Abstract:Introduction: Renewal of extinguished responses is associated with higher activity in specific extinction-relevant brain regions, i.e., hippocampus (HC), inferior frontal gyrus (IFG), and ventromedial PFC (vmPFC). HC is involved in processing of context information, while IFG and vmPFC use such context information for selecting and deciding among competing response options. However, it is as yet unknown to what extent trials with changed versus unchanged outcome, or extinction trials that evoke renewal (i.e., extinction context differs from acquisition and test context: ABA trials) and trials that do not (i.e., same context in all phases: AAA trials) are represented differentially in extinction-relevant brain regions. Methods: In this study, we applied representational similarity analysis (RSA) to determine differences in neural representations of these trial types and their relationship to extinction error rates and renewal level. Results: Overall, individuals with renewal (REN) and those without (NoREN) did not differ significantly in their discrimination levels between ABA and AAA extinction trials, with the exception of right posterior HC, where REN exhibited more pronounced context-related discrimination. In addition, higher dissimilarity of representations in bilateral posterior HC, as well as in several IFG regions, during extinction learning was linked to lower ABA renewal rates. Both REN and NoREN benefitted from prediction error feedback from ABA extinction errors for context- and outcome-related discrimination of trials in IFG, vmPFC, and HC, but only the NoREN group also benefitted from error feedback from AAA extinction errors. Discussion: Thus, while in both groups the presence of a novel context supported formation of distinct representations, only in NoREN the expectancy violation of the surprising change of outcome alone had a similar effect. In addition, only in NoREN context-related discrimination was linked to error feedback in vmPFC. In summary, the findings show that context- and outcome-related discrimination of trials in HC, vmPFC, and IFG is linked to extinction learning errors, regardless of renewal propensity, and at the same time point towards differential context processing strategies in REN and NoREN. Moreover, better discrimination of context-related trials during extinction learning promotes less renewal during extinction recall, suggesting that renewal may be related to suboptimal context-related trial discrimination.

Learning about trial sequences disrupts the partial reinforcement extinction effect in classical conditioning.

Effect of continuous and partial reinforcement on the acquisition and extinction of human conditioned fear.

Increasing previous but not concurrent extinction attenuates the "extinction makes acquisition context specific" effect in human predictive learning.

Prediction error determines how memories are organized in the brain: a study of Pavlovian fear extinction in rats

Contextual modulation of human associative learning following novelty-facilitated extinction, counterconditioning, and conventional extinction.

Prelimbic corticopontine neurons gate extinction learning

Acquisition With Partial and Continuous Reinforcement in Rat Magazine Approach.

The role of the medial prefrontal cortex in trace fear extinction

Congruency sequence effects and previous response times: conflict adaptation or temporal learning?

Slower reacquisition after partial extinction in human contingency learning.

Dissimilarities of neural representations of extinction trials are associated with extinction learning performance and renewal level

Uncertainty-Dependent Extinction of Fear Memory in an Amygdala-mPFC Neural Circuit Model

Both probability and rate of reinforcement can affect the acquisition and maintenance of conditioned responses.

A preliminary study of training conditions necessary for secondary reinforcement.

Working Memory and Reinforcement Schedule Jointly Determine Reinforcement Learning in Children: Potential Implications for Behavioral Parent Training

Precedence-effect-induced enhancement of prepulse inhibition in socially reared but not isolation-reared rats

Infralimbic cortex plays a similar role in the punishment and extinction of instrumental behavior

Explaining the effectiveness of fear extinction through latent-cause inference

Why Does Dual-Tasking Hamper Implicit Sequence Learning?

Lack of medial prefrontal cortex activation underlies the immediate extinction deficit