Abstract:This paper joins the non-point source pollution regulation discussion and examines whether economic incentives provided by crop insurance subsidies alter fertilizer application decisions in the direction with environmental benefits. The model predicts that farmers regularly apply more fertilizer than optimal in a given year to take advantage of yield gains in the few years with favorable weather conditions, and that the long-term optimal fertilizer application level reduces with crop insurance, thus creating environmental externalities. Intuitively, farmers use “insurance application” of fertilizer at their own full expenses to achieve exceptional good yields and profits to make up for losses in bad years to sustain long-term profitability. With insurance covering the loss in very bad years, such incentive is reduced, resulting in a reduced the long-term optimal fertilizer level. Empirically, this study finds that a reduction in fertilizer use was achieved in the search of reducing systemic production risk in agriculture via crop insurance. An Instrumental variable (IV) approach was used taking advantage of the exogenous shocks on crop insurance enrollment induced by Federal Crop Insurance Reform Act (FCIRA) of 1994 and the differential response to the policy due to past extreme heat shocks. The study finds that counties in the Corn Belt where cropland is dominated by corn and soybean production showed an 18.5% decrease in commercial nitrogen (N) fertilizer use. No significant change in phosphorus (P) fertilizer application was found. The difference in behavior responses between N and P is expected and can be explained by the natural process of N and P in the soil and history of nutrients management in the Corn Belt. These findings suggest that public programs that alters economic incentives can have significant knock-on effects on agricultural non-point source pollution. Further, effective design of economic incentive programs in regulating agricultural NPS pollution should be rooted in understanding natural process of the pollutants in the ecosystem. More broadly, policy targeting the same population, regardless of the designed purpose of the programs, should be considered when predicting policy outcomes.

Command-Control Versus Market Incentive Policies for Non-point Source Pollution

Pollution Control Costs of A Transboundary River Basin: Empirical Tests of the Fairness and Stability of Cost Allocation Mechanisms Using Game Theory

Reversing Property Rights: Practice‐Based Approaches for Controlling Agricultural Nonpoint‐source Water Pollution When Emissions Aggregate Nonlinearly

The Relative Efficiency of Agricultural Source Water Pollution Control Policies

What Works for Agricultural Nonpoint Source Pollution Reduction? Evidence from the Corn Belt in the United States

The Regulatory Policy Design of Nonpoint Pollution from Agricultural Activities: Issues and Challenges in China

Spatially-Distributed Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Framework to Control Phosphorus from Agricultural Diffuse Pollution

Comparing price and nonprice approaches to urban water conservation

Modeling Nonpoint Source Pollution Control from the View of Game Theory

Knowledge Spillover and Positive Environmental Externality in Agricultural Decision Making under Performance-Based Payment Programs

Controlling non-point-source pollution by rural resource recycling. Nitrogen runoff in Tai Lake valley, China, as an example

Confronting our Agricultural Nonpoint Source Control Policy Problem

Tripartite evolutionary game and simulation analysis of agricultural non-point source pollution control

Too little or too much? Exploring the effectiveness of different policies in air pollution control from technical and non-technical pathways

A Method for Analyzing Pollution Control Policies: Application to SO2 Emissions in China

Spatial optimization of nutrient reduction measures on agricultural land to improve water quality: A coupled modeling approach

Cost-Sharing Mechanism of Water Pollution Control in Main and Subbasins Based on Stackelberg Game Model

The effectiveness of incomplete and overlapping pollution regulation: Evidence from bans on phosphate in automatic dishwasher detergent

Regional Non-point Source Pollution Control Method: A Design of Ecological Compensation Standards

Environmental Tax, Polluting Plants’ Strategies and Effectiveness: Evidence from China: The Effectiveness of an Environmental Tax

Cost Heterogeneity and the Potential Savings from Market-Based Policies