Abstract:Solar radiation modification has been suggested as a backup option to reduce anthropogenic warming. Marine cloud brightening (MCB) and ocean albedo modification (OAM) are two proposed approaches to intentionally reflect sunlight back to space over oceanic regions. Using the NCAR Community Earth System Model, we compare climate response to MCB and OAM under the framework of fast adjustment and slow feedback. We implement MCB and OAM uniformly over the global ocean to offset CO2-induced warming. We find that to offset 3.3 K global mean warming from a doubling of CO2, diagnosed effective radiative forcing is -4.8 and -3.6 W m(-2) for OAM and MCB, respectively. Correspondingly, radiative forcing efficacy of OAM is about 70% of MCB. Fast climate adjustment differs in response to MCB and OAM forcing. MCB cools the lower atmosphere by reflecting sunlight from cloud, causing a reduction in sunlight absorption in the atmosphere. In contrast, OAM, by reflecting more sunlight from surface, increases shortwave heating of the lower atmosphere, leading to a decrease in low marine clouds and hence a positive cloudy-sky shortwave forcing that partly compensates the negative clear-sky shortwave forcing. The slow climate response and pattern of equilibrium climate change are similar between MCB and OAM. As for hydrological cycle, relative to the climate under a doubling of CO2, both MCB and OAM produce an increase in precipitation and runoff over tropical land. Plain Language Summary To counteract anthropogenic CO2-induced global warming, various climate intervention approaches have been proposed. Among them, two approaches intend to reflect more sunlight back to space over ocean. One is marine cloud brightening that involves enhancement of marine cloud albedo. The other is ocean albedo modification that involves enhancement of ocean surface albedo. This study uses an Earth system model to compare climate response to these two climate intervention approaches. In our simulations, both approaches are designed to offset global mean surface warming caused by a doubling of atmospheric CO2. For the same amount of global cooling, ocean albedo modification produces a much stronger negative radiative forcing, implying that the forcing efficacy is smaller than that of marine cloud brightening. Under fixed sea surface temperature, fast climate adjustments, including changes in cloud and precipitation, differ substantially between these two approaches. This is mainly because ocean albedo modification reflects more sunlight from ocean surface, heating the lower atmosphere, but marine cloud brightening reflects more sunlight from cloud, cooling the lower atmosphere. When the climate system reaches a new equilibrium state after the adjustment of the atmosphere and upper ocean, these two approaches produce similar pattern of climate change.

Sea-going hardware for the cloud albedo method of reversing global warming

Albedo Enhancement of Marine Clouds to Counteract Global Warming: Impacts on the Hydrological Cycle

Efficient Water Transport and Solar Steam Generation Via Radially, Hierarchically Structured Aerogels

Marine-cloud brightening: an airborne concept

High‐performance and Wide Relative Humidity Passive Evaporative Cooling Utilizing Atmospheric Water

Increasing the Earth's Albedo: The Köhler Equation at Sea

Climate More Responsive to Marine Cloud Brightening Than Ocean Albedo Modification: A Model Study

Lubricated Surface in a Vertical Double-Sided Architecture for Radiative Cooling and Atmospheric Water Harvesting

Substantial cooling effect from aerosol-induced increase in tropical marine cloud cover

Note for COP26 on Marine Cloud Brightening

Evaluating rainbowing for ocean alkalinity enhancement

Desalination of seawater by spray freezing in a natural draft tower

The efficacy of aerosol–cloud radiative perturbations from near-surface emissions in deep open-cell stratocumuli

Physical science research needed to evaluate the viability and risks of marine cloud brightening

An ocean thermocline desalination system using the direct spray method

Water Skin Effect and Arched Double‐Sided Evaporation for Boosting All‐Weather High Salinity Desalination

Evaporation mitigation using floating modular devices

Reversing heat conduction loss: Extracting energy from bulk water to enhance solar steam generation

Use of aircraft in ocean alkalinity enhancement

Testing the climate intervention potential of ocean afforestation using the Great Atlantic Sargassum Belt

Stratospheric Albedo Modification by Aerosol Injection