Superconductivity from collective excitations in magic angle twisted bilayer graphene

Gargee Sharma,Maxim Trushin,Oleg P. Sushkov,Giovanni Vignale,Shaffique Adam

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.2.022040

2019-09-06

Abstract:A purely electronic mechanism is proposed for the unconventional superconductivity recently observed in twisted bilayer graphene (tBG) close to the magic angle. Using the Migdal-Eliashberg framework on a one parameter effective lattice model for tBG we show that a superconducting state can be achieved by means of collective electronic modes in tBG. We posit robust features of the theory, including an asymmetrical superconducting dome and the magnitude of the critical temperature that are in agreement with experiments.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: to explain the unconventional superconducting phenomena observed in magic - angle twisted bilayer graphene (tBG). Specifically, the authors proposed a pure - electron mechanism to explain this superconductivity, and through the Migdal - Eliashberg framework and an effective single - parameter lattice model, showed how collective electron excitation modes lead to the superconducting state in tBG.

### Main problems:
1. **Explaining unconventional superconductivity**: In tBG near the magic angle, superconductivity and insulating phases have been experimentally observed. The traditional BCS theory (Bardeen - Cooper - Schrieffer theory) mainly relies on electron - phonon coupling to explain superconductivity, but the superconductivity here may not be caused by this mechanism.
2. **Exploring new superconducting mechanisms**: The authors put forward a hypothesis that collective electron excitations (such as plasmons) can act as pairing mediators to form a superconducting state. This mechanism is different from the traditional BCS mechanism because it does not require phonon participation.

### Key contributions of the paper:
- **Theoretical model**: Using the Migdal - Eliashberg framework and an effective single - parameter lattice model, the dynamic polarization function and the dynamic screened Coulomb interaction in tBG were studied.
- **Prediction consistent with experiments**: The theory predicted an asymmetric superconducting dome and the order of magnitude of the critical temperature, and these results are in line with the experimental data.
- **Emphasizing the importance of electron interactions**: Pointed out the crucial role of strong electron interactions (such as Coulomb interactions and plasmon effects) in the superconductivity in tBG.

### Formula presentation:
- **Dynamic polarization function**:
\[
\Pi(q,i\omega) = 4 \sum_{k} \sum_{m,n} (f^n_{k + q}- f^m_k) F^{nm}_{k,k + q}\frac{E^n_{k + q}- E^m_k}{E^n_{k + q}- E^m_k - i\omega}
\]
where \( f^n_k \) is the Fermi - Dirac distribution, and \( F^{nm}_{k,k + q}=|\psi^\dagger_{n,k + q}\psi_{m,k}|^2 \) is the chiral factor of graphene.

- **Critical temperature formula**:
\[
r_s^2 T_c \arctan\left(\frac{E_F}{\omega_M}\right)\left[\frac{4r_s}{\pi}\arctan\left(\frac{E_F}{\pi T_c}\right)- 1\right]=1
\]

### Summary:
This paper aims to reveal a new mechanism for unconventional superconductivity in magic - angle twisted bilayer graphene, especially to explain superconducting pairing through collective electron excitations (such as plasmons). This mechanism not only provides a new perspective for understanding the superconductivity in tBG, but also points out the direction for future research.