Gödel incompleteness through Arithmetic Universes after A. Joyal

Joost van Dijk,Alexander Gietelink Oldenziel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2004.10482

2020-04-22

Abstract:We give proofs of Gödel's incompleteness theorems after A. Joyal. The proof uses internal category theory in an arithmetic universe, a predicative generalisation of topoi. Applications to Löb's Theorem are discussed.

Category Theory,Logic

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Quotients, pure existential completions and arithmetic universes

Maria Emilia Maietti,Davide Trotta

2024-06-18

Abstract:We provide a new description of Joyal's arithmetic universes through a characterization of the exact and regular completions of pure existential completions. We show that the regular and exact completions of the pure existential completion of an elementary doctrine $P$ are equivalent to the $\mathsf{reg}/\mathsf{lex}$ and $\mathsf{ex}/\mathsf{lex}$-completions, respectively, of the category of predicates of $P$. This result generalizes a previous one by the first author with F. Pasquali and G. Rosolini about doctrines equipped with Hilbert's $\epsilon$-operators. Thanks to this characterization, each arithmetic universe in the sense of Joyal can be seen as the exact completion of the pure existential completion of the doctrine of predicates of its Skolem theory. In particular, the initial arithmetic universe in the standard category of ZFC-sets turns out to be the completion with exact quotients of the doctrine of recursively enumerable predicates.

Category Theory,Logic
Incompleteness theorems via Turing category

Yasha Savelyev

2024-12-19

Abstract:We give a reframing of Godel's first and second incompleteness theorems that applies even to some undefinable theories of arithmetic. The usual Hilbert-Bernays provability conditions and the diagonal lemma are replaced by a more direct diagonalization argument, from first principles, based in category theory and in a sense analogous to Cantor's original argument. To this end, we categorify the theory Gödel encodings, which might be of independent interest. In our setup, the Gödel sentence is computable explicitly by construction even for $\Sigma ^{0} _{2}$ theories (likely extending to $\Sigma ^{0} _{n}$). In an appendix, we study the relationship of our reframed second incompleteness theorem with arguments of Penrose.

Logic,Logic in Computer Science
A common Misconception about the Categorical Arithmetic

Giuseppe Raguní

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1602.03389

2016-01-13

Abstract:Although the categorical arithmetic is not effectively axiomatizable, the belief that the incompleteness Theorems can be apply to it is fairly common. Furthermore, the so-called "essential" (or "inherent") semantic incompleteness of the second-order Logic that can be deduced by these same Theorems does not imply the standard semantic incompleteness that can be derived using the Loewenheim-Skolem or the compactness Theorem. This state of affairs has its origins in an incorrect and misinterpreted Goedel's comment at the Koenigsberg congress of 1930 and has consolidated due to different circumstances. This paper aims to clear up these questions and proposes an alternative interpretation for the Goedel's statement.

General Mathematics
Epistemological Consequences of the Incompleteness Theorems

Giuseppe Raguní

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1602.03390

2016-01-13

Abstract:After highlighting the cases in which the semantics of a language cannot be mechanically reproduced (in which case it is called inherent), the main epistemological consequences of the first incompleteness Theorem for the two fundamental arithmetical theories are shown: the non-mechanizability for the truths of the first-order arithmetic and the peculiarities for the model of the second-order arithmetic. Finally, the common epistemological interpretation of the second incompleteness Theorem is corrected, proposing the new "Metatheorem of undemonstrability of internal consistency".

General Mathematics
An Intuitively Complete Analysis of Godel's Incompleteness

Jason W. Steinmetz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1512.03667

2020-04-29

Abstract:A detailed and rigorous analysis of Gödel's proof of his first incompleteness theorem is presented. The purpose of this analysis is two-fold. The first is to reveal what Gödel actually proved to provide a clear and solid foundation upon which to base future research. The second is to construct a coherent explication of Gödel's proof that is not only approachable by the non-specialist, but also brings to light the core principles underlying Gödel's proof.

Logic,Logic in Computer Science
The Geometric Completion of a Doctrine

Joshua Wrigley

2023-04-15

Abstract:As several different formal systems with inequivalent syntax may describe equivalent semantics, it is possible to find `completions' to more expressive syntaxes that are semantically invariant. Doctrine theory, in the sense of Lawvere, is the natural categorical framework in which to express completions for first-order logic. We study the suitability of a fibred generalisation of the ideal completion of a preorder to act as a completion for doctrines to the syntax of geometric logic. In contrast to other completions of doctrines considered in the literature, our completion takes a Grothendieck topology as a second argument. As a result, the geometric completion is idempotent, as well as being `semantically invariant' for any doctrine whose models can be expressed as a category of continuous flat functors, encompassing a wide class of the most commonly considered doctrines. We also relate the geometric completion to other completions of doctrines considered in the literature: first, by studying the behaviour of the geometric completion when the second argument is omitted, and then by studying the interaction with those completions of doctrines that complete to a fragment of geometric logic. Throughout, we reference how these completions of doctrines yield completions of categories via the syntactic category construction. We demonstrate that it is equivalent to represent logical theories by either doctrines or syntactic categories, in so far as they have equivalent classifying toposes.

Category Theory,Logic
Geometric realisations of the unipotent enveloping algebra of a quiver

Lucien Hennecart

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aim.2024.109536

IF: 1.675

2024-04-01

Advances in Mathematics

Abstract:We compare and generalise the various geometric constructions (due to Ringel, Lusztig, Schofield, Bozec, Davison...) of the unipotent generalised Kac–Moody algebra associated with an arbitrary quiver. These constructions are interconnected through several geometric operations, including the stalk Euler characteristic of constructible complexes, the characteristic cycle, the Euler obstruction map, and the intersection multiplicities of Lagrangian subvarieties. We provide a proof that these geometric realisations hold for the integral form of the Lie algebra. Furthermore, by modifying the generators of the enveloping algebra, we ensure compatibility with the natural coproducts that can be defined in terms of restriction diagrams. As a result, we establish that the top cohomological Hall algebra of the strictly seminilpotent stack is isomorphic to the positive part of the enveloping algebra of the generalised Kac-Moody algebra associated with the quiver. This appears to be one of the cornerstones needed to describe the BPS algebra of very general 2-Calabi–Yau categories, which is the subject of the author's work on BPS Lie algebras for 2-Calabi–Yau categories with Davison and Schlegel Mejia.

mathematics
The internal languages of univalent categories

Niels van der Weide

2024-11-11

Abstract:Internal language theorems are fundamental in categorical logic, since they express an equivalence between syntax and semantics. One of such theorems was proven by Clairambault and Dybjer, who corrected the result originally by Seely. More specifically, they constructed a biequivalence between the bicategory of locally Cartesian closed categories and the bicategory of democratic categories with families with extensional identity types, $\sum$-types, and $\prod$-types. This theorem expresses that the internal language of locally Cartesian closed is extensional Martin-Löf type theory with dependent sums and products. In this paper, we study the theorem by Clairambault and Dybjer for univalent categories, and we extend it to various classes of toposes, among which are $\prod$-pretoposes and elementary toposes. The results in this paper have been formalized using the proof assistant Coq and the UniMath library.

Category Theory,Logic in Computer Science
A classification of incompleteness statements

Henry Towsner,James Walsh

2024-09-10

Abstract:For which choices of $X,Y,Z\in\{\Sigma^1_1,\Pi^1_1\}$ does no sufficiently strong $X$-sound and $Y$-definable extension theory prove its own $Z$-soundness? We give a complete answer, thereby delimiting the generalizations of Gödel's second incompleteness theorem that hold within second-order arithmetic.

Logic
Gödel's Program in Set Theory

Sandra Müller,Grigor Sargsyan

2024-12-10

Abstract:Gödel proved in the 1930s in his famous Incompleteness Theorems that not all statements in mathematics can be proven or disproven from the accepted ZFC axioms. A few years later he showed the celebrated result that Cantor's Continuum Hypothesis is consistent. Afterwards, Gödel raised the question whether, despite the fact that there is no reasonable axiomatic framework for all mathematical statements, natural statements, such as Cantor's Continuum Hypothesis, can be decided via extending ZFC by large cardinal axioms. While this question has been answered negatively, the problem of finding good axioms that decide natural mathematical statements remains open. There is a compelling candidate for an axiom that could solve Gödel's problem: V = Ultimate-L. In addition, due to recent results the Sealing scenario has gained a lot of attention. We describe these candidates as well as their impact and relationship.

Logic
Incompleteness of boundedly axiomatizable theories

Ali Enayat,Albert Visser

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1090/proc/16975

IF: 0.9709

2024-09-21

Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society

Abstract:Our main result (Theorem A) shows the incompleteness of any consistent sequential theory T T formulated in a finite language such that T T is axiomatized by a collection of sentences of bounded quantifier-alternation-depth. Our proof employs an appropriate reduction mechanism to rule out the possibility of completeness by simply invoking Tarski's Undefinability of Truth theorem. We also use the proof strategy of Theorem A to obtain other incompleteness results.

mathematics, applied
Nonstandard proof methods in toposes

José Siqueira

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apal.2024.103424

IF: 0.776

2024-02-23

Annals of Pure and Applied Logic

Abstract:We determine sufficient structure for an elementary topos to emulate Nelson's Internal Set Theory in its internal language, and show that any topos satisfying the internal axiom of choice occurs as a universe of standard objects and maps. This development allows one to employ the proof methods of nonstandard analysis (transfer, standardisation, and idealisation) in new environments such as toposes of G -sets and Boolean étendues.

mathematics, applied,logic
Yablo's Paradox And Arithmetical Incompleteness

Graham Leach-Krouse

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1110.2056

2011-12-18

Abstract:In this short paper, I present a few theorems on sentences of arithmetic which are related to Yablo's Paradox as Gödel's first undecidable sentence was related to the Liar paradox. In particular, I consider two different arithemetizations of Yablo's sentences: one resembling Gödel's arithmetization of the Liar, with the negation outside of the provability predicate, one resembling Jeroslow's undecidable sentence, with negation inside. Both kinds of arithmetized Yablo sentence are undecidable, and connected to the consistency sentence for the ambient formal system in roughly the same manner as Gödel and Jeroslow's sentences. Finally, I consider a sentence which is related to the Henkin sentence "I am provable" in the same way that first two arithmetizations are related to Gödel and Jeroslow's sentences. I show that this sentence is provable, using Löb's theorem, as in the standard proof of the Henkin sentence.

Logic
Elementary Quotient Completions, Church's Thesis, and Partioned Assemblies

Maria Emilia Maietti,Fabio Pasquali,Giuseppe Rosolini

DOI: https://doi.org/10.23638/LMCS-15%282%3A21%292019

2019-06-22

Abstract:Hyland's effective topos offers an important realizability model for constructive mathematics in the form of a category whose internal logic validates Church's Thesis. It also contains a boolean full sub-quasitopos of "assemblies" where only a restricted form of Church's Thesis survives. In the present paper we compare the effective topos and the quasitopos of assemblies each as the elementary quotient completions of a Lawvere doctrine based on the partitioned assemblies. In that way we can explain why the two forms of Church's Thesis each category satisfies differ by the way each is inherited from specific properties of the doctrine which determines the elementary quotient completion.

Logic
Teaching G{ö}del's incompleteness theorems

Gilles Dowek

2023-03-31

Abstract:The basic notions of logic-predicate logic, Peano arithmetic, incompleteness theorems, etc.-have for long been an advanced topic. In the last decades, they became more widely taught, inphilosophy, mathematics, and computer science departments, to graduate and to undergraduate students. Many textbooks now present these notions, in particular the incompleteness theorems. Having taught these notions for several decades, our community can now stand back and analyze the choices faced when designing such a course. In this note, we attempt to analyze the choices faced when teaching the incompleteness theorems.

History and Overview,Logic in Computer Science
The Unreasonable Efficacy of the Lifting Condition in Higher Categorical Galois Theory I: a Quasi-categorical Galois Theorem

Joseph Rennie

2024-09-05

Abstract:In (Borceux-Janelidze 2001) they prove a Categorical Galois Theorem for ordinary categories, and establish the main result of (Joyal-Tierney 1984), along with the classical Galois theory of Rings, as instances of this more general result. The main result of the present work refines this to a Quasicategorical Galois Theorem, by drawing heavily on the foundation laid in (Lurie 2024). More importantly, the argument used to prove the result is intended to highlight a deep connection between factorization systems (specifically the lex modalities of (Anel-Biedermann-Finster-Joyal 2021)), higher-categorical Galois Theorems, and Galois theories internal to higher toposes. This is the first part in a series of works, intended merely to motivate the lens and prove Theorem 3.4. In future work, we will delve into a generalization of the argument, and offer tools for producing applications.

Category Theory
What If Turing Had Preceded Gödel?

Sebastian Oberhoff

2024-04-18

Abstract:The overarching theme of the following pages is that mathematical logic -- centered around the incompleteness theorems -- is first and foremost an investigation of $\textit{computation}$, not arithmetic. Guided by this intuition we will show the following. * First, we'll all but eliminate the need for Gödel numbers. * Next, we'll introduce a novel notational device for representable functions and walk through a condensed demonstration that Peano Arithmetic can represent every computable function. It has achieved Turing completeness. * Continuing, we'll derive the Diagonal Lemma and First Incompleteness Theorem using significantly simplified proofs. * Approaching the Second Incompleteness Theorem, we'll be able to use some self-referential trickery to avoid much of the technical morass surrounding it; arriving at three separate versions. * Extending the analogy between the First Incompleteness Theorem and the Unsolvability of the Halting Problem produces an equivalent of the Nondeterministic Time Hierarchy Theorem from the field of computational complexity. * Lastly, we'll briefly peer into the realm of the uncomputable by connecting our ideas to oracles.

Computational Complexity,Logic in Computer Science
Composition series of arbitrary cardinality in modular lattices and abelian categories

Eric J. Hanson,J. Daisie Rock

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aim.2023.109292

2023-09-14

Abstract:For a certain family of complete modular lattices, we prove a Jordan--Hölder--Scheier-like" theorem with no assumptions on cardinality or well-orderedness. This family includes both lattices which are both join- and meet-continuous, as well as the lattices of subobjects of any object in an abelian category satisfying properties related to Grothendieck's axioms (AB5) and (AB5*). We then give several examples of objects in abelian categories which satisfy these axioms, including pointwise finite-dimensional persistence modules, presheaves, and certain Prüfer modules. Moreover, we show that, over an arbitrary ring, the infinite product of isomorphic simple modules both fails to satisfy our axioms and admits at least two composition series with distinct cardinalities. We conclude by giving a lattice-theoretic proof that any object which is locally finitely generated and satisfies our axioms can be expressed as a direct sum of indecomposable subobjects. We conjecture that this decomposition is unique.

Category Theory,Representation Theory
Existentially closed De Morgan algebras

Vahagn Aslanyan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1810.02335

2019-11-08

Abstract:We show that the theory of De Morgan algebras has a model completion and axiomatise it. Then we prove that it is $\aleph_0$-categorical and describe definable and algebraic closures in that theory. We also obtain similar results for Boole-De Morgan algebras.

Logic

Gödel incompleteness through Arithmetic Universes after A. Joyal

Quotients, pure existential completions and arithmetic universes

Incompleteness theorems via Turing category

A common Misconception about the Categorical Arithmetic

Epistemological Consequences of the Incompleteness Theorems

An Intuitively Complete Analysis of Godel's Incompleteness

The Geometric Completion of a Doctrine

Geometric realisations of the unipotent enveloping algebra of a quiver

The internal languages of univalent categories

A classification of incompleteness statements

Gödel's Program in Set Theory

Incompleteness of boundedly axiomatizable theories

Nonstandard proof methods in toposes

Yablo's Paradox And Arithmetical Incompleteness

Elementary Quotient Completions, Church's Thesis, and Partioned Assemblies

Teaching G{ö}del's incompleteness theorems

The Unreasonable Efficacy of the Lifting Condition in Higher Categorical Galois Theory I: a Quasi-categorical Galois Theorem

What If Turing Had Preceded Gödel?

Composition series of arbitrary cardinality in modular lattices and abelian categories

Existentially closed De Morgan algebras