Sex Differences in Human Brain Structure at Birth

Yumnah T. Khan,Alex Tsompanidis,Marcin A. Radecki,Lena Dorfschmidt,APEX Consortium,Topun Austin,John Suckling,Carrie Allison,Meng-Chuan Lai,Richard A.I. Bethlehem,Simon Baron-Cohen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.06.20.599872

2024-06-21

Abstract:Sex differences in human brain anatomy have been well-documented; however, their underlying causes remain controversial. Neonatal research offers a pivotal opportunity to address this long-standing debate. Given that postnatal environmental influences (e.g., gender socialisation) are minimal at birth, any sex differences observed at this stage can be more readily attributed to prenatal influences. Here, we assessed on-average sex differences in global and regional brain volumes in 514 newborns (236 birth-assigned females and 278 birth-assigned males) using data from the developing Human Connectome Project. On average, males had significantly larger intracranial and total brain volumes, even after controlling for birth weight. After controlling for total brain volume, females showed higher total cortical gray matter volumes, whilst males showed higher total white matter volumes. After controlling for total brain volume in regional comparisons, females had increased white matter volumes in the corpus callosum and increased gray matter volumes in the bilateral parahippocampal gyri (posterior parts), left anterior cingulate gyrus, bilateral parietal lobes, and right caudate nucleus. Males had increased gray matter volumes in the right medial and inferior temporal gyrus (posterior part) and right subthalamic nucleus. Effect sizes ranged from small for regional comparisons to large for global comparisons. While postnatal experiences likely amplify sex differences in the brain, our findings demonstrate that several global and regional on-average sex differences are already present at birth.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores gender differences in the brain structure of human newborns. Specifically, the research team aims to address the following key questions:

1. **Determine if gender differences exist at birth**: By studying the total and regional volumes of newborn brains to ascertain whether gender differences are already present at birth.

2. **Assess the magnitude of these differences**: By quantifying the average differences between male and female newborns in terms of total brain volume, cortical gray matter volume, white matter volume, and specific brain region volumes.

3. **Explore potential causes of gender differences**: Given that postnatal environmental factors (such as gender socialization) have relatively little influence, any gender differences observed in the study are more likely attributable to prenatal factors, which helps in understanding the origins of gender differences.

### Summary of Research Findings

- **Total Volume Differences**: The total brain volume and intracranial volume of male newborns are significantly larger than those of females, even when controlling for birth weight.

- **Cortical Gray Matter and White Matter Differences**: When controlling for total volume, females exhibit higher cortical gray matter volume, while males exhibit higher white matter volume.

- **Differences in Specific Brain Regions**: Females have higher white matter volume in the corpus callosum and higher gray matter volume in the bilateral parahippocampal gyrus (posterior), left anterior cingulate gyrus, bilateral parietal lobes, and left caudate nucleus compared to males. Males, on the other hand, have higher gray matter volume in the right middle and inferior temporal gyri (posterior) and the right basal forebrain nucleus compared to females.

- **Effect Size**: The effect size for total volume differences is relatively large, while the effect sizes for regional comparisons are relatively small.

In summary, the study reveals gender differences that are already present at birth and provides important clues for understanding the origins of these differences. These findings are significant for subsequent exploration of how gender differences influence neurodevelopment and disease susceptibility.