Abstract:Recent reports suggest the ON and OFF pathways are differentially susceptible to selective vision loss in glaucoma. Thus, perimetric assessment of ON- and OFF-pathway function may serve as a useful diagnostic. However, this necessitates a developed understanding of normal ON/OFF pathway function around the visual field and as a function of input intensity. Here, using electroencephalography, we measured ON- and OFF-pathway biased contrast response functions in the upper and lower visual fields. Using the steady-state visually evoked potential paradigm, we flickered achromatic luminance probes according to a saw-tooth waveform, the fast-phase of which biased responses towards the ON or OFF pathways. Neural responses from the upper and lower visual fields were simultaneously measured using frequency tagging - probes in the upper visual field modulated at 3.75Hz, while those in the lower visual field modulated at 3Hz. We find that responses to OFF/decrements are larger than ON/increments, especially in the lower visual field. In the lower visual field, both ON and OFF responses were well described by a sigmoidal non-linearity. In the upper visual field, the ON pathway function was very similar to that of the lower, but the OFF pathway function showed reduced saturation and more cross-subject variability. Overall, this demonstrates that the relationship between the ON and OFF pathways depends on the visual field location and contrast level, potentially reflective of natural scene statistics.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: understanding the response characteristics of the ON and OFF pathways in the visual pathway to different contrast stimuli in different visual areas (upper and lower visual fields), and how these characteristics affect visual function assessment. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Evaluate the functional differences between the ON and OFF pathways**: By measuring the steady - state visual evoked potential (SSVEP), the researchers hope to reveal the response characteristics of the ON and OFF pathways in the upper and lower visual fields and determine whether these pathways show asymmetry in different visual areas. 2. **Explore the nonlinear characteristics of the contrast - response function (CRF)**: The researchers used stimuli modulated by a sawtooth waveform to preferentially activate the ON or OFF pathways and simultaneously recorded the neural responses in the upper and lower visual fields by means of the frequency - tagging technique. The aim was to describe the contrast - response functions of the ON and OFF pathways and explore their nonlinear characteristics. 3. **Understand the influence of natural scene statistics on the visual pathway**: The study hypothesized that the information distribution in natural scenes may affect the adaptability of the visual pathway. Therefore, the researchers hope to verify this hypothesis through experimental data, that is, the asymmetry of the ON and OFF pathways may be to better handle the common contrast changes in natural scenes. 4. **Provide a basis for clinical diagnosis**: Since diseases such as glaucoma may lead to selective visual loss, understanding the functional differences between the ON and OFF pathways under normal conditions can provide new methods and tools for clinical diagnosis. ### Research Background In the visual system, the ON and OFF pathways encode light increments (brightening) and light decrements (darkening), respectively. Early studies showed that these two pathways are functionally symmetric, but more and more evidence suggests that they may be asymmetric. In particular, the response characteristics of the ON and OFF pathways in different visual areas (such as the upper and lower visual fields) may be different. In addition, the information distribution in natural scenes may also be one of the reasons for this asymmetry. ### Research Methods - **Participants**: A total of 27 participants were recruited. - **Visual Stimuli**: A flickering probe was presented using a hexagonal array, and the brightness of the probe was modulated according to a sawtooth waveform to preferentially activate the ON or OFF pathways. - **EEG Recording**: Electroencephalogram signals were recorded through a 128 - channel EGI HydroCel Sensor Net, and spectral analysis was performed using the recursive least - squares method (RLS). - **Data Analysis**: Dimensionality reduction was carried out through reliable component analysis (RCA), and a hyperbolic ratio function was fitted to describe the contrast - response functions of the ON and OFF pathways. ### Main Findings - In the lower visual field, the response of the OFF pathway is greater than that of the ON pathway, especially under high - contrast conditions. - The responses of the ON and OFF pathways in the lower visual field show obvious nonlinear characteristics, conforming to an S - shaped curve. - In the upper visual field, the response of the ON pathway is similar to that in the lower visual field, but the response saturation of the OFF pathway is lower and there are large differences among individuals. - These results indicate that the response characteristics of the ON and OFF pathways depend on the location of the visual area and the contrast level, which may reflect the statistical characteristics of natural scenes. ### Conclusion This study shows that there are significant differences in the response characteristics of the ON and OFF pathways in different visual areas, and these differences may be related to the information distribution in natural scenes. Understanding these differences is helpful for better simulating human behavior and providing a more detailed understanding for visual function assessment in pathological states (such as glaucoma).

Visual field asymmetries in responses to ON and OFF pathway biasing stimuli

Glaucoma classification through SSVEP derived ON- and OFF-pathway features

The Amblyopic Deficit for 2nd Order Processing: Generality and Laterality

Contrast Sensitivity of ON and OFF Human Retinal Pathways in Myopia

A Novel Motion-on-Color Paradigm for Isolating Magnocellular Pathway Function in Preperimetric Glaucoma

The ON-OFF dichotomy in visual processing: from receptors to perception

New methods for detection of early loss of rapid flicker, spatial vision, and chromatic sensitivity in glaucoma

Consistent metacognitive efficiency and variable response biases in peripheral vision

Mapping Visual Contrast Sensitivity and Vision Loss Across the Visual Field with Model-Based fMRI

Early Impairment of Magnocellular Visual Pathways Mediated by Isolated-Check Visual Evoked Potentials in Primary Open-Angle Glaucoma: a Cross-Sectional Study

Summation of Temporal L-Cone- and M-Cone-Contrast in the Magno- and Parvocellular Retino-Geniculate Systems in Glaucoma

Seeing with Prejudice: Inherent Biases in Connectivity Between Oriented and Luxotonic Cells

Spatial modulation of dark versus bright stimulus responses in the mouse visual system

Model-Based Approach Shows ON Pathway Afferents Elicit a Transient Decrease of V1 Responses

Asymmetric Activation of Retinal ON and OFF Pathways by AOSLO Raster-Scanned Visual Stimuli

Visual perception of motion, luminance and colour in a human hemianope

Retinal adaptation abnormalities in primary open-angle glaucoma

The value of assessing progressive loss of red/green and yellow/blue chromatic sensitivity in glaucoma

Light adaptation alters inner retinal inhibition to shape OFF retinal pathway signaling

Feedback from higher to lower visual areas for visual recognition may be weaker in the periphery: Glimpses from the perception of brief dichoptic stimuli.