Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this paper is twofold. First, the authors investigate a firm’s decision to provide a CSR report, and if so, whether to have the report assured and to seek higher quality assurance as reflected through the choices of the scope of the assurance and type of assurer, Big 4 accounting firm vs specialist consultant. Second, the authors investigate the impact of voluntary assurance of CSR reports, assurance scope and type of assurer on the likelihood of inclusion in the DJSI and on market valuation. Design/methodology/approach The study’s sample consists of 17,050 firm-year observations from 40 countries with CSR reports available from Corporate Register and ESG metrics available from ASSET4 over the period 2009–2015. The study first empirically examines the associations between CSR commitment and each of CSR report provision, CSR report assurance, assurance scope and type of assurer. It then examines that association between both inclusion in the DJSI and market valuation with each of CSR report assurance, assurance scope and type of assurer, using inclusion in the DJSI as an objective measure of a firm’s reputation for sustainability given its recognition as a leading indicator for corporate sustainability and market valuation as a reflection of the broader set of capital market participants. Findings The authors establish two key findings consistent with the predictions of signaling theory. First, we show that high CSR commitment firms are more likely to: provide standalone CSR reports; obtain assurance; obtain assurance from a Big 4 accounting firm; and, adopt higher assurance scope. Second, the authors find that both CSR report assurance and assurance scope increase the likelihood of inclusion in the DJSI, but that the type of assurance provider does not. Alternatively, the authors find that capital market participants appear to value the provision of a CSR report only when it is assured by a Big 4 accounting firm. Originality/value The results in the existing literature exploring the capital market benefits to CSR Assurance have been mixed. Firms that voluntarily obtain CSR Assurance incur a cost in doing so and must perceive a net benefit from obtaining such assurance. Despite the limited guidance currently provided by existing CSR standards, we establish the existence of benefits to obtaining CSR Assurance in terms of enhanced likelihood of DJSI inclusion and, more generally, enhanced market valuation. The discussions with DJSI analysts indicate that CSR assurance does enhance the perceived reliability of CSR data, thus improving user confidence.

Corporate Environmental Reports: The Need for Standards and an Environmental Assurance Service

Determinants of corporate environmental reporting: the importance of environmental performance and assurance

Are third-party assurances preferable to third-party comments for promoting financial accountability in environmental reporting?

Are the Environmental Accounting and Report Informative?

How to Fix ESG Reporting

The Economic Consequences of Voluntary Environmental Information Disclosure

Incentives and disincentives for corporate environmental disclosure

Causes and consequences of voluntary assurance of CSR reports

Corporate accountability and the physical environment: Social responsibility and accounting beyond profit

Accounting for Society: Examining the Interplay between Financial Reporting and Social Responsibility

Navigating the Challenges of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Reporting: The Path to Broader Sustainable Development

Analysis of corporate environmental reports using statistical techniques and data mining

Making the grade: An analysis of sustainability reporting standards and Global Reporting Initiative adherence ratings

Where firms choose to disclose voluntary environmental information

Do Firms Follow through on Environmental Commitments? An Empirical Examination

Environmental Management Accounting: Assist in Quantifying Corporate Environmental Information Disclosure

Integrating corporate sustainability reporting and environmental management systems into environmental performance management: an audit perspective

Assuring the unknowable: a reflection on the evolving landscape of sustainability assurance for financial auditors

The Decision to Disclose Environmental Information: A Research Review and Agenda

Does Voluntary ESG Reporting Resolve Disagreement among ESG Rating Agencies?

Institutional pressures and the accounting and reporting of environmental liabilities