Abstract:The ability to flexibly switch our response to external stimuli according to contextual information is critical for successful interactions with a complex world. Context-dependent computations are necessary across many domains 1–3 , yet their neural implementations remain poorly understood. Here we developed a novel behavioral task in rats to study context-dependent selection and accumulation of evidence for decision-making 4−6 . Under assumptions supported by both monkey and rat data, we first show mathematically that this computation can be supported by three dynamical solutions, and all networks performing the task implement a combination of these solutions. These solutions can be identified and tested directly with experimental data. We further show that existing electrophysiological and modeling data are compatible with the full variety of possible combinations of these solutions, suggesting that different individuals could use different combinations. To study variability across individual subjects, we developed automated, high-throughput methods to train rats on our task, and we trained many subjects on it. Consistent with theoretical predictions, neural and behavioral analyses revealed substantial heterogeneity across rats, despite uniformly good task performance. Our theory further predicts a specific link between behavioral and neural signatures, which was robustly supported in the data. In summary, our results provide a new experimentally-supported theoretical framework to analyze individual variability in biological and artificial systems performing flexible decision-making tasks, they open the door to cellular-resolution studies of individual variability in higher cognition, and they provide insights into neural mechanisms of context-dependent computation more generally.

From Learning to Choosing: How Decision-Making Evolves with Experience in Rats

Learning to Choose: Behavioral Dynamics Underlying the Initial Acquisition of Decision-Making

Learning to Choose: Behavioral Dynamics Underlying the Initial Acquisition of Decision Making

Extracting the dynamics of behavior in sensory decision-making experiments

Rats and Humans Can Optimally Accumulate Evidence for Decision-Making

Rats optimally accumulate and discount evidence in a dynamic environment

From innate to instructed: A new look at perceptual decision-making

Individual variability of neural computations underlying flexible decisions

Behavior of Rats in a Self-Paced Risky Decision-Making Task Based on Definite Probability

Learning the structure of the world: The adaptive nature of state-space and action representations in multi-stage decision-making

The Role of the Rat Prefrontal Cortex and Sex Differences in Decision-Making

Onboard Sensors Reveal New Insights into Animal Decision-Making

Training a Two-Choice Decision-Making Model with Environment Feedback.

Individual differences in decision-making shape how mesolimbic dopamine regulates choice confidence and change-of-mind

Serial decision-making in monkeys during an oculomotor task.

Insight into differing decision-making strategies that underlie cognitively effort-based decision making using computational modeling in rats

Performance errors during rodent learning reflect a dynamic choice strategy

A Possible Neural Circuit for Decision Making and Its Learning Process.

Internal states emerge early during learning of a perceptual decision-making task

A Decision-Making Model Based on a Spiking Neural Circuit and Synaptic Plasticity.

A new theoretical framework jointly explains behavioral and neural variability across subjects performing flexible decision-making