Hospital leaders warned that failure to recall striking doctors risked patient safety in some trusts, documents show

Gareth Iacobucci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q740

2024-03-27

BMJ

Abstract:Documents obtained by The BMJ have shed new light on the process of derogation, which is designed to protect patients during industrial action by health workers. Gareth Iacobucci reports

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

NHS England and trusts are undermining process for recalling striking doctors, says BMA

Abi Rimmer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q18

2024-01-05

BMJ

Abstract:NHS England and some NHS trusts are undermining the process for recalling striking junior doctors in unexpected and extreme circumstances, placing the BMA in an "impossible situation," the union has said.Junior doctors in England began a six day strike—the longest single walkout in NHS history—at 7 am on Wednesday 3 January.1When the dispute between the government and junior doctors began last year, the BMA said it had agreed with NHS England a voluntary process for recalling striking junior doctors to work in the event of safety concerns arising from "unexpected and extreme circumstances" unrelated to industrial action. This process is called a derogation.The BMA said the process had worked well in all previous rounds of strike action. However, during the current round of industrial action NHS England and some trusts had requested derogations without providing the BMA with the information it needed to recall striking doctors, it said.In a letter...

medicine, general & internal
Junior doctors' strike: NHS England to gather information on service impact

Abi Rimmer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q29

2024-01-06

BMJ

Abstract:NHS England has said it will gather information on whether refusals by the BMA to recall striking doctors to work has affected services. Junior doctors in England began a six day strike—the longest single walkout in NHS history—at 7 am on Wednesday 3 January. On 4 January NHS England wrote to the BMA to respond to concerns raised by the union that NHS England and some NHS trust were undermining the process for recalling striking doctors, called derogations.1 NHS England said that during the industrial action its priority was to support local leaders to do whatever was necessary to maintain safe care for patients and that the process for submitting requests for patient safety mitigations (derogations) was a "critical component of this." It said it was "regrettable" that the BMA had questioned "the integrity and motive of local clinical leaders—some of whom are likely to be BMA members—who are...

medicine, general & internal
Patient safety concerns were chief reason for strike suspension, says BMA

Susan Mayor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i4844

2016-01-01

Abstract:The BMA’s cancellation of next week’s five day strike by junior doctors in England was primarily due to warnings from trainees, senior doctors, and NHS managers that the safety of patients would be put at greater risk than in previous strikes, because of the strike’s longer duration and the shorter notice given by the BMA of the action.The BMA said in a statement on Monday 5 September that although it had provided more than the legally required seven days’ notice NHS England said that it needed more time to plan for escalated action.1The BMA’s Junior Doctors Committee called the strike on Wednesday 31 August, giving the NHS 12 days to prepare for full withdrawal of junior doctors’ labour between 8 am and 5 pm for five consecutive weekdays from 12 to 16 September. Previous strikes each lasted for a maximum of 48 hours and gave longer notice.2 …
Strike escalation and seasonal pressures create perfect storm for the NHS

Saffron Cordery

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q168

2024-01-23

BMJ

Abstract:New year, same industrial dispute. We were just three days into 2024 when junior doctors embarked on a six-day strike—the longest ever in the NHS.The timing could not have been more challenging for trusts, already wrestling with seasonal pressures and staffing shortages. Turnout was high, reflecting the strength of feeling that remains among junior doctors. But the impact of this walkout, compounded by a surge in flu and covid-19, has whipped up a perfect storm for the NHS. It is one that trusts will find increasingly hard to weather until both sides of the dispute—the government and the British Medical Association (BMA)—break through their impasse.During this historic strike, as with all strikes, patient safety remained trusts' number one priority. But the escalated length and timing proved especially tough for trust leaders, who worked hard to safeguard emergency and critical care services for the most vulnerable patients.Owing to their substantial worry...

medicine, general & internal
Steady undermining of the UK National Health Service underlies industrial action by doctors and other staff

John Wl Puntis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.20529/IJME.2024.027

Abstract:Erosion of standard of healthcare in the United Kingdom underlies the industrial action taken recently by staff in the publicly provided National Health Service. Underfunding and understaffing, largely as a consequence of neoliberal government "austerity" policies implemented following the 2007-08 banking crisis, together with lack of long-term planning and a drive towards outsourcing, have led to a deterioration in the quality of services. Reduction in bed numbers and neglect of community and social support have compounded problems by making it more difficult both to admit and to discharge patients in a timely fashion. Access to services has been compromised with negative consequences for the sick. Reduction of doctors' real wages together with stress at work, moral injury caused by feelings of not being able to do the best for patients, burnout from the Covid-19 pandemic and uncertainty about the future have led to the longest ever strike action by junior doctors in England.
Doctors' leaders welcome "long overdue" plans to regulate NHS managers

Gareth Iacobucci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2648

2024-11-28

BMJ

Abstract:NHS managers who silence whistleblowing doctors or endanger patients through misconduct could be sacked and permanently barred from working in the NHS, under new proposals.Regulating health service managers for the first time will tackle a "culture of cover up" that has been present in numerous patient safety scandals in recent years, the government said. Health minister Karin Smyth, said, "To turn around our NHS we need the best and brightest managing the health service, a culture of transparency that keeps patients safe, and an end to the revolving door that allows failed managers to pick up in a new NHS organisation."Proposed options for regulating NHS managers include statutory mechanisms that would place legal obligations on employers to prevent certain managers working in the health service, full statutory registration of NHS managers, which would require them to register with a regulator, or an accredited voluntary register on which managers could choose...

medicine, general & internal
Northern Ireland: Junior doctors on picket line are at "breaking point"

Emma Wilkinson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q597

2024-03-09

BMJ

Abstract:Junior doctors in Northern Ireland have said that they went on strike this week to protect patient care amid a "haemorrhaging" of doctors to countries with better pay and conditions.Speaking to The BMJ from the picket line on 6 March during a 24 hour walkout at Ulster Hospital in Belfast, doctors said that they were at breaking point. This is the first time junior doctors in Northern Ireland have gone on strike, after 97.6% voted in favour of taking industrial action in a BMA ballot on pay restoration.Rebecca Mercer, a foundation year 2 (FY2) doctor currently working in the emergency department, had come to support the strike in between two night shifts. She said, "Conditions have got to the point where we can't carry on any further. We're all under so much pressure and so much stress that people are near breaking point and are looking for other options elsewhere."Doctors...

medicine, general & internal
Strike? – and what about clinical education?

Simon Gay

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14739879.2023.2194266

2023-04-01

Education for Primary Care

Abstract:As I write this editorial, at this precise moment in time in the UK junior doctors are on strike. This comes shortly after the multiple strike actions of other healthcare professionals within the British National Health System.
Any NHS reform has to avoid a repeat of 2012

Tom Moberly

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2041

2024-09-20

BMJ

Abstract:The BMA and the UK government have finally agreed about something—two things, in fact: a new pay deal and the need for major reform of the NHS.After 44 days of strike action over the past two years, resident doctors (as junior doctors will now be known) have voted to accept the government's latest pay offer, with two thirds of those who voted backing the deal (doi:10.1136/bmj.q2038).1The BMA and the government also agreed that Ara Darzi's report on the state of the health service in England underlines the fact that far reaching change is needed (doi:10.1136/bmj.q2001 doi:10.1136/bmj.q2032 doi:10.1136/bmj.q2009).234 "Without radical action, the NHS won't survive," said the BMA's council chair, Philip Banfield, in response to the review, while the prime minister, Keir Starmer, said that the health service must "reform or die."One of many failings that Darzi highlights is the wellbeing of health service staff. "Every day, more than a million...

medicine, general & internal
BMA enters dispute with NHS trust over plans to cut doctor overtime rates

Elisabeth Mahase

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2489

2024-11-13

BMJ

Abstract:The BMA has entered into a formal dispute with University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust (UHB) over its plans to cut overtime rates for doctors.The trust told doctors last week that it would no longer pay enhanced rates for work carried out outside contracted hours and would instead pay basic salary rates. The BMA said it has since given UHB "several opportunities to reverse that decision and avoid patient care being impacted by the trusts' failure to pay their doctors fairly for extra shifts" but that the trust has "chosen not to respond."The BMA accused the trust of contravening a national agreement the association made with the Department of Health and Social Care earlier this year when settling industrial disputes, which included an agreement that rates for extra contractual work would be negotiated at a local level rather than imposed by trusts on doctors.As a result, the BMA has now...

medicine, general & internal
Why The BMJ will no longer report on unsubstantiated press releases

Kamran Abbasi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.o1878

2022-07-28

The BMJ

Abstract:When do you say enough is enough? Doctors and other UK public sector workers have concluded that time is now, in a pay dispute that will turn a long hot summer into an autumn and winter of discontent (doi:10.1136/bmj.o1859, doi:10.1136/bmj.o1868, doi:10.1136/bmj.o1872, doi:10.1136/bmj.o1873).1234 Workforce pressures and staff burnout are at unprecedented levels (doi:10.1136/bmj.o1866, doi:10.1136/bmj.o1796).56 NHS restructuring is understandably met with "change fatigue" (doi:10.1136/bmj.o1765).7 The effect on staff manifests in worse outcomes and frustrating experiences for patients, the self evident logic of which seems to escape the people in power. "If you want a picture of the future," wrote George Orwell in 1984, "imagine a boot stamping on a human face—for ever."It seems Orwell was imagining health services in 2022. The positive focus on health at the start of the covid pandemic is now replaced by policy makers telling us that covid is over when it isn't (doi:10.1136/bmj.o1779, doi:10.1136/bmj-2021-069558).89 Or that it...
BMA Meeting: Doctors Call for Professional Regulation of Managers to Hold Them to Account

Nigel Hawkes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.f4138

2013-01-01

BMJ

Abstract:Managers in the NHS should be subject to a regime of professional regulation so that they can be held accountable for their actions and omissions, the BMA’s annual meeting voted today. In spite of doubts expressed by Mark Porter, chairman of council of the BMA, the annual representative meeting carried by a large majority a motion favouring such regulation, proposed by Peter Holden, a Derbyshire GP and member of council. Holden argued that the introduction of managers into the NHS—“most, if not all, without any instinctive, institutional corporate code of professional ethics and behaviour backed up by a formal professional disciplinary and registration regime”—had created a toxic working environment. “Not even in Communist China did they have managers overruling doctors in the operation of …
GP redundancies: sending the wrong message

Luke Read,Sangeetha Sornalingam,Maxwell Cooper

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q367

2024-02-14

BMJ

Abstract:News that 11 salaried GPs at a surgery in Surrey have been offered redundancy1 has sent shockwaves through medical students and junior doctors. Drivers for redundancy included "new ways of working" (patient demand for virtual appointments) and recruitment of additional roles reimbursement scheme (ARRS) practitioners such as physician associates, clinical pharmacists, and paramedics.23 These professionals are quicker to train and easier for surgeries to employ thanks to government funded reimbursement.3Redundancies undermine the status and value of GPs and risk reducing the quality of patient care. ARRS professionals receive significantly less clinical training than GPs and thrive where medicine is protocol driven and transactional—such as when consultations result in a prescription or referral. Without a proved increase in overall effectiveness (rather than just access), replacing GPs with ARRS practitioners is likely to increase tests, second opinions, referrals, and re-presentations. This will not serve patients with complex, psychosocial, or medically unexplained symptoms....

medicine, general & internal
Doctors are under attack from all sides, BMA chair tells annual meeting

Gareth Iacobucci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1402

2024-06-25

BMJ

Abstract:The medical profession is under attack financially, professionally, and morally, and must continue to fight to preserve itself, the BMA's chair of council has said.In a speech to the association's annual representative meeting in Belfast, Philip Banfield took aim at the government over industrial action, funding cuts, and the state of general practice. He also highlighted doctors' fears of speaking out about patient safety and announced a judicial review claim against the General Medical Council over the way it plans to regulate physician and anaesthesia associates, which the BMA says will lead to a dangerous blurring of lines for patients.Discussing the fractured relations between doctors and ministers, Banfield expressed his frustration that while consultants and specialist, associate specialist, and specialty (SAS) doctors in England have been able to secure pay deals, the dispute with junior doctors has now lasted 20 months without resolution. He said that calling an election does...

medicine, general & internal
Junior doctors' strike in South Korea: systemic barriers undermine medical practice

Hyunmi Park

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q752

2024-04-06

BMJ

Abstract:Dyer reports on the junior doctors striking in South Korea in response to plans to increase medical school places.1 The underlying deeper crisis—a shortage of doctors in lifesaving specialties2—is due not to a lack of willing professionals but to systemic barriers preventing effective medical practice.Doctors who work in lifesaving specialties face a tangible threat of criminal prosecution when patients' outcomes fail to meet the expectations of the patients' families. In 2020 a physician and her resident were detained over the death of an octogenarian patient with cancer who underwent standard treatment. They received suspended sentences despite the complexities of the case.3 The legal right to initiate lawsuits and the ensuing lengthy legal battles impose an immense burden on doctors who have dedicated themselves to patient care. South Korea sees over 700 criminal cases against doctors annually, a sharp contrast to the 1-2 in the United Kingdom.The burden of funding medical...

medicine, general & internal
Junior doctors offer prime minister "final chance" to avoid pre-election strike

Gareth Iacobucci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1367

2024-06-21

BMJ

Abstract:The BMA's Junior Doctors Committee in England has written to the prime minister, urging him to take a "final chance" to avert upcoming planned strikes by committing to a pay deal.Junior doctors in England are due to stage a five day walkout from 7 am on 27 June to 7 am on 2 July, ahead of the UK's general election on Thursday 4 July.In the letter sent to Rishi Sunak on 19 June the committee's co-chairs, Robert Laurenson and Vivek Trivedi, called on him to make a written commitment to a "detailed pathway" to pay restoration that could be implemented if he forms the next government.Their letter says, "This does not require you to break purdah and is entirely within your gift to take this bold action and give a clear plan for the future."Highlighting that more money has been spent on strikes than resolving the issue would have cost,...

medicine, general & internal
OHID: Cuts to disparities office could worsen health inequalities, doctors warn

Elisabeth Mahase

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q378

2024-02-14

BMJ

Abstract:Healthcare leaders are concerned that the restructuring of the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities (OHID), which partly replaced Public Health England in 2021, could slow down crucial work to tackle the country's worsening health inequalities.Large staffing cuts, the loss of senior members of staff, and the fragmentation of the organisation into three divisions were reported last week by the Health Service Journal,1 and the former Labour health minister Philip Hunt has said that OHID had "effectively been dismantled and certainly decimated." In response, a spokesperson for the Department of Health and Social Care said this was "categorically untrue" but confirmed that there had been a restructuring.Penelope Toff, chair of the BMA's public health medicine committee, said that there were "serious questions" over whether the changes would lead to a "scaling back of vital national public health leadership and functions." She said, "Public health funding in the UK has been...

medicine, general & internal
Junior doctors in England back six more months of strike action over pay

Elisabeth Mahase

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q717

2024-03-21

BMJ

Abstract:Junior doctors in England have overwhelmingly voted in favour (98%) of extending their mandate for industrial action over pay for another six months, meaning that they can now strike up to 19 September, the BMA has announced. The ballot also approved the use of action short of striking.Nearly 34 000 doctors (62%) voted in the ballot, around 10 000 fewer than last August's turnout of 43 440 (71.25%),1 although this is still well above the 50% minimum turnout needed for a mandate.In a statement the BMA Junior Doctors Committee co-chairs, Robert Laurenson and Vivek Trivedi, said, "The government should see the urgency of the situation. Rather than waste time dragging out talks, they can come forward with a credible offer on pay right now."Today's re-ballot shows that doctors understand that reversing this means being in the struggle for the long haul. We ask the health secretary to come forward as...

medicine, general & internal
Mix of relief and disappointment—striking a balance in the pay deal for resident doctors in England

Nikki Nabavi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2116

2024-09-28

BMJ

Abstract:On 16 September 2024, the BMA announced that its members had voted to accept the pay deal offered by the government for resident (previously known as "junior") doctors. As a newly qualified doctor who started working less than two months ago, I have had much of my studying and training affected by industrial action and the covid-19 pandemic. Despite being among the cohort of doctors who have not taken part in any official strikes, as none were scheduled during our first months working, my time on clinical placements was continuously coloured by the pay dispute and declining morale.The pay offer was announced during my induction week—a mixed wave of relief and disappointment ran through the lecture theatre as we all collected our first "Dr" ID badges and met our new colleagues. It was immediately clear that the proposed deal was divisive. Two years ago, resident doctors were balloted for a...

medicine, general & internal
Doctor who kept patients' unsecured medical records at home is struck off

Clare Dyer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2153

2024-10-02

BMJ

Abstract:A doctor who left the medical records of about 300 patients unsecured in a rented apartment when she moved out has been struck off the UK medical register.Documents found in the former home of Maryam Mohamed Al Qureshi in Southampton included records of abortions and overdoses and of psychiatric treatment, as well as patients' names, addresses, and birth dates. The documents, from eight different healthcare providers, covered dates from 1996 to 2013.Mohamed Al Qureshi, who was known as Victoria Pickles when she qualified from Leeds University in 2006 but changed her name in 2018, was already suspended after a 2022 medical practitioners tribunal found her culpable of failing to provide good clinical care when a patient called the NHS 111 hotline.That tribunal also found that she had failed to cooperate with a subsequent NHS inquiry and had made a dishonest statement during an appraisal. It suspended her for a year,...

medicine, general & internal

Hospital leaders warned that failure to recall striking doctors risked patient safety in some trusts, documents show

NHS England and trusts are undermining process for recalling striking doctors, says BMA

Junior doctors' strike: NHS England to gather information on service impact

Patient safety concerns were chief reason for strike suspension, says BMA

Strike escalation and seasonal pressures create perfect storm for the NHS

Steady undermining of the UK National Health Service underlies industrial action by doctors and other staff

Doctors' leaders welcome "long overdue" plans to regulate NHS managers

Northern Ireland: Junior doctors on picket line are at "breaking point"

Strike? – and what about clinical education?

Any NHS reform has to avoid a repeat of 2012

BMA enters dispute with NHS trust over plans to cut doctor overtime rates

Why The BMJ will no longer report on unsubstantiated press releases

BMA Meeting: Doctors Call for Professional Regulation of Managers to Hold Them to Account

GP redundancies: sending the wrong message

Doctors are under attack from all sides, BMA chair tells annual meeting

Junior doctors' strike in South Korea: systemic barriers undermine medical practice

Junior doctors offer prime minister "final chance" to avoid pre-election strike

OHID: Cuts to disparities office could worsen health inequalities, doctors warn

Junior doctors in England back six more months of strike action over pay

Mix of relief and disappointment—striking a balance in the pay deal for resident doctors in England

Doctor who kept patients' unsecured medical records at home is struck off