,Ingo Ruczinski,Terri Beaty,Heather Volk,Christine Ladd-Acosta,Nilanjan Chatterjee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.10.08.24315066

2024-10-09

Abstract:Family-based studies provide a unique opportunity to characterize genetic risks of diseases in the presence of population structure, assortative mating, and indirect genetic effects. We propose a novel framework, PGS-TRI, for the analysis of polygenic scores (PGS) in case-parent trio studies for estimation of the risk of an index condition associated with direct effects of inherited PGS, indirect effects of parental PGS, and gene-environment interactions. Extensive simulation studies demonstrate the robustness of PGS-TRI in the presence of complex population structure and assortative mating compared to alternative methods. We apply PGS-TRI to multi-ancestry trio studies of autism spectrum disorders (N = 1,517) and orofacial clefts (N = 1,904) to establish the first transmission-based estimates of risk associated with pre-defined PGS for these conditions and other related traits. For both conditions, we further explored offspring risk associated with polygenic gene-environment interactions, and direct and indirect effects of genetically predicted levels of gene expression and metabolite traits.

Genetic and Genomic Medicine

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in the presence of complex population structures and assortative mating, how to accurately estimate the direct effects, indirect effects, and gene - environment interactions of Polygenic Scores (PGS) on disease risk. Specifically, the author proposes a new framework, PGS - TRI, for analyzing PGS in case - parent trio studies to estimate disease risks associated with the following factors:

1. **Direct genetic effect**: The direct impact of the PGS inherited by the offspring on their disease risk.
2. **Indirect genetic effect**: The indirect impact of the parents' PGS on the offspring's disease risk, which may be transmitted through the parents' environmental factors.
3. **Gene - environment interaction**: The impact of the interaction between PGS and environmental exposure on the offspring's disease risk.

### Background problems
Traditional population - based research methods (such as GWAS) may be biased when estimating PGS effects due to factors such as population stratification and assortative mating. These biases can cause genetic effects to be overestimated or underestimated, thus affecting the interpretation and application of the results. In addition, although existing family - based research methods can avoid these problems to a certain extent, they are mainly applicable to randomly sampled families and are not suitable for the trio design based on affected individuals.

### Solutions
To solve the above problems, the author proposes the PGS - TRI method, which has the following characteristics:
- **Flexibility**: Allows the disease risk and PGS distribution to vary flexibly among different families, thus being able to effectively deal with the effects of population stratification and assortative mating.
- **Decomposability**: Decomposes the PGS distribution into a transmitted part and a parental part to estimate the direct and indirect effects respectively.
- **Robustness**: The robustness and effectiveness of PGS - TRI under complex population structures and assortative mating conditions have been verified through extensive simulation studies.

### Application examples
To demonstrate the application value of PGS - TRI, the author applies it to multi - ancestral trio studies of two different developmental disorder diseases - autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and orofacial clefts (OFCs). Through these applications, the author not only verifies the effectiveness of PGS - TRI but also discovers new gene - environment interactions and other potential biomarker associations related to the risks of these two diseases.

### Summary
In general, this paper aims to develop a new statistical method to more accurately estimate various effects of PGS in family trio studies, thereby providing a more reliable understanding of the genetic mechanisms of complex diseases and providing a scientific basis for future prevention and treatment strategies.