Robust deep learning estimation of cortical bone porosity from MR T1-weighted images for individualized transcranial focused ultrasound planning

Matthieu Dagommer,Mohammad Daneshzand,Aapo Nummemnaa,Bastien Guerin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.18.24310644
2024-07-18
Abstract:Objective: Transcranial focused ultrasound (tFUS) is an emerging neuromodulation approach that has been demonstrated in animals but is difficult to translate to humans because of acoustic attenuation and scattering in the skull. Optimal dose delivery requires subject-specific skull porosity estimates which has traditionally been done using CT. We propose a deep learning (DL) estimation of skull porosity from T1-weighted MRI images which removes the need for radiation-inducing CT scans. Approach: We evaluate the impact of different DL approaches, including network architecture, input size and dimensionality, multichannel inputs, data augmentation, and loss functions. We also propose back-propagation in the mask (BIM), a method whereby only voxels inside the skull mask contribute to training. We evaluate the robustness of the best model to input image noise and MRI acquisition parameters and propagate porosity estimation errors in thousands of beam propagation scenarios. Main results: Our best performing model is a cGAN with a ResNet-9 generator with 3D 64x64x64 inputs trained with L1 and L2 losses. The model achieved a mean absolute error of 6.9% in the test set, compared to 9.5% with the pseudo-CT of Izquierdo et al. (38% improvement) and 9.4% with the generic pixel-to-pixel image translation cGAN pix2pix (36% improvement). Acoustic dose distributions in the thalamus were more accurate with our approach than with the pseudo-CT approach of both Burgos et al. and Izquierdo et al, resulting in near-optimal treatment planning and dose estimation at all frequencies compared to CT (reference). Significance: Our DL approach porosity estimates with ~7% error, is robust to input image noise and MRI acquisition parameters (sequence, coils, field strength) and yields near-optimal treatment planning and dose estimates for both central (thalamus) and lateral brain targets (amygdala) in the 200-1000 kHz frequency range.
Radiology and Imaging
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper mainly discusses how to use deep learning to estimate the porosity of the skull to optimize individualized transcranial focused ultrasound (tFUS) treatment planning. tFUS is an emerging neuromodulation technique, but it is affected by the acoustic attenuation and scattering of the skull when applied to humans. Traditionally, CT scans are required to estimate an individual's skull porosity, but this method increases radiation exposure. In this study, the authors propose a deep learning model based on conditional generative adversarial networks (cGAN), using a ResNet-9 generator and 3D 64x64x64 input, combined with L1 and L2 loss functions for training. This model outperforms previous methods such as pseudo CT (pCT) mapping and pixel-to-pixel image translation methods, reducing errors and improving the accuracy of acoustic dose distribution at different frequencies. The paper also introduces the "Backpropagation Inside the Mask" (BIM) technique, which only involves pixels in the skull region during training, enhancing the model's robustness to input image noise and variations in MRI acquisition parameters. The experiments show that even on high noise images and T1-weighted MRI images with different field strengths, sequences, and receive coils, the model can provide near-optimal treatment planning and dose estimation. In conclusion, this paper aims to address the accurate estimation of skull porosity through non-invasive MRI images to improve the accuracy and safety of tFUS treatment and reduce reliance on CT scans.