Abstract:DNA mixtures are a common sample type in forensic genetics, and we typically assume that contributors to the mixture are unrelated when calculating the likelihood ratio (LR). However, scenarios involving mixtures with related contributors, such as in family murder or incest cases, can also be encountered. Compared to the mixtures with unrelated contributors, the kinship within the mixture would bring additional challenges for the inference of the number of contributors (NOC) and the construction of probabilistic genotyping models. To evaluate the influence of potential kinship on the individual identification of the person of interest (POI), we conducted simulations of two-person (2 P) and three-person (3 P) DNA mixtures containing unrelated or related contributors (parent-child, full-sibling, and uncle-nephew) at different mixing ratios (for 2 P: 1:1, 4:1, 9:1, and 19:1; for 3 P: 1:1:1, 2:1:1, 5:4:1, and 10:5:1), and performed massively parallel sequencing (MPS) using MGIEasy Signature Identification Library Prep Kit on MGI platform. In addition, in silico simulations of mixtures with unrelated and related contributors were also performed. In this study, we evaluated 1): the MPS performance; 2) the influence of multiple genetic markers on determining the presence of related contributors and inferring the NOC within the mixture; 3) the probability distribution of MAC (maximum allele count) and TAC (total allele count) based on in silico mixture profiles; 4) trends in LR values with and without considering kinship in mixtures with related and unrelated contributors; 5) trends in LR values with length- and sequence-based STR genotypes. Results indicated that multiple numbers and types of genetic markers positively influenced kinship and NOC inference in a mixture. The LR values of POI were strongly dependent on the mixing ratio. Non- and correct-kinship hypotheses essentially did not affect the individual identification of the major POI; the correct kinship hypothesis yielded more conservative LR values; the incorrect kinship hypothesis did not necessarily lead to the failure of POI individual identification. However, it is noteworthy that these considerations could lead to uncertain outcomes in the identification of minor contributors. Compared to length-based STR genotyping, using sequence-based STR genotype increases the individual identification power of the POI, concurrently improving the accuracy of mixing ratio inference using EuroForMix. In conclusion, the MGIEasy Signature Identification Library Prep kit demonstrated robust individual identification power, which is a viable MPS panel for forensic DNA mixture interpretations, whether involving unrelated or related contributors.

On the limitations of probabilistic claims about the probative value of mixed DNA profile evidence

Complex DNA mixture analysis in a forensic context: evaluating the probative value using a likelihood ratio model

A review of likelihood ratios in forensic science based on a critique of Stiffelman "No longer the Gold standard: Probabilistic genotyping is changing the nature of DNA evidence in criminal trials"

Calculating the Likelihood Ratio for Multiple Pieces of Evidence

Interpreting forensic DNA mixtures: allowing for uncertainty in population substructure and dependence

A tale of two PG systems: A comparison of the two most widely used continuous probabilistic genotyping systems in the United States

Evidentiary evaluation of single cells renders highly informative forensic comparisons across multifarious admixtures

Encoding of low-quality DNA profiles as genotype probability matrices for improved profile comparisons, relatedness evaluation and database searches

DNA database matches: A p versus np problem

Non parametric Bayesian approach to LR assessment in case of rare haplotype match

Low LRs obtained from DNA mixtures: On calibration and discrimination performance of probabilistic genotyping software

On forensic likelihood ratios from low-coverage sequencing

Paternity testing and other inference about relationships from DNA mixtures

Applications of Probabilistic Genotyping Method for Combining Evidence Across Microhaplotype DNA Mixture Profiles

Searching national DNA databases with complex DNA profiles: an empirical study using probabilistic genotyping

Evaluation of DNA Mixtures from Database Search.

Comments arising from WJ Thompson "Uncertainty in probabilistic genotyping of low template DNA A case study comparing STRmix and TrueAllele"

Logical implications of applying the principles of population genetics to the interpretation of DNA profiling evidence

Assessing the Forensic Value of DNA Evidence from Y Chromosomes and Mitogenomes

Improved individual identification in DNA mixtures of unrelated or related contributors through massively parallel sequencing

Evidential strength of categorical expert witness statements