Abstract:We perform systematic density functional theory (DFT) calculations to assess the performance of various exchange-correlation potentials $V_{xc}$ in describing the chalcogenide GaM$_4$Q$_8$ lacunar spinels (M=Mo, V, Nb, Ta; Q=S, Se). We examine the dependency of crystal structure (in cubic and rhombohedral symmetries), electronic structure, magnetism, optical conductivity, and lattice dynamics in lacunar spinels at four different levels of $V_{xc}$: the local density approximation (LDA), generalized gradient approximation (GGA), meta-GGA, and hybrid with fractional Fock exchange. We find that LDA significantly underperforms GGA and higher level functionals in predicting lattice constants. LDA also fails to properly describe the magnetism in the family, and for some compositions it does not find the ground state distorted crystal structure. The Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) and PBE revised for solids (PBEsol) GGA functionals perform reasonably well in predicting lattice constants as well as the electronic structures. We find that the GGA with an on-site Coulomb interaction (GGA$+U$) is unnecessary to produce a semiconducting state in the distorted polar $R3m$ phase. Plus Hubbard $U$ values ranging from 1$\sim$2 eV, however, improve the quantitative performance of the GGA functionals. The meta-GGA functional SCAN predicts reasonable lattice constants and electronic structures; it exhibits behavior similar to the GGA$+U$ functionals for small $U$ values. The hybrid functional HSE06 is accurate in predicting the lattice constants, but leads to a band gap of $\approx$1 eV in the rhombohedral phase, which is higher than the experimental estimation of 0.2 eV. Our findings suggest that accurate qualitative and quantitative simulations of the lacunar spinel family with DFT requires careful attention to the nuances of the exchange-correlation functional and considered spin structures.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the performance of different exchange - correlation functionals in describing chalcogenide lacunar spinels GaM₄Q₈ (M = Mo, V, Nb, Ta; Q = S, Se). Specifically, the research aims to explore the dependence of the crystal structure, electronic structure, magnetism, optical conductivity and lattice dynamics of these materials on different levels of exchange - correlation potential (Vₓc). ### Main problems 1. **Crystal structure**: Study the crystal structure prediction ability of different functionals under cubic and trigonal symmetries. 2. **Electronic structure**: Evaluate the description ability of different functionals for the electronic structure, including band structure and density of states. 3. **Magnetism**: Analyze the influence of different functionals on the magnetism of materials, especially ferromagnetic and spin - polarized states. 4. **Optical conductivity**: Examine the prediction accuracy of different functionals for optical properties. 5. **Lattice dynamics**: Evaluate the prediction ability of different functionals for lattice vibration modes. ### Research background The chalcogenide lacunar spinel family GaM₄Q₈ has attracted wide attention due to its unique physical properties, such as metal - insulator transition, the ability to host skyrmion lattices, and multiferroicity. However, the understanding of electron correlation effects and structural distortions in these materials is still insufficient. In particular, the choice of theoretical method is crucial when describing multiple electronic states of these materials. ### Solutions To evaluate the performance of different functionals, the author uses the following four different levels of exchange - correlation functionals: - Local density approximation (LDA) - Generalized gradient approximation (GGA), including PBE and PBEsol functionals - Meta - generalized gradient approximation (meta - GGA), such as SCAN functional - Hybrid functionals, such as HSE06 By systematically comparing the performance of these functionals in describing material properties, the author hopes to find the first - principles DFT simulation method most suitable for describing the chalcogenide lacunar spinel family, and points out the possible compromises that need to be made in different properties to promote future research and prediction. ### Conclusions The research finds that GGA and higher - level Vₓc functionals are superior to LDA in predicting most properties. In particular, the GGA functional combined with local Coulomb interaction (GGA+U) can significantly improve the quantitative prediction of the electronic structure. Spin - orbit coupling (SOC) can break orbital degeneracy in the cubic phase, making the half - metal phase appear. The SCAN and HSE06 functionals can accurately predict lattice parameters, but the band gap caused by HSE06 is larger than the experimental estimate. Therefore, choosing the appropriate exchange - correlation functional is crucial for accurately simulating the physical properties of the chalcogenide lacunar spinel family. ### Summary This paper provides an important basis for understanding the structure - property relationship of the chalcogenide lacunar spinel family through the systematic evaluation of different exchange - correlation functionals, and emphasizes the details that need to be considered when choosing functionals. This will help to more accurately simulate and predict the complex behavior of these materials in the future.

Assessing exchange-correlation functional performance in the chalcogenide lacunar spinels GaM$_4$Q$_8$ (M = Mo, V, Nb, Ta; Q = S, Se)

Rare-Earth Chalcogenides: A Large Family of Triangular Lattice Spin Liquid Candidates

Assessing exchange-correlation functional performance for structure and property predictions of oxyfluoride compounds from first principles

Influence of the Exchange-Correlation Potential and Magnetic Properties on the Li2FeSiO4 Cathode Materials

Assessing the accurate exchange-correlation functional in van der Waals TMD Materials AB2 (A = Nb, Ta and B = S, Se, Te)

Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions, Néel skyrmions and V$_4$ magnetic clusters in multiferroic lacunar spinel GaV$_4$S$_8$

Performance of Exchange-Correlation Approximations to Density-Functional Theory for Rare-earth Oxides

Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions, Néel skyrmions and V 4 magnetic clusters in multiferroic lacunar spinel GaV 4 S 8

Comparing first-principles density functionals plus corrections for the lattice dynamics of YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_6$

Pitfalls of Exchange-Correlation Functionals in Descriptions of Magnetism: Cautionary Tale of the FeRh Alloy

Hierarchy of Exchange-Correlation Functionals in Computing Lattice Thermal Conductivities of Rocksalt and Zincblende Semiconductors

Comparing first-principles density functionals plus corrections for the lattice dynamics of YBa2Cu3O6

Resonating holes vs molecular spin-orbit coupled states in group-5 lacunar spinels

Molecular Mott state in the deficient spinel GaV$_4$S$_8$

Structural Characterization and Functional Assessment of Exchange-Correlation Functionals in van der Waals TMDs AB2 (A = Mo, W; B = S, Se, Te)

Evaluation performance to assess accurate exchange-correlation functional in van der Waals TMD Materials AB2 (A = Mo, W and B = S, Se and Te)

Spin-state Gaps and Self-Interaction-Corrected Density Functional Approximations: Octahedral Fe(II) Complexes as Case Study

Assessing r2SCAN meta-GGA functional for structural parameters, cohesive energy, mechanical modulus and thermophysical properties of 3d, 4d and 5d transition metals

Prediction of Li intercalation voltages in rechargeable battery cathode materials: effects of exchange-correlation functional, van der Waals interactions, and Hubbard $U$

Accuracy of metaGGA functionals in describing transition metal fluorides

Magnetic phase transitions and spin density distribution in the molecular multiferroic system GaV 4 S 8