Abstract:The navigational mechanisms of homing pigeons, Columba livia, have been extensively studied and represent a useful model for the navigation of birds and other animals. Pigeons navigate with an olfactory map and sun compass from unfamiliar areas and, in familiar areas, are largely guided by visual landscape cues, following stereotyped and idiosyncratic routes. However, the mechanisms by which they gain familiarity, improve their navigation and transition between navigational strategies during learning are not fully understood. Addressing these outstanding questions in this navigational model will help to improve our understanding of navigational ontogeny. We sought to investigate whether passive exposure to the cues at a site, without release, was sufficient for navigational learning, given that pigeons can determine the home direction before taking off. We exposed pigeons to cues at a novel site before returning them to the site the next day and releasing them alongside controls. We found no differences in the directional distributions, mean vector lengths, virtual vanishing times, efficiency indices or homing efficiency indices between birds that had and had not previously visited the site. We therefore found no evidence to suggest that passive exposure to the cues at a novel site was sufficient to facilitate a detectable improvement in navigational performance. There are three possible explanations for this result: first, a larger sample size would have detected a weak effect of learning; second, passive exposure to a release site is insufficient to generate navigational learning; and third, pigeons learn from passive exposure but do not rely upon this information, showing no difference in performance, despite learning. We discuss these three explanations with reference to previous findings on navigational learning in homing pigeons. We suggest that experiments should continue to examine navigational ontogeny in homing pigeons to help address this major problem for the field of navigation.

The problem with two-event sequence learning by pigeons

Serial pattern learning: The anticipation of worsening conditions by pigeons

Serial pattern learning: Pigeons ( Columba livia ) prefer an improving schedule over an initially easier fixed ratio schedule.

Exploring boundary conditions of the single-code/default strategy in pigeons

Discriminative proprieties of Vary and Repeat contingencies

An analysis of coordinated responding of pigeons

Rats' performance in a suboptimal choice procedure implemented in a natural-foraging analogue

Skinner-Pigeon Experiment Simulated Based on Probabilistic Automata

Discrimination of complex human behavior by pigeons (Columba livia) and humans

On the value of advanced information about delayed rewards

Reinforcer control by comparison-stimulus color and location in a delayed matching-to-sample task

Executive Control of Sequence Behavior in Pigeons Involves Two Distinct Brain Regions

Information, certainty, and learning.

Cost does not prevent pigeons from investing in the future.

Homing pigeon navigational ontogeny: no evidence that exposure to a novel release site is sufficient for learning

From Learning to Choosing: How Decision-Making Evolves with Experience in Rats

Temporal context effects on suboptimal choice

Learning about trial sequences disrupts the partial reinforcement extinction effect in classical conditioning.

Recurrent networks endowed with structural priors explain suboptimal animal behavior

Why Does Dual-Tasking Hamper Implicit Sequence Learning?

Performance errors during rodent learning reflect a dynamic choice strategy