Abstract:As water becomes scarcer in northern China, designing policies that can induce water users to save water has become one of the most important tasks facing China's leader. Past water policies may not be a solution for the water scarcity problem in the long run. This paper looks at a new water policy: increasing water prices so as to provide water users with direct incentives to save water. Using a methodology that allows us to incorporate the resource constraints, we are able to recover the true price of water with a set of plot level data. Our results show that farmers are quite responsive if the correct price signal is used, unlike estimates of price elasticities that are based on traditional methods. Our estimation results show that water is severely under priced in our sample areas in China. As a result, water users are not likely to respond to increases in water prices. Thus as the first step to establishing an effective water pricing policy, policy makers must increase water price to the level of VMP so that water price reflects the true value of water, the correct price signal. Increases in water prices once they are set at the level of VMP, however, can lead to significant water savings. However, our analysis also shows that higher water prices also affect other aspects of the rural sector. Higher irrigation costs will lower the production of all crops, in general, and that of grain crops, in particular. Furthermore, when facing higher irrigation costs, households suffer income losses. Crop income distribution also worsens with increases in water prices. In summary, our paper provides both good news and bad news to policy makers. On the one hand, water pricing policies obviously have great potential for curbing demand and helping policy makers address the emerging water crisis. On the other hand, dealing with the negative production and income impacts of higher irrigation cost will pose a number of challenges to policy makers. In other words, if China's leaders plan to increase water prices to address the nation's water crisis, an integrated package of policies will be needed to achieve water savings without hurting rural incomes or national food security.

Comparing price and nonprice approaches to urban water conservation

Water Conservation: Theory and Evidence in Urban Areas of the Developed World

Combining price and non-price interventions for water conservation

The impact of pricing structure change on residential water consumption: A long-term analysis of water utilities in California

Price and Behavioural Signals to Encourage Household Water Conservation: Implications for the UK

The Environmental Effects Of Water Pricing Policy In China

The cost of alternative urban water supply and efficiency options in California

The Impact of Water Pricing Policy on Local Environment - an Analysis of Three Irrigation Districts in China

Research on Water Price and Quantity to Meet the Basic Living Needs of Urban Residents Based on Water Conservation

Command-Control Versus Market Incentive Policies for Non-point Source Pollution

Is less always more? Conservation, efficiency and water education programs

Options for the Procurement of Environmental Water Rights-Market Allocation or Government Regulation?

Do Announcement and Implementation of Prices and Subsidies Differentially Affect Water Consumption

What Causes Heterogeneous Responses to Social Comparison Messages for Water Conservation?

Irrigation Water-Pricing Policy

Exploring price effects on the residential water conservation technology diffusion process: a case study of Tianjin city

Pricing Policies in Managing Water Resources in Agriculture: An Application of Contract Theory to Unmetered Water

Multiple Goals Dilemma of Residential Water Pricing Policy Reform: Increasing Block Tariffs or a Uniform Tariff with Rebate?

Irrigation Water Pricing Policy in China

Irrigation Water Demand and Implications for Water Pricing Policy in Rural China

The Effects of Policy Announcement, Prices and Subsidies on Water Consumption