Abstract:Bears foraging near human developments are often presumed to be responding to food shortage, but this explanation ignores social factors, in particular despotism in bears. We analyzed the age distribution and body condition index (BCI) of shot brown bears in relation to densities of bears and people, and whether the shot bears were killed by managers (i.e., problem bears; n = 149), in self-defense (n = 51), or were hunter-killed nonproblem bears (n = 1,896) during 1990-2010. We compared patterns between areas with (Slovenia) and without supplemental feeding (Sweden) of bears relative to 2 hypotheses. The food-search/food-competition hypothesis predicts that problem bears should have a higher BCI (e.g., exploiting easily accessible and/or nutritious human-derived foods) or lower BCI (e.g., because of food shortage) than nonproblem bears, that BCI and human density should have a positive correlation, and problem bear occurrence and seasonal mean BCI of nonproblem bears should have a negative correlation (i.e., more problem bears during years of low food availability). Food competition among bears additionally predicts an inverse relationship between BCI and bear density. The safety-search/naivety hypothesis (i.e., avoiding other bears or lack of human experience) predicts no relationship between BCI and human density, provided no dietary differences due to spatiotemporal habitat use among bears, no relationship between problem bear occurrence and seasonal mean BCI of nonproblem bears, and does not necessarily predict a difference between BCI for problem/nonproblem bears. If food competition or predation avoidance explained bear occurrence near settlements, we predicted younger problem than nonproblem bears and a negative correlation between age and human density. However, if only food search explained bear occurrence near settlements, we predicted no relation between age and problem or nonproblem bear status, or between age and human density. We found no difference in BCI or its variability between problem and nonproblem bears, no relation between BCI and human density, and no correlation between numbers of problem bears shot and seasonal mean BCI for either country. The peak of shot problem bears occurred from April to June in Slovenia and in June in Sweden (i.e., during the mating period when most intraspecific predation occurs and before fall hyperphagia). Problem bears were younger than nonproblem bears, and both problem and nonproblem bears were younger in areas of higher human density. These age differences, in combination with similarities in BCI between problem and nonproblem bears and lack of correlation between BCI and human density, suggested safety-search and naïve dispersal to be the primary mechanisms responsible for bear occurrence near settlements. Younger bears are less competitive, more vulnerable to intraspecific predation, and lack human experience, compared to adults. Body condition was inversely related to the bear density index in Sweden, whereas we found no correlation in Slovenia, suggesting that supplemental feeding may have reduced food competition, in combination with high bear harvest rates. Bears shot in self-defense were older and their BCI did not differ from that of nonproblem bears. Reasons other than food shortage apparently explained why most bears were involved in encounters with people or viewed as problematic near settlements in our study.

Brown bear food habits in natural and human-modified landscapes in West-European Russia

Bears and berries: species-specific selective foraging on a patchily distributed food resource in a human-altered landscape

The selection by the Asiatic black bear (Ursus thibetanus) of spring plant food items according to their nutritional values

Does despotic behavior or food search explain the occurrence of problem brown bears in Europe?

Cozy den or winter walk: the effects of climate and supplementary feeding on brown bear winter behavior

Do ingredient and nutrient intake reveal individual dietary specialization in an omnivorous carnivore, the brown bear?

Dietary habits of Asiatic black bear in Bajaur Agency, Pakistan

Wolves foraging on berries is likely a widespread behavior in southern boreal ecosystems

Brown bear habitat use patterns across 19 years of population expansion in the Cantabrian Mountains

Hibernating or not hibernating? Brown bears' response to a mismatch between environmental natural cues and captive management, and its welfare implications

The seasonal sensitivity of brown bear denning phenology in response to climatic variability

The cascading effects of human food on hibernation and cellular aging in free-ranging black bears

Anthropogenic Neighborhood Impact on Bacterial and Fungal Communities in Polar Bear Feces

Behavioral activity of Ursus arctos brown bear in zoo conditions

Increased Stress in Asiatic Black Bears Relates to Food Limitation, Crop Raiding, and Foraging Beyond Nature Reserve Boundaries in China

Ancient DNA Reveals Maternal Philopatry of the Northeast Eurasian Brown Bear (Ursus arctos) Population during the Holocene

Implementing a comprehensive approach to study the causes of human-bear (Ursus arctos pruinosus) conflicts in the Sanjiangyuan region, China

To be browsed or not to be browsed: differences in nutritional characteristics of blackthorn subject to the long-term pressure of herbivores

Presence of gastrointestinal and bronchopulmonary parasites in Cantabrian brown bears

A Grazer in a Browser's Habitat: Resource Selection of Foraging Cattle in Productive Boreal Forest

Human footprint and forest disturbance reduce space use of brown bears across Europe.